Floyd Mayweather Versus

[ThatOne]

In light of the Pretty Boy's destruction of Sugar Shane Mosley in a fight where he abandoned his safety first posture and pretty much stood toe to toe how does he fare against these other great welterweights?*

Sugar Ray Leonard

Tommy Hearns

Roberto Duran

Wilfredo Benitez

Ayub Kalule





* I realize they all didn't spend their entire career there.

[Darling]

Mouth-watering fights.

[Diamond WEAPON]

Floyd stops them all within 30 seconds... Advanced nutrition/training methods/evolution and all that.

Next...

[Goodnight, Irene]

Beats Kalule. Loses to the rest.

[Shazam!]

No blueprint baby.

[hub city boxing]

bets them all easy but sugar ray he wins a close fight with him

[NazNaci1]

Beats Kalule. Loses to the rest.

x2

[tanibanana]

how does he fare against these other great welterweights?

Sugar Ray Leonard

Tommy Hearns

Roberto Duran

Wilfredo Benitez

Ayub Kalule

beats Kalule, Benitez
close fight w/ Duran
Loses to Hearns & Leonard

[dempseyfire]

He beats Kayule in a tough fight.

Benitez is 50/50

Loses to the rest, is BLUDGEONED by Hearns within 3 rounds.

[jezzamundo]

Sugar Ray Leonard UD15 Floyd Mayweather - close but clear decision

Tommy Hearns TKO4 Floyd Mayweather - can't see Floyd winning this one, Hearns is offensively brilliant and so powerful

Roberto Duran UD15 Floyd Mayweather - another close but clear decision, Mayweather wins via split decision in rematch

Floyd Mayweather UD15 Wilfredo Benitez - close decision

Floyd Mayweather UD15 Ayub Kalule

[Shazam!]

To all those stating that Hearns would KO Mayweather. Do you believe that Floyd's speed and defense is that inferior to Sugar Ray Leonard's?

[The Great John L]

He beats Kayule in a tough fight.

Benitez is 50/50

Loses to the rest, is BLUDGEONED by Hearns within 3 rounds.

That sounds about right, but I think he would have given Duran quite a few problems as well.

[Shazam!]

To all those stating that Hearns would KO Mayweather. Do you believe that Floyd's speed and defense is that inferior to Sugar Ray Leonard's?

I don't think his speed or defence is any less than Leonards, but his chin can't stand up to Hearns, surely you can't think it would? He would get hit at least once.

Well, yeah I'd favour a Hearns KO thinking about it. Mayweather is tiny in comparison. He'd have to run and run for the first few rounds! But he knows all the tricks and if Hearns over committed he'd catch him coming in. If he got past the first few rounds he'd stand even more of a chance. As I said, I'd favour Hearns, but Mayweather is such a crafty customer I don't see it as a foregone conclusion at all.

[Bricks]

In light of the Pretty Boy's destruction of Sugar Shane Mosley in a fight where he abandoned his safety first posture and pretty much stood toe to toe how does he fare against these other great welterweights?*

Sugar Ray Leonard

Tommy Hearns

Roberto Duran

Wilfredo Benitez

Ayub Kalule





* I realize they all didn't spend their entire career there.

Hindsight is a great thing. But its fair to say from the way Mosley became old in the second round after he couldnt take mayweather out that the long inactivity had got to shane.

based on floyds prime against their respective primes.

Sugar Ray Leonard- SRL at 147 does everything Flloyd does but much better and faster and in an entertaining way. SRL stops him in 12.

Tommy Hearns - Flloyd has his hands up real good and likes to counter. But the Motor City cobra could bust a man to the body like no one except maybe Mike mccallum. One sided 15 round demolition and PBF is ruined a near shutout. Hearns dances and lets Flooyd follow him. When your 6ft 2 and long armed you dont need to go looking for someone from their chest. U can do it at distance.I simply cannot see Tommy losing to PBF. PBF isnt the great finisher ray leonard was.

Roberto Duran- The duran who beat SRL (ie in condition and not suffering cramps or complacent) wins. PBF cannot move like leonard did. And duran handled a great counter puncher lke hagler so flloyd wont be too problematic. 15 round points decision to Duran.

Wilfredo Benitez- Mayweather outpoints wilfred in a defensive technical match over 15 rounds

Ayub Kalule- PBF stops him in 7.

[gambler49]

Sugar Ray Leonard WINS MD

Tommy Hearns WINS KO 6 (NO WAY TH CAN LOSE)

Roberto Duran WINS TKO 11

Wilfredo Benitez LOSES SD

Ayub Kalule LOSED UD

[IKSRTFO]

To all those stating that Hearns would KO Mayweather. Do you believe that Floyd's speed and defense is that inferior to Sugar Ray Leonard's?

No but I'm sure Hearns hits a hell of a lot harder than Mosley and if it were Hearns in the 2nd round of that fight landing that same right, Floyd would do more tha just buckle.

[Grimm]

While Floyd may have it rough and lose against most of these, I don't see him being knocked out.

I think he proved to have an awesome chin by being able to stand up to a huge flush shot from Mosley. On top of that he's a defensive fighter.

I think Hearns would likely win especially over 12 rounds.

A Leonard vs Mayweather fight would be harsh on the eyes, I would still go with Leonard though.

I actually give the advantage to Mayweather against Duran. Mayweather's plan would be to box and move he wouldn't stand in there with him like Leonard did in the first fight.

The Benitez fight could be very ugly no matter the decision there would be no clear winner.

I think Mayweather boxes his way to a UD against Kalule.

[jezzamundo]

To all those stating that Hearns would KO Mayweather. Do you believe that Floyd's speed and defense is that inferior to Sugar Ray Leonard's?

I'd say Floyd is a shade slower than Leonard, but not to the extent that it would make a difference in this fight and I would rate his defense as better than Leonard's. However, he is considerably less powerful than Leonard, meaning Hearns could be more offensively minded in this matchup. Taking into account the huge size, power and reach advantages - I can't see Floyd winning this more than once out of 10.

[AZOSI]

Beats Benitez and Kalule

Duran is too close to call for me.

Hearns is a matchup nightmare for Floyd. Floyd doesn't hit hard enough to bother Hearns and Hearns was a bomber.

Leonard wins a boring close decision. Something like 116-112 in a 12 rounder.

[Bricks]

To all those stating that Hearns would KO Mayweather. Do you believe that Floyd's speed and defense is that inferior to Sugar Ray Leonard's?

No but that isnt the point. The point is hearns handspeed on those long jabs and straights is just as fast if not faster than SRL. Sure ray had faster hooks but imo the hit man had astonishing velocity on those jabs and straight rights.

Plus Hearns was a great counter puncher as well. We're talking about a prime tommy at 147.

I have given PBF the benefit of the doubt in that his chin and skill would help him survive 15 but he would take a shellacking.

[Diamond WEAPON]

An interesting point to ponder is how much Leonard and Hearns would drain down in an actual fight with Mayweather, being that both were naturally bigger. Floyd is plateauing in weight in the mid-150s, Leonard was over 160 and Hearns was eventually a LHW while still fairly effective.

Regardless though Mayweather loses to Duran, Leonard, and Hearns, and beats Kayule and Benitez.

[Grimm]

An interesting point to ponder is how much Leonard and Hearns would drain down in an actual fight with Mayweather, being that both were naturally bigger. Floyd is plateauing in weight in the mid-150s, Leonard was over 160 and Hearns was eventually a LHW while still fairly effective.

Regardless though Mayweather loses to Duran, Leonard, and Hearns, and beats Kayule and Benitez.

Same day weigh in kind of evens it out.

[IKSRTFO]

While Floyd may have it rough and lose against most of these, I don't see him being knocked out.

I think he proved to have an awesome chin by being able to stand up to a huge flush shot from Mosley. On top of that he's a defensive fighter.

I think Hearns would likely win especially over 12 rounds.

A Leonard vs Mayweather fight would be harsh on the eyes, I would still go with Leonard though.

I actually give the advantage to Mayweather against Duran. Mayweather's plan would be to box and move he wouldn't stand in there with him like Leonard did in the first fight.

The Benitez fight could be very ugly no matter the decision there would be no clear winner.

I think Mayweather boxes his way to a UD against Kalule.

The Shane fight IMO says that Hearns would easily KO him. Floyd wouldn't see those bombs coming like he did with Shane. Hearns was faster stronger, bigger, and a better boxer than Shane. The only advantage Shane has over Hearns is a chin giving Mayweather a punchers chance which isn't alot. Hearns is hands down probably top 3 hardest punchers at Welter EVER. For me to believe Mayweather would've stood up to those shots, he would've took Shane's flush shots like he was Marvin Hagler. Just a bad nightmarish matchup for Floyd and anyone else not named Hagler or Leonard, two very big welters.

[Grimm]

While Floyd may have it rough and lose against most of these, I don't see him being knocked out.

I think he proved to have an awesome chin by being able to stand up to a huge flush shot from Mosley. On top of that he's a defensive fighter.

I think Hearns would likely win especially over 12 rounds.

A Leonard vs Mayweather fight would be harsh on the eyes, I would still go with Leonard though.

I actually give the advantage to Mayweather against Duran. Mayweather's plan would be to box and move he wouldn't stand in there with him like Leonard did in the first fight.

The Benitez fight could be very ugly no matter the decision there would be no clear winner.

I think Mayweather boxes his way to a UD against Kalule.

The Shane fight IMO says that Hearns would easily KO him. Floyd wouldn't see those bombs coming like he did with Shane. Hearns was faster stronger, bigger, and a better boxer than Shane. The only advantage Shane has over Hearns is a chin giving Mayweather a punchers chance which isn't alot. Hearns is hands down probably top 3 hardest punchers at Welter EVER. For me to believe Mayweather would've stood up to those shots, he would've took Shane's flush shots like he was Marvin Hagler. Just a bad nightmarish matchup for Floyd and anyone else not named Hagler or Leonard, two very big welters.

I don't think Floyd would come in with that same game plan.

The advantage Floyd does hold over Hearns is thinking. Like I said though I still think Hearns beats him.

[jezzamundo]

The Shane fight IMO says that Hearns would easily KO him. Floyd wouldn't see those bombs coming like he did with Shane. Hearns was faster stronger, bigger, and a better boxer than Shane. The only advantage Shane has over Hearns is a chin giving Mayweather a punchers chance which isn't alot. Hearns is hands down probably top 3 hardest punchers at Welter EVER. For me to believe Mayweather would've stood up to those shots, he would've took Shane's flush shots like he was Marvin Hagler. Just a bad nightmarish matchup for Floyd and anyone else not named Hagler or Leonard, two very big welters.

Hagler was never a welterweight, only ever a middeweight. Over his whole career his weight was always in the 155lb-163lb range. When he fought Hearns it was at middleweight.