No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post Reply
Mensa07
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 618
Joined: 14 Mar 2006, 06:12

No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Mensa07 »

..could it make a fighter? I'm no fighter, but in the gym the other day I started to wonder if say 12 minutes sparring, even low-contact, would be more beneficial from a novice point of view than say 10 rounds on the bags and 2 mile run.

Repetition is the key to learning, and the rythms and reflexes etc of a fight are something that you won't pick up from bags. From a fitness point of view, and this is something I know nothing about, would you not be better repetitively putting your body through 2/3 minute spars than training it to do 8k runs?

I might very well be talking bollox, it's been known before, it's just a thought I had that are the 'traditional' methods of speed bag, skipping, runs still the best way to make a fighter? Could you get by on just sparring, and doing some technique work and shadowboxing?
JLP
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 802
Joined: 07 Nov 2012, 05:42

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by JLP »

Mensa07 wrote:I might very well be talking bollox, it's been known before, it's just a thought I had that are the 'traditional' methods of speed bag, skipping, runs still the best way to make a fighter? Could you get by on just sparring, and doing some technique work and shadowboxing?

The traditional methods of boxing training prioritises sparring and shadow-boxing, so your question above is not really posed too well. Heavy-bag, speed-bag, double-end-bag, skipping, roadwork and floor-work are all supplementary. If your training time was extremely limited and you could only pick one thing to do --and you were going to have competitive fights-- light(ish) sparring should be your choice, in my view.

You'll get all sorts of opinions on this subject. Some good, some bad, some stupid. At the end of the day, if you want to get good at anything in life, you should practice that particular skill over and over and over. You can take your answer from that.
Looking On
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 927
Joined: 12 Oct 2012, 13:50

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Looking On »

depends on what level ,

If your talking pro boxing then id go along with JLP

but if your talking white collar etc then quite often with novices its the fittest guy that wins .
JLP
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 802
Joined: 07 Nov 2012, 05:42

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by JLP »

Looking On wrote:but if your talking white collar etc then quite often with novices its the fittest guy that wins .
Yeah there's some truth in that but I'd say there is also a bit of a misconception, too. With rank novices fitness plays its part but it is actually more a case of who handles the situation best i.e. who doesn't allow their nerves/adrenaline to swamp them and stays most relaxed. You see super-fit guys hooped after a minute purely because they've let it all get on top of them, fired themselves up, shot their wad and then crumbled. Lots of sparring enables you to learn how to deal with the fear/excitement that can consume you.
danconnollyeire
Light Heavyweight
Posts: 3576
Joined: 24 May 2012, 10:31

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by danconnollyeire »

You cAnt just spar and shadow box

Simply if you're a weak puncher you need to work on strength. If you have low stamina you need to run more etc. if you're not very explosive there's useful exercises (hill sprints, plyometrics)

It's not that simple
Bricks
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3916
Joined: 28 Apr 2008, 12:42

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Bricks »

Mensa07 wrote:..could it make a fighter? I'm no fighter, but in the gym the other day I started to wonder if say 12 minutes sparring, even low-contact, would be more beneficial from a novice point of view than say 10 rounds on the bags and 2 mile run.
Repetition is the key to learning, and the rythms and reflexes etc of a fight are something that you won't pick up from bags. From a fitness point of view, and this is something I know nothing about, would you not be better repetitively putting your body through 2/3 minute spars than training it to do 8k runs?

I might very well be talking bollox, it's been known before, it's just a thought I had that are the 'traditional' methods of speed bag, skipping, runs still the best way to make a fighter? Could you get by on just sparring, and doing some technique work and shadowboxing?
Of course you are are right. I have seen a thousand punch bag masters who skip like a pro and can run 2 miles but put them in a ring and the moment they get hit they realise they will never be boxers.

U cannot beat sparring and padwork with a good padsman hitting back where u r exposed is only second to it.
Terminator666
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1669
Joined: 06 Nov 2007, 10:18

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Terminator666 »

Think there are some boxers who don't bother with running-Hamed at one point of his career never did any.
Darcy Delaney
Cruiserweight
Posts: 635
Joined: 19 Mar 2011, 07:56

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Darcy Delaney »

once i managed to get (fighting fight) i all i ever done was loads of sparring with different people and good pad work but i used to do a 45 min power walk instead of running as i found i'd get shin splints when i done long runs (it worked for me as a heavyweight ) then plenty of ground work :TU:
i never had a lot of fights but i did help a lot of top pro's with sparring as they were getting ready for fights and the training i done worked for me :TU:
TJ77
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1352
Joined: 19 Sep 2010, 13:01

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by TJ77 »

Interesting thread :TU:
stevieb_8006
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by stevieb_8006 »

obv hes an exceptional talent, but james toney only ever really focussed on sparring and shadow boxed post roy jones jnr.

Im sure he messed about doing bits and bobs, weights and stuff, but that was the core of his training.

Theres an interview online where he calls all other fighters bag beaters.
stujones
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 27576
Joined: 29 Aug 2003, 15:08

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by stujones »

running isn't that specific to the sport when you look at the movement. However, where I think it is at is most important is when you are taking a shot. Need leg strength and for me, it is better than doing the weights.

Bag, Pads and Sparring are the three most essential. You can build up the stamina by really working over the bag.... is more specific with than running. Sparring and sparring with leg weights on is the most essential in honing in technique and stamina building also.
badmexfighter
Cruiserweight
Posts: 18
Joined: 04 Nov 2011, 17:21

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by badmexfighter »

I used to be an amateur boxer, running was very important, but if you were just going to train and didn't want to become a boxer could help it.

The sparring was very limited, we didn't have boxing equipment, and most of the guys hit very hard, so the coach didn't let us spar more than 10 minutes
Scrap
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1604
Joined: 29 May 2006, 05:24

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Scrap »

stujones wrote:running isn't that specific to the sport when you look at the movement. However, where I think it is at is most important is when you are taking a shot. Need leg strength and for me, it is better than doing the weights.

Bag, Pads and Sparring are the three most essential. You can build up the stamina by really working over the bag.... is more specific with than running. Sparring and sparring with leg weights on is the most essential in honing in technique and stamina building also.
Running and Skipping, are specific to Boxing, they engage the TFL and posterior Chain.
Mensa07
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 618
Joined: 14 Mar 2006, 06:12

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Mensa07 »

mugabi wrote:
Mensa07 wrote:..could it make a fighter? I'm no fighter, but in the gym the other day I started to wonder if say 12 minutes sparring, even low-contact, would be more beneficial from a novice point of view than say 10 rounds on the bags and 2 mile run.
Repetition is the key to learning, and the rythms and reflexes etc of a fight are something that you won't pick up from bags. From a fitness point of view, and this is something I know nothing about, would you not be better repetitively putting your body through 2/3 minute spars than training it to do 8k runs?

I might very well be talking bollox, it's been known before, it's just a thought I had that are the 'traditional' methods of speed bag, skipping, runs still the best way to make a fighter? Could you get by on just sparring, and doing some technique work and shadowboxing?
Of course you are are right. I have seen a thousand punch bag masters who skip like a pro and can run 2 miles but put them in a ring and the moment they get hit they realise they will never be boxers.
lol, thats me to a tee!
magnus
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1187
Joined: 13 Dec 2004, 08:59

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by magnus »

I'm sure I read that Juan Diaz (lightweight champ a couple of years ago) never ran, just did some swimming for cardio. He certainly had no "engine" problems.
dbf
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1794
Joined: 28 Nov 2003, 11:06

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by dbf »

Different things for different fighters. Calzaghe did very little sparring, and got most of his timing down on the floor to ceiling bag. Haye isn't a massive sparrer either.

Any good amateur coach will tell you that there are 3 types of sparring; technique, conditioned, and open. Open is usually the lesser of the 3.

Regular hard spars or gym wars can put years on a fighter so I can think you need to do additional work so as not to cook yourself before a contest. Pad work is overated and whilst making the boxer and it seems more recently the coach feeling good I'm not a huge believer in doing rounds and rounds of pads.
dbf
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1794
Joined: 28 Nov 2003, 11:06

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by dbf »

magnus wrote:I'm sure I read that Juan Diaz (lightweight champ a couple of years ago) never ran, just did some swimming for cardio. He certainly had no "engine" problems.
True. Big Wlad Klitschko is the same. Calzaghe never skipped. Whatever works for you I guess.
polecateddy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by polecateddy »

Naz never did any road work hardly either. He just did the indoor gym stuff.
Jeff Thomas
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3016
Joined: 30 Apr 2009, 06:32

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Jeff Thomas »

If you do 12 minute sparring rounds for conditioning then your training at the wrong intensity for a boxing match.

Diaz hammered the swimming and cross trainer.. He didn't just do a bit of it. :TU:

I coach beginners how to box and as an experiment I had two friends come to me and I thought I'll not do pads with them ill just coach them from the beginning by conditioned sparring and they are absolutely quality for novices. One in particular will be a good fighter. Take him on the pads and he's ok but no great shakes- put him in to spar and he's fantastic and holds his own with much more experienced lads.
Trojans44
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 352
Joined: 23 Sep 2010, 14:05

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Trojans44 »

My obseravtion of boxing trainers is that more so than in any other sport they appear to have no actual qualification or deep understanding of conditioning and sometimes even the sport itself. Some appear to just fling a towel over their shoulder. I remember Andy Murray recently stating after a stint in a boxing gym that he was shocked by the primitive training techniques. Enzo Calzaghe e.g. just seemed to shout incoherent nonsense between rounds.
dapug
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 221
Joined: 31 Dec 2007, 08:21

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by dapug »

Mensa07 wrote:
mugabi wrote:
Mensa07 wrote:..could it make a fighter? I'm no fighter, but in the gym the other day I started to wonder if say 12 minutes sparring, even low-contact, would be more beneficial from a novice point of view than say 10 rounds on the bags and 2 mile run.
Repetition is the key to learning, and the rythms and reflexes etc of a fight are something that you won't pick up from bags. From a fitness point of view, and this is something I know nothing about, would you not be better repetitively putting your body through 2/3 minute spars than training it to do 8k runs?

I might very well be talking bollox, it's been known before, it's just a thought I had that are the 'traditional' methods of speed bag, skipping, runs still the best way to make a fighter? Could you get by on just sparring, and doing some technique work and shadowboxing?
Of course you are are right. I have seen a thousand punch bag masters who skip like a pro and can run 2 miles but put them in a ring and the moment they get hit they realise they will never be boxers.
lol, thats me to a tee!
You are so right, it is so different having someone in front of you, nothing like a pressure tested fighter.
Jeff Thomas
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3016
Joined: 30 Apr 2009, 06:32

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by Jeff Thomas »

Trojans44 wrote:My obseravtion of boxing trainers is that more so than in any other sport they appear to have no actual qualification or deep understanding of conditioning and sometimes even the sport itself. Some appear to just fling a towel over their shoulder. I remember Andy Murray recently stating after a stint in a boxing gym that he was shocked by the primitive training techniques. Enzo Calzaghe e.g. just seemed to shout incoherent nonsense between rounds.

I've been to loads of gyms and the level of knowledge of physiology ranges from moronic to genius.. and everywhere in between.

I once had a boxing coach next to me be asked for some nutritional advice for a 12 year old swimmer. I'd just recently qualified as a personal trainer which I spent 18 months at college studying part time so I was really looking forward to his answer.

So the Dad asks this bloke what he should do before the race which was a fair distance if I recall correctly, and his advice was.....

'Don't eat any sugar between now and the race (two days later) then just before you get in the swimming pool have a lucozade. The energy boost will power you through the race'. I didn't stay there for long.

In contrast I spent some time with a trainer - who I won't name here to save embarassment but the guy is a genius. His tutelage has helped me understand boxing in a whole new way. Sadly too late to really put it into practice but as an aspiring coach I've passed lots on to my lads and so far our winning percentage sits around 75% so i'm quite happy with that for a newbie.
bripez
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4877
Joined: 11 Feb 2010, 18:07

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by bripez »

Interesting topic - and I keep changing my mind !

One thing for sure, it is too simplistic to say that Naz / Toney / Klitschko / Calzaghe et al did or did not do certain things so therefore it must be good etc. is too simplistic - you cannot take one single boxer who is an elite world class athlete and apply the same philosophy to the average person.

eg. I cannot imagine any boxer in the world saying to a young lad that he doesn't have to do roadwork because didn't do it and he became a world champ : Naz would have been world class whether he did roadwork or not.
stujones
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 27576
Joined: 29 Aug 2003, 15:08

Re: No roadwork, no bags/pads, just sparring & shadowboxing..

Post by stujones »

Trojans44 wrote:My obseravtion of boxing trainers is that more so than in any other sport they appear to have no actual qualification or deep understanding of conditioning and sometimes even the sport itself. Some appear to just fling a towel over their shoulder. I remember Andy Murray recently stating after a stint in a boxing gym that he was shocked by the primitive training techniques. Enzo Calzaghe e.g. just seemed to shout incoherent nonsense between rounds.
And Legend has it that a younh Enzo knew his limitations and not much boxing knowledge took Joe to an amateur club as a test and the coaches said "you're son is special he should go to someone more equiped than us" - then Enzo thought - well I cannot be doing to bad then. And the rest is history.
Post Reply