Enzo Maccarinelli to face Shane McPhilbin rematch

[mcato]

Enzo Maccarinelli has been ordered to fight McPhibin. Do we want to see this fight again. Im not sure. What do you think

[ShadrachSimmo]

Enzo should vacate and retire.

[15829]

Enzo should vacate and retire.

Completly agree, Enzos got nothing left to prove stick to being a pundit for allegedly before he gets really hurt

[whiskey]

Whether or not people want to see it, Shane deserves the rematch.

The time keeper has been suspended until jan 2013 too.

[15829]

Whether or not people want to see it, Shane deserves the rematch.

The time keeper has been suspended until jan 2013 too.

He shoud fight the winner of Askin and JLD for the vacant title

[dookus]

Whether or not people want to see it, Shane deserves the rematch.

The time keeper has been suspended until jan 2013 too.

He shoud fight the winner of Askin and JLD for the vacant title

I agree, suspension isn't nearly good enough for him

[Horse]

The time keeper has been suspended until jan 2013 too.

Not a very harsh punishment at all.

[gb]

Given his timekeeping, he probably thinks that he's been suspended for a month! (sorry, couldn't resist it!)

[15829]

As much as i like Enzo he's deluded

[smoggy7188]

Good to see the purse is a 50/50 split.

[whiskey]

As much as i like Enzo he's deluded

Your right Diggler, he's always come across as a very decent bloke indeed.

But eff me he's like a scarecrow blowing in the wind every time a shot lands.

[Dan Dares]

I've no wish to see this fight again. I turned it off after the ridiculous first round.

[billy nelson]

Enzo will stop him next time!

[jameswilson]

Another thing that did puzzle me slightly watching it back. Zab Judah got ruled as stopped by Tszyu because after being put down he got up and then touched down again before the count had finished. Now this I think was also the case with Mac for one of his knockdowns, he got up, wobbled a bit and then took a knee. Do we not have that rule as part of our title fights or have I misinterpreted the rule somehow?

[whiskey]

Enzo will stop him next time!

Enzo Calzaghe will stop the fight?

agreed.

[stujones]

James,

No formal rule as such as far as I am aware.

Slight difference to how Enzo touched down for a second time in the count, and how Zab did. Jay Nady waved it off because of how he went down the second time.... all over the shop.

Enzo consciously took a knee to buy some time, Judah was doing a Berbick.

[15829]

Enzo will stop him next time!

Enzo Calzaghe will stop the fight?

agreed.

If hes allowed in the corner

[crusader]

Another thing that did puzzle me slightly watching it back. Zab Judah got ruled as stopped by Tszyu because after being put down he got up and then touched down again before the count had finished. Now this I think was also the case with Mac for one of his knockdowns, he got up, wobbled a bit and then took a knee. Do we not have that rule as part of our title fights or have I misinterpreted the rule somehow?

Nady didn't stop the Judah fight because it was mandated by a rule; he interpreted Judah's return to the canvas as a sign that he was unable to continue.

[Coco]

Enzo should take the fight, knock him out then fight Cleverly

[lefthook82]

No desire to ever see Shane McPhilbin again. Boxing is all about different styles, but the one where fighters practice Brazilian Jujitsu with the occasional clubbing shot thrown in is not to my taste. I'll bet on it but will read the rbr

[lefthook82]

No desire to ever see Shane McPhilbin again. Boxing is all about different styles, but the one where fighters practice Brazilian Jujitsu with the occasional clubbing shot thrown in is not to my taste. I'll bet on it but will read the rbr

[billy nelson]

Given the circumstances i thought Enzo done well and showed a desire to win,that you cant put into a fighter he has it in spades

[Final round]

No desire to ever see Shane McPhilbin again. Boxing is all about different styles, but the one where fighters practice Brazilian Jujitsu with the occasional clubbing shot thrown in is not to my taste. I'll bet on it but will read the rbr

He doesn't exactly practice the sweet science that's for sure

[Adamj1987]

to the title of the thread good, he should

[Grays_Dan]

Enzo should take the fight, knock him out then fight Cleverly

I know its April Fools day but really? Thats not even funny. Cleverly would destroy him.