Maccarinelli-Mcphilban
Maccarinelli-Mcphilban
What would you do now.
Re: Maccarinelli-Mcphilban
you need to add.....
rule it a NC and have a rematch relatively soon!
rule it a NC and have a rematch relatively soon!
-
Old bones Ian
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 11808
- Joined: 13 Jul 2004, 07:33
Re: Maccarinelli-Mcphilban
Decision stands and order a rematch. For me a NC should only be called if the one of the boxers is at fault , this mistake was by the timekeeper. And at the moment we have to accept it was a genuine mistake by him.
Re: Maccarinelli-Mcphilban
Why should a boxer have to be at fault? The fight was a farce and a disgrace to British boxing. Ruling it a no contest is a good way for the board to make it clear that this sort of thing will not be tolerated.Old bones Ian wrote:Decision stands and order a rematch. For me a NC should only be called if the one of the boxers is at fault , this mistake was by the timekeeper.
I don't see why we have to accept that is the case. Hopefully the BBBofC will investigate and find out if it was just a mistake or not.Old bones Ian wrote:And at the moment we have to accept it was a genuine mistake by him.
-
jameswilson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 13439
- Joined: 08 Jan 2004, 18:01
Re: Maccarinelli-Mcphilban
Is Enzo going to move back down to Light heavyweight again now? I think there where he isn't facing guys who get in the ring weighing potentially 215lbs he would fare far better.