http://boxrec.com/show_display.php?show_id=412477
It was an exhibition bout, with no referee and no decision.
Chicago Tribune thought Ryan looked better, Chicago Herald opined Hall a clear winner, while Chicago Inter Ocean had it even.
Paddy Carroll was the master of ceremonies, and not the referee, per Inter Ocean, although the Herald called him the referee.
McMillan-Baker was also an exhibition.
1891-09-28 Jim Hall W-PTS5 Tommy Ryan
Re: 1891-09-28 Jim Hall W-PTS5 Tommy Ryan
I deleted the bout. 