Captain Hook wrote:All I said is that Khan flattened Earl and I didn't believe Earl was "shot" at the time... I take your points on board and respect your opinion, so kindly respect mine.
You clearly did say more than that as it's there above us in black and white and my posts were clearly a response to what you were saying rather than thinking, but in keeping with the reconciliatory line above I'd prefer to wrap it up as well
Anyway, for what it's worth - Earl aside - I'd agree with the overall view that Khan can bang, but is not a concussive puncher. He's a lot like Bradley in that respect.
I believe Bradley is the only (realistic) opponent at the weight who would beat him.
Captain Hook wrote:We can carry it on if you want you slaaaag :)
Anyway, for what it's worth - Earl aside - I'd agree with the overall view that Khan can bang, but is not a concussive puncher. He's a lot like Bradley in that respect.
I believe Bradley is the only (realistic) opponent at the weight who would beat him.
Deserter wrote:I think Khan will comfortably outbox Maidana when they meet, but I was astonished by this quote in the latest press conference:
"He is known as a big puncher but I really think I am a bigger puncher. Although I am best known for my speed, ask my past opponents about my power.”
I really do wonder what he's talking about at times - first there were the claims of how Pacman couldn't put him down despite his 'best' efforts, and now this...
In one respect he is right he certainly has the resources to be a big puncher.....but like you i agree he shouldnt talk like he is the finished article....its just he hasnt used those resources properly up to now even tho he is a pro for 5 years now and not a "kid" anymore.......Khan doesnt really plant his feet enough to punch he prefers to go for speed and a high work rate....... he should make the step up to now thinking a bit more not being so dumb in the ring as he has shown some times, he should start planting his feet more at specific times in a fight, learn to pace himself and take a breather ,putting his full power in single shots when he sees the opening....all the greats like SRL could do this....SR was a fine great great technician and boxer but man he could take guys out with single shots when he needed it.......NAZ was also adept at this at a lesser level.....and its something Khan really needs to do rather than talking otherwise its a waste of his resources. I felt he could and should have taken out Malignaggi earlier like this.
He needs to plant a Bradley or Maidana out with a single shot the way Nunn took out Kalambay to really show people that dimension in him....instead of talking like he got it made already
Deserter wrote:I think Khan will comfortably outbox Maidana when they meet, but I was astonished by this quote in the latest press conference:
"He is known as a big puncher but I really think I am a bigger puncher. Although I am best known for my speed, ask my past opponents about my power.”
I really do wonder what he's talking about at times - first there were the claims of how Pacman couldn't put him down despite his 'best' efforts, and now this...
Well if you consider it fully, you will probably realise he is right he certainly has the resources to a big puncher.....but like you i agree he shouldnt talk like he is the finished article....its just he hasnt used them properly up to now even tho he is a pro for 5 years now.......Khan doesnt really plant his feet to punch he prefers to go for speed and a high work rate....... he should make the step up to now thinking a bit more not being so dumb in the ring as he has shown man times, he should start planting his feet more at specific times in a fight and putting his full power in single shots when he sees the opening...........NAZ was adept at this.....and its something Khan really needs to do otherwise its a waste of his resources. I felt he could and should have taken out Malignaggi earlier like this.
He needs to plant a Bradley or Maidana out with a single shot the way Nunn took out Kalambay to really show people that dimension in him....instead of talking like he got it made already
He cant really afford to do that though as if he he plants his feet then he's static which makes him an easier target to hit and thus potentially knock out with his suspect chin!
Deserter wrote:I think Khan will comfortably outbox Maidana when they meet, but I was astonished by this quote in the latest press conference:
"He is known as a big puncher but I really think I am a bigger puncher. Although I am best known for my speed, ask my past opponents about my power.”
I really do wonder what he's talking about at times - first there were the claims of how Pacman couldn't put him down despite his 'best' efforts, and now this...
Well if you consider it fully, you will probably realise he is right he certainly has the resources to a big puncher.....but like you i agree he shouldnt talk like he is the finished article....its just he hasnt used them properly up to now even tho he is a pro for 5 years now.......Khan doesnt really plant his feet to punch he prefers to go for speed and a high work rate....... he should make the step up to now thinking a bit more not being so dumb in the ring as he has shown man times, he should start planting his feet more at specific times in a fight and putting his full power in single shots when he sees the opening...........NAZ was adept at this.....and its something Khan really needs to do otherwise its a waste of his resources. I felt he could and should have taken out Malignaggi earlier like this.
He needs to plant a Bradley or Maidana out with a single shot the way Nunn took out Kalambay to really show people that dimension in him....instead of talking like he got it made already
Yep, some really good points there. Don't you think the Nunn punch was a bit of fluke though given that it didn't really mark a big change in hs style but was more of an anomoly?
I think a better benchmark is Honeyghan, who was initially more of a boxer, but then started sitting down on his shots more and taking men out as a result?
Captain Hook wrote:We can carry it on if you want you slaaaag :)
Anyway, for what it's worth - Earl aside - I'd agree with the overall view that Khan can bang, but is not a concussive puncher. He's a lot like Bradley in that respect.
I believe Bradley is the only (realistic) opponent at the weight who would beat him.
I think Ortiz is a bigger threat. I think Bradley size and style match up quite nicely for Khan. Ortiz, however, is big, strong, fast and accurate. He'll land on Khan and then...
Deserter wrote:I think Khan will comfortably outbox Maidana when they meet, but I was astonished by this quote in the latest press conference:
"He is known as a big puncher but I really think I am a bigger puncher. Although I am best known for my speed, ask my past opponents about my power.”
I really do wonder what he's talking about at times - first there were the claims of how Pacman couldn't put him down despite his 'best' efforts, and now this...
Well if you consider it fully, you will probably realise he is right he certainly has the resources to a big puncher.....but like you i agree he shouldnt talk like he is the finished article....its just he hasnt used them properly up to now even tho he is a pro for 5 years now.......Khan doesnt really plant his feet to punch he prefers to go for speed and a high work rate....... he should make the step up to now thinking a bit more not being so dumb in the ring as he has shown man times, he should start planting his feet more at specific times in a fight and putting his full power in single shots when he sees the opening...........NAZ was adept at this.....and its something Khan really needs to do otherwise its a waste of his resources. I felt he could and should have taken out Malignaggi earlier like this.
He needs to plant a Bradley or Maidana out with a single shot the way Nunn took out Kalambay to really show people that dimension in him....instead of talking like he got it made already
He cant really afford to do that though as if he he plants his feet then he's static which makes him an easier target to hit and thus potentially knock out with his suspect chin!
That may will be why!!!...
Tommy Hearns is the ultimate guy who made the transition from boxer to puncher even tho his chin was somewhat suspect and to a lesser extent Lennox Lewis used to move around and Manny Steward got him to become a guy who could really unload in spurts and stand there and his chin has been questioned..but i see your point totally and its one time will tell ...
Michael Nunn looked to have made the transition to puncher after he won the title but ultimately as we know it wasnt the case..........yep Honeyghan is a great comparison......justas long as Amir doesnt think he can fight everyone the way Lllord did which contributed greatly to his downfalll
mugabi wrote: Honeyghan is a great comparison......justas long as Amir doesnt think he can fight everyone the way Lllord did which contributed greatly to his downfalll
Yep, you're completely right - he did a bit of a Naz and fell in love with banging guys out and so when he came up against a cute boxer like Starling he got horribly dissected. The earlier version of Honeyghan would have given Starling a far sterner argument rather than just charging in and getting picked off.
Captain Hook wrote:Flattened might not be the word then.....but you get the point :)
Good points about Honeyghan, remember the Bumphus fight too....?
It was madness wasn't it - legging it across the ring to nail him! I can't remember whether it was that fight or the Gene Hatcher one where he uttered the immortal 'I don't get paid for no over-time!'
His team, coach, everyone around him said if you fight on against Khan your going to get horribly hurt. Your punch resistance has gone and your not 100% 'all there' anymore.
When he declared he was fighting on, they all resigned from being part of his team.
He then got flattened, exactly as forecasted by his former team.
Captain Hook wrote:Flattened might not be the word then.....but you get the point :)
Good points about Honeyghan, remember the Bumphus fight too....?
It was madness wasn't it - legging it across the ring to nail him! I can't remember whether it was that fight or the Gene Hatcher one where he uttered the immortal 'I don't get paid for no over-time!'
Captain Hook wrote:Flattened might not be the word then.....but you get the point :)
Good points about Honeyghan, remember the Bumphus fight too....?
It was madness wasn't it - legging it across the ring to nail him! I can't remember whether it was that fight or the Gene Hatcher one where he uttered the immortal 'I don't get paid for no over-time!'
