Matthew Saad Muhammad vs Tomasz Adamek

[gilgamesh]

Come on can't you just imagine how action packed this one would be? Your thoughts.

[SaadOffTheDeck]

This is one I'm very comfortable taking my boy in. There would be a ton of action and Adamek would end up getting stopped in 10 or 11.

[gregor]

This mean it would be at LHW, so Adamek chances are marginal. I admit Adamek improved his defence and started to look like someone with a gameplan, but it happened only later when he was in CW/HW. If he fights him like he fought Briggs (and in LHW he showed nothing to think otherwise) it would be just asking for disaster. Still, it would be really entertaining as long as it lasts.

[gilgamesh]

I agree, Saad Muhammad would get the better of him. But it would be a surefire Fight of the Year, if not Fight of the Decade type fight.

[BoxBuzz]

Saad wins because anything Ademek can dish he can take...Saad could weather out the storm and then just wear TA down and eventually probably put him away.

[Duran Fan]

It would be fight of the year. I would go for MSM. But it would be no certainty.

[Arbachakov]

Unless it was past prime Saad, it would be more likely to be a one sided fight, rather than a great back and forth contest.

[crusader]

Adamek was an average champion at 175 and he has been overrated throughout his entire career, imo. I don't think he would be competitive enough to make it fight of the year. Saad wins this.