2 Missing Fights For Herman Weiner

[DavidEpstein]

Herman Weiner's comeback record should read:

In 1934, Weiner launched a comeback. On Feb. 10th he KO'd Rex King in 2 rounds in Salisbury, Maryland. At the 104th Armory on Feb. 23rd, He scored a 2nd round stoppage over Jack Reed. In Newark, New Jersey, Weiner bombed out Eight Ball Taylor. On August 10, 1934, he continued his knockout steak with a 3rd round KO over Fred Klick also in Newark. Weiner, weighing 192lbs., scored his 5th straight knockout victory with a 2nd round knockout over Rex King, 184lbs. at Carlins Park in Baltimore, Maryland on Oct. 29, 1934.

[John]

that's only four fights ?

[Emaster]

On Feb. 10th [1934, Herman Weiner] KO'd Rex King in 2 rounds in Salisbury, Maryland.

In 1 round according to BoxRec.

In Newark, New Jersey, Weiner bombed out Eight Ball Taylor.

Bout Missing in BoxRec. Does Taylor have a BoxRec record at all?

On August 10, 1934, he continued his knockout steak with a 3rd round KO over Fred Klick also in Newark.

A 2nd round KO according to BoxRec.

Weiner's wiki page says his "ring record was reported to be: 38-19-1 (31 knockouts)." His BoxRec record presently reads 32-20-1 (25 KOs).

[DavidEpstein]

I believe heavyweight Red Taylor was also known as "Eight Ball" Taylor.

http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_ ... &cat=boxer

Taylor fought Weiner in the mid 1920s and I believe he also fought Weiner in that comeback fight in the 1930s.

[DavidEpstein]

I believe I've find a total of 9 more fights not listed for Herman Weiner:

1928: Aug.-Al "Lefty" Marino, Virginia......W KO
1928: Thomas Murphy, Virgina.......W KO
1930: James "Jim" Dugan...............W KO
1930: James "Jim" Pond.................W KO
1930: Feb.21-Jack Davis, Hagerstown, MDW KO 1
1930: July 23-Honus Hartman, Hagerston, W KO 2
1930: Aug.29-Johnny Parker, Portsmoth,VA.L KO 1
1931:Feb.11-Mitz Minkel, Carlins Park, Baltimore, MD..Result unknown
1934:Apr or May-Eight Ball Taylor, Newark, N.J. W KO 3

[John]

I believe I've find a total of 9 more fights not listed for Herman Weiner:

1928: Aug.-Al "Lefty" Marino, Virginia......W KO
1928: Thomas Murphy, Virgina.......W KO
1930: James "Jim" Dugan...............W KO
1930: James "Jim" Pond.................W KO
1930: Feb.21-Jack Davis, Hagerstown, MDW KO 1
1930: July 23-Honus Hartman, Hagerston, W KO 2
1930: Aug.29-Johnny Parker, Portsmoth,VA.L KO 1
1931:Feb.11-Mitz Minkel, Carlins Park, Baltimore, MD..Result unknown
1934:Apr or May-Eight Ball Taylor, Newark, N.J. W KO 3

We need a source, newspaper scans etc

[stac]

and exact dates