Robin Reid #1 - you are joking ?

[TonyHolmes]

I see that a few weeks ago Robin Reid got mysteriously promoted to #1 in the Super-Middleweight diviosion.

As it's some time since he held a recognised title, came up well short against Ottke, and lost against #4 Joe Calzaghe , how can this ranking be taken remotely seriously?

TH

[JCS]

It is based on a computerized point system, not by popular opinion.

If Calzaghe stepped it up a bit more I'm sure he would be #1.. unless he gets beat.

[computerrank]

I see that a few weeks ago Robin Reid got mysteriously promoted to #1 in the Super-Middleweight diviosion.

As it's some time since he held a recognised title, came up well short against Ottke, and lost against #4 Joe Calzaghe , how can this ranking be taken remotely seriously?

TH

Please look at:

http://www.boxrec.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... ht=#289012

and

http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.php/B ... escription

Best regards
Martin