Carlos Zarate vs. Lupe Pintor 'The Controversy'

[Rover]

I would think,,,,,,that those 'in-the-know' understand.

For Arturo 'Cuyo' Hernandez,

A contract with Lupe Pintor as the WBC Bantamweight Champion, is worth a hell of lot more
than 'nothing' with Carlos Zarate.

Unless, you think that 'Cuyo' Hernandez did this for nothing.

Another post without evidence. Keep it up.

[Rover]

I see you in your Scorecard Post,,,,,,

You clearly have it for Carlos Zarate (144-140) or 9-6-0 in Rounds.

What are you doing, now calling 'Professional and Experienced Judges' - Art Lurie and Harold Buck 'inept'.

How dare you disrespect those two legends.

I told you in another thread that I'd scored it 144-140 for Zarate days ago, though I didn't post my RBR scorecard.
I have disagreed with many decisions in the past, and I will no doubt disagree with many more.
If you'd like to leave this thread on a note of agreement--that we both disagreed with the decision, fine with me.

[Rover]

I like your scorecard,,,,,,,,very difficult to not score 'Even' rounds, especially in that bout.

Originally, I had thought Carlos won it by a 'wide-margin', but also gave Lupe Pintor much credit
for a good performance, including wobbling Carlos (Round 10), and rocking him in Rounds 11 and 14.

After reviewing the bout, I had it (146-142) or 7-4-4 in Rounds, including scoring Round 4 ({10-8}.

Funny...I scored 11 close for Zarate.
I will occasionally score even rounds, and one could score some in that fight reasonably.
So our margins are identical, and a thread of disagreement does end on a note of agreement.
:)
I do find your threads (Rubaldino, Lujan/Zamora (hasn't been added to in a while), Saad Muhammad) interesting, as I do enjoy those fighters.