Better Fighter?

[Tomasino]

We've moved on from that one.

Lockridge

John John Molina or Kuniaki Shibata

Shibata. Was tough because I enjoyed watching Molina in his prime.

[NazNaci1]

Lockridge.


Eder Jofre or Ike Williams?

Williams, too much of everything.

Matthew Franklin v Bob Foster

[raylawpc]

Lockridge.


Eder Jofre or Ike Williams?

Williams, too much of everything.

Matthew Franklin v Bob Foster

Foster

Ryan v. Fitzsimmons @ middleweight 1900

[JDC]

Nice shout. I'm not getting involved in that one

[The End]

Lockridge.


Eder Jofre or Ike Williams?

Williams, too much of everything.

Matthew Franklin v Bob Foster

Foster

Ryan v. Fitzsimmons @ middleweight 1900

The Fits even though he's become a chuck norris joke on this site.

Barerra v. Morales

[Goodnight, Irene]

It isnt a VERSUS thread, guys.

It is simply who you feel the better boxer was.

[NazNaci1]

In which case I'll go again....

Barrera.

Arguello - Joe Brown @ Lightweight

[JDC]

It isnt a VERSUS thread, guys.

It is simply who you feel the better boxer was.

Oh yeah, and it's the title

[Tomasino]

In which case I'll go again....

Barrera.

Arguello - Joe Brown @ Lightweight

Old Bones.



James Jeffries or Mike Tyson?

[The End]

It isnt a VERSUS thread, guys.

It is simply who you feel the better boxer was.

If this is directed at me, I am aware. Which is why i put two fighters that already foughtt

[The End]

In which case I'll go again....

Barrera.

Arguello - Joe Brown @ Lightweight

Old Bones.



James Jeffries or Mike Tyson?

Good one there. I'm leaning towards Jefferies.

Oscar De La Hoya v. Kostya Tszyu

[boxbible]

DLH...

Chuck Wepner or Randall Tex Cobb?

[BoxBuzz]

Ok this is apples and apples...all either of them have going for them is blood and guts lol.

I'll go with Cobb, I think he's willing to shed to the last pint, whereas, I'm thinking Wepner might request a transfusion during the break around the 13th or 14th rounds.


Sugar Ray Leonard or Pernell Whitaker?

[Ezzard]

Leonard

Monzon or Mayweather

[Tomasino]

Leonard

Monzon or Mayweather

Monzon!



Mustapha Hamsho or Winky Wright?

[The End]

Leonard

Monzon or Mayweather

Monzon!



Mustapha Hamsho or Winky Wright?

Winky ..

Mayweather or Azuma Nelson

[Goodnight, Irene]

Mayweather.

Alexis Arguello or Joe Louis?

[Tomasino]

Joe Louis.


Gene Tunney or Ezzard Charles

[Goodnight, Irene]

Im so glad you bring that one up, because Charles is the consensus #1 LHW, and Tunney, my personal choice as the best LHW ever, and they each had worthy HW careers. Id say Tunney --- all told, its marginal.

Danny Lopez or Felix Trinidad?

[Tomasino]

Im so glad you bring that one up, because Charles is the consensus #1 LHW, and Tunney, my personal choice as the best LHW ever, and they each had worthy HW careers. Id say Tunney --- all told, its marginal.

Danny Lopez or Felix Trinidad?

I agree.


Lopez, similar fighters in the sense that both surged back when hurt and often scored kayos after knockdowns. Lopez had better quality opposition.



Beau Jack or Marco A Barrera?

[Goodnight, Irene]

Lopez reminds me of a miniaturised Trinidad, thats why I compared them.

A bit like the way people compare Arguello to Louis.

[tommo100]

butterbean or solis!!!!

[Tomasino]

:geek2:

Solis. It was horrible having to picture both of those flabbers fighting, the worst yet.

[Tomasino]

Lopez reminds me of a miniaturised Trinidad, thats why I compared them.

A bit like the way people compare Arguello to Louis.

[Tomasino]

Wilfredo Gomez or Bernard Hopkins.