Juan Coggi v. Marcos Maidana.

[Rover]

Two hard-hitting Argentinian jr. welters who could be KD'd, but neither was ever officially KO'd (Maidana so far, anyway). (Yes, I'm well aware of Gonzalez I.)
I think Coggi would win a decision in a fight where both hit the floor multiple times.

[giacomino]

Good call. Both flawed, but both fun to watch. Coggi was the better boxer but, like Maidana, was open to getting hit with big punches. Would have been a good fight

[Vladimir5555]

I think Coggi win by decision in a slugfest