dont agree re honeygun, he defended four times i think, lost to varca then regaiined it and eventually lost it to starling in a brutal beatdown. (he was never the same afterthat fight)
his peak may have been short but he sure as hell was the best welter on the planet for a while.
massivley underated in comparison to the old favourites say the likes of mcguigan he is a level up again in my view on par with Buchanon.
British greats All-time and p4p...
-
jamesmcdonnell
- Heavyweight
- Posts: 45229
- Joined: 12 Nov 2003, 06:11
J wrote:1. Ted Kid Lewis
2. Jimmy Wilde
3. Lennox Lewis
4. Jack kid Berg
5. Bob Fitzimmons
6. Ken Buchanon
7. Lloyd Honeygun (the ost underated fighter of the past 20 years unified welterweight beaitng curry nto many can say they were unified champ)
8. John H stracey
9. Barry Mcguigan
10. Nigel Benn (cos he is my fave fighter)
so yes jim there's a lis thwere, though I know you are gonna hate it but there you go, you asked.
arrrrrrrrrrrrgh benny lynch arrrrgh see i hate these lists you always miss someone off. stuff it i cant be arsed to re jig it.
-
BubiScholz
- Heavyweight
- Posts: 1879
- Joined: 02 Feb 2004, 13:02
He is a real good boxer and I like him. In his times there was just one World title belt. 30 years later he would have been one world champion.J wrote:no and quite rightly so what are you on about.
Or are you joking?
how many world titles did he win?
Why should I joke? Because I don´t like all about Harrison.....
Sorry for posting....
-
jamesmcdonnell
- Heavyweight
- Posts: 45229
- Joined: 12 Nov 2003, 06:11
-
Manos de Oro
- Heavyweight
- Posts: 1630
- Joined: 21 Sep 2004, 12:10
J, something worth thinking about is that even though Lloyd won abroad the same as Ken, the air conditioned interior of Caeser's was vastly different to the unbearable heat in San Juan during that afternoon. They even tried to screw Ken by sneaking in first and nabbing the coolest corner - so he'd fry between rounds without shade.J wrote:dont agree re honeygun, he defended four times i think, lost to varca then regaiined it and eventually lost it to starling in a brutal beatdown. (he was never the same afterthat fight)
his peak may have been short but he sure as hell was the best welter on the planet for a while.
massivley underated in comparison to the old favourites say the likes of mcguigan he is a level up again in my view on par with Buchanon.
Again, hope it doesn't sound like I'm trying to denigrate Lloyd in any way, but I rank Ken higher because he unified the titles himself, rather than won them in a one-er. He did that against Ruben Navarro in the same snake pit that Johnny Owen fought his final fight in, in Los Angeles. Navarro tried to take Ken's head off but got thoroughly outboxed. Showing calmness and poise in such a cauldron (someone even tried to switch his water bottle - all sorts of skullduggery were going on) is astonishing.
Comparing him to Ricky Hatton is also interesting - he gave Laguna a rematch (again, away from home: that is shocking!!) and beat him more convincinly than the first, despite Laguna actually boxing a bit better (IMO). He also made Carlos Ortiz surrender in only 6 rounds of a one sided fight...
His only loss came against a man who you could make a strong case for being the best ever at that weight - Roberto Duran. And even then Ken actually fought with him, and was closing strongly for a UD loss when he got hit by the low blow and 'stopped'.
bubi no need to act so offended but there no way henry cooper makes an all time top ten mate.
you know me well enough not to be offended and if you are well thats your own fault.
jeez manos we are geting a bit specific when we are talking about air conidtioning mate. kinell.also if you look at the list i do rank ken ahead of llloyd but not by much mate!!!
same coudl be said for mcguigan when he lost to cruz in the midday sun, its the same for both fighters.
you know me well enough not to be offended and if you are well thats your own fault.
jeez manos we are geting a bit specific when we are talking about air conidtioning mate. kinell.
also if you look at the list i do rank ken ahead of llloyd but not by much mate!!!same coudl be said for mcguigan when he lost to cruz in the midday sun, its the same for both fighters.