Kelvin hall (spoilers)

[Rixxy]

liam smith and perry carrutiters both scored 38 and so drawn.

[JCB123]

Draw???

Is that the 1st fight???

[TerribleTerry]

Well done Carruthers - he is better than his record and it looks like he has shown it in Scotland tonight

[ThereByTheGrace]

Keep up the good work with the spoilers - looking forward to Rocky's victory party!

[JCB123]

Anyone who is there, was it a draw or was it a contentious decision???

[Tommy Gunn13]

bit of a shock that one...

[Tommy Gunn13]

Anyone who is there, was it a draw or was it a contentious decision???

Carruthers is a brummie i think,so cant be hometown decison..

[TerribleTerry]

Anyone who is there, was it a draw or was it a contentious decision???

Carruthers is a brummie i think,so cant be hometown decison..

Nope, no 'home towner' in this one: also nice to see the ref didn't read the script and automatically raise the hand of the prospect - Scottish refs have come in for some stick for their score cards on dinner shows in recent years - I would hope that FW will put this fight up on youtube so we can see it for ourselves?...

[JCB123]

I was thinkin along the lines of was it actually a "draw" or could have the prospect maybe have lost??

Either way it's all experience

[TerribleTerry]

I was thinkin along the lines of was it actually a "draw" or could have the prospect maybe have lost??

Either way it's all experience

True - someone was saying that FW's website had it down as a Carruthers win though?

Can anyone confirm was it a draw or a win for Carruthers?

[ThereByTheGrace]

I heard that Arthur beat McDonagh - not sure how though

[jonp]

definate draw,terry has been training realy hard,sparring with some good lads he might give brian rose a tussle now

[dondada]

Keep up the good work with the spoilers - looking forward to Rocky's victory party!

Erm, table for one, please?

[15829]

was a draw thought liam on the 1st an last lost the second and just edged the 3rd so i thought he won but cant argue to much it was a draw

[Alba]

john thain ?how did he get on

[Gazmac81]

Table for ???????????

Keep up the good work with the spoilers - looking forward to Rocky's victory party!

Erm, table for one, please?

[slapbangwhallop]

john thain ?how did he get on

unless he came on after the Burns fight then I missed that one.

McDonagh made Arthur work every road and I had Arthur one round up going into the last. Wouldnt have whinged if it was a draw but I scored it 77-75 to Arthur.

Liam Smith looked shockingly open and easy to hit last. If he had been called the loser in that fight you would have had no argument - although he would have argued. Plenty of chat in the ring from the pair and it was a very scrappy affair.

Stephen Ormond looked an exciting acquisition for allegedly and almost had Greaves out of there.

[kerrminator]

I was there and a draw was a fair conclusion. It was a hell of a scrap and the young perry fella (think thats his name anyway) certainly wasnt there to just make up the numbers. Great wee scrap

[kerrminator]

john thain ?how did he get on

Dont think he fought, he was sheduled for between Simpson and Burns bouts (perhaps to give Billy time to go from one fighter to the other ) but it never happened, I never even went for a pish so I didnt miss it. I was looking forward to seeing him too coz both Appleby and Arther claim he's worth the watching.

next time hopefully :)

[hurlock]

what was the scoring on arthur v mcdonagh???

[slapbangwhallop]

what was the scoring on arthur v mcdonagh???

79-74

[bigped]

john thain ?how did he get on

Dont think he fought, he was sheduled for between Simpson and Burns bouts (perhaps to give Billy time to go from one fighter to the other ) but it never happened, I never even went for a pish so I didnt miss it. I was looking forward to seeing him too coz both Appleby and Arther claim he's worth the watching.

next time hopefully :)

John thain got the win, must have been hard going in the ring right after that burns fight but he went in and done the job.

[sgtcecil]

liam smith was very easy to catch imo, I scored it 39-39. draw was a fair result and all credit to carruthers, he came to fight and deserved the draw.

Appleby looked good in his return. Expected it to be a quick blow out and the body shots were devastating (although the opponent is hardly world class!)!

Arthur did what was expected - as usual the connemara kid is not a fighter you look good against and he also caught arthur once or twice. I'd have AAA as an underdog just now if he was to fight murray or rees. Also find it worrying that he was still 4lb away from the lightweight limit last night - will lightweight be a struggle for him?

Ormond looked good and greaves played the panto villain well as ever!

Didn't stay to watch thain