Mcphilbin just looks like he does everything wrong&im on about the basics,which you are first taught when boxing...I think he will slip into the Journeyman mode now¬ win often at all..But whatever i think,you cant EVER take away the fact that he won the British title...Looking On wrote:You say Mcphilbin was terrible etc , and while i cant disagree with you it got me thinking about the fact that in the amateurs to my knowledge he beat Keane , possibly an ABA semi final ???? i know he lost in the aba's to Tyson Fury .SamWise72 wrote:Just watched the fight, and he looked like he has promise, but the bigger thing it reminded me of is how dreadful McPhilbin is. His attempts to put pressure on in the 3rd were like watching an elephant on its hind legs. Has nobody ever taught him how to punch? McPhilbin - Williams was the worst British title fight I've ever suffered through.
My view of Keane is that he's not quick enough to beat JLD. Hard to say whether he can apply enough pressure to have a chance of knocking him out, but I think he's gonna get outscored in that fight.
Hes obviously got some boxing ability as you dont do well in the top amateur tournaments if you cant box , but something happened to him that has made him not do too well in his last couple of fights , is it his lifestyle he leads ? is it that he just doesnt want it ?
Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
-
Tommy Gunn13
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 3290
- Joined: 10 Nov 2008, 13:11
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
-
billy nelson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 1966
- Joined: 12 Apr 2010, 12:49
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
Very true but you also can't get carried away by beating himTommy Gunn13 wrote:Mcphilbin just looks like he does everything wrong&im on about the basics,which you are first taught when boxing...I think he will slip into the Journeyman mode now¬ win often at all..But whatever i think,you cant EVER take away the fact that he won the British title...Looking On wrote:You say Mcphilbin was terrible etc , and while i cant disagree with you it got me thinking about the fact that in the amateurs to my knowledge he beat Keane , possibly an ABA semi final ???? i know he lost in the aba's to Tyson Fury .SamWise72 wrote:Just watched the fight, and he looked like he has promise, but the bigger thing it reminded me of is how dreadful McPhilbin is. His attempts to put pressure on in the 3rd were like watching an elephant on its hind legs. Has nobody ever taught him how to punch? McPhilbin - Williams was the worst British title fight I've ever suffered through.
My view of Keane is that he's not quick enough to beat JLD. Hard to say whether he can apply enough pressure to have a chance of knocking him out, but I think he's gonna get outscored in that fight.
Hes obviously got some boxing ability as you dont do well in the top amateur tournaments if you cant box , but something happened to him that has made him not do too well in his last couple of fights , is it his lifestyle he leads ? is it that he just doesnt want it ?
-
Tommy Gunn13
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 3290
- Joined: 10 Nov 2008, 13:11
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
I agree Billy,it was only the 2nd time ive seen Keane..but to stop Mcphilbin that early was a good win..Im not slating your man,but what ive seen of him in the pros,hes yet to impress me..No doubt the better opponent,the better he will be..Personally,i think the Cruiserweights in the UK over the next 6-18months well be very interesting,with some good fights out there 
-
Boxingcutsman
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 783
- Joined: 30 May 2012, 21:35
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
Tommy Gunn13 wrote:I agree Billy,it was only the 2nd time ive seen Keane..but to stop Mcphilbin that early was a good win..Im not slating your man,but what ive seen of him in the pros,hes yet to impress me..No doubt the better opponent,the better he will be..Personally,i think the Cruiserweights in the UK over the next 6-18months well be very interesting,with some good fights out there
Very well said Tommy Gunn
-
Old bones Ian
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 11810
- Joined: 13 Jul 2004, 07:33
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
As long as the guys face each other at some point, we've had it in the past where its a good domestic division but the boxers take different routes and we never really find out who was the best between them. The light middles a few years ago spring to mind.Boxingcutsman wrote:Tommy Gunn13 wrote:I agree Billy,it was only the 2nd time ive seen Keane..but to stop Mcphilbin that early was a good win..Im not slating your man,but what ive seen of him in the pros,hes yet to impress me..No doubt the better opponent,the better he will be..Personally,i think the Cruiserweights in the UK over the next 6-18months well be very interesting,with some good fights out there
Very well said Tommy Gunn
-
Tommy Gunn13
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 3290
- Joined: 10 Nov 2008, 13:11
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
Yes Ian them Light Middles could have been awesome...Lets hope the Cruisers mix it with one anotherOld bones Ian wrote:As long as the guys face each other at some point, we've had it in the past where its a good domestic division but the boxers take different routes and we never really find out who was the best between them. The light middles a few years ago spring to mind.Boxingcutsman wrote:Tommy Gunn13 wrote:I agree Billy,it was only the 2nd time ive seen Keane..but to stop Mcphilbin that early was a good win..Im not slating your man,but what ive seen of him in the pros,hes yet to impress me..No doubt the better opponent,the better he will be..Personally,i think the Cruiserweights in the UK over the next 6-18months well be very interesting,with some good fights out there
Very well said Tommy Gunn
-
Boxingcutsman
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 783
- Joined: 30 May 2012, 21:35
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
I can say 100% that we (team Keane) are willing to fight anybody just like we've been trying to for the last 3 and a half yrs since Chris turned pro. We hope has much has anyone that politics don't get in the way, and hold us back no longer. we've been waiting a long time to get moving in the right direction that were finally moving in now, that's all thanks to Errol Johnson who has had faith & helped us without no big promoter, backer or sponsorship at all, and were not willing to let the chances go when we get them, no matter what or who stands in the way. We believe Chris is the best in Britain already and were confident enough and willing to put that to the test against any of the top 10 in Britain 
-
billy nelson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 1966
- Joined: 12 Apr 2010, 12:49
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
I no longer coach stephen but is it not fact he was to fight you in your home town with no complaints from us? Yet when the show got switched to Glasgow your underwear filled up and you pulled out the fight.Boxingcutsman wrote:I can say 100% that we (team Keane) are willing to fight anybody just like we've been trying to for the last 3 and a half yrs since Chris turned pro. We hope has much has anyone that politics don't get in the way, and hold us back no longer. we've been waiting a long time to get moving in the right direction that were finally moving in now, that's all thanks to Errol Johnson who has had faith & helped us without no big promoter, backer or sponsorship at all, and were not willing to let the chances go when we get them, no matter what or who stands in the way. We believe Chris is the best in Britain already and were confident enough and willing to put that to the test against any of the top 10 in Britain
Stephen and i never moaned about fighting in your hometown with english referees or judges yet YOUR team did,so your being a little misleading shall we say that your team were willing to fight anyone anywhere.
Mate im not saying Chris isnt a decent fighter he is but imo hes certainly not the best cruiser in the UK.
-
kells
- Heavyweight

Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
why dont u train him billy?
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
You stillfighting kells got a fight for you in march if you fancy it?
-
Boxingcutsman
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 783
- Joined: 30 May 2012, 21:35
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
I no longer coach stephen but is it not fact he was to fight you in your home town with no complaints from us? Yet when the show got switched to Glasgow your underwear filled up and you pulled out the fight.billy nelson wrote:Boxingcutsman wrote:I can say 100% that we (team Keane) are willing to fight anybody just like we've been trying to for the last 3 and a half yrs since Chris turned pro. We hope has much has anyone that politics don't get in the way, and hold us back no longer. we've been waiting a long time to get moving in the right direction that were finally moving in now, that's all thanks to Errol Johnson who has had faith & helped us without no big promoter, backer or sponsorship at all, and were not willing to let the chances go when we get them, no matter what or who stands in the way. We believe Chris is the best in Britain already and were confident enough and willing to put that to the test against any of the top 10 in Britain
Stephen and i never moaned about fighting in your hometown with english referees or judges yet YOUR team did,so your being a little misleading shall we say that your team were willing to fight anyone anywhere.
Mate im not saying Chris isnt a decent fighter he is but imo hes certainly not the best cruiser in the UK.
Who do you think is the best in UK then Billy ? We never actually said NO, and that can be proven. I cant believe your trying to insinuate we we're scared aswell lol. Stephen doesn't even punch mate, all he's got is a good work rate, why would anyone be scared ? I've heard some shit but that's the worst I've ever heard Billy. I guarantee you this mate 100% if and when they fight, Stephen will definitely get knocked out.
-
billy nelson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 1966
- Joined: 12 Apr 2010, 12:49
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
Well me and you can have a wager on the outcome if and when it happens?Boxingcutsman wrote:I no longer coach stephen but is it not fact he was to fight you in your home town with no complaints from us? Yet when the show got switched to Glasgow your underwear filled up and you pulled out the fight.billy nelson wrote:Boxingcutsman wrote:I can say 100% that we (team Keane) are willing to fight anybody just like we've been trying to for the last 3 and a half yrs since Chris turned pro. We hope has much has anyone that politics don't get in the way, and hold us back no longer. we've been waiting a long time to get moving in the right direction that were finally moving in now, that's all thanks to Errol Johnson who has had faith & helped us without no big promoter, backer or sponsorship at all, and were not willing to let the chances go when we get them, no matter what or who stands in the way. We believe Chris is the best in Britain already and were confident enough and willing to put that to the test against any of the top 10 in Britain
Stephen and i never moaned about fighting in your hometown with english referees or judges yet YOUR team did,so your being a little misleading shall we say that your team were willing to fight anyone anywhere.
Mate im not saying Chris isnt a decent fighter he is but imo hes certainly not the best cruiser in the UK.
Who do you think is the best in UK then Billy ? We never actually said NO, and that can be proven. I cant believe your trying to insinuate we we're scared aswell lol. Stephen doesn't even punch mate, all he's got is a good work rate, why would anyone be scared ? I've heard some shit but that's the worst I've ever heard Billy. I guarantee you this mate 100% if and when they fight, Stephen will definitely get knocked out.
-
billy nelson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 1966
- Joined: 12 Apr 2010, 12:49
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
What Stephen can do is punch very correctly and plenty hard enough,all of a sudden Christ is a puncher I dont think so mate!Boxingcutsman wrote:I no longer coach stephen but is it not fact he was to fight you in your home town with no complaints from us? Yet when the show got switched to Glasgow your underwear filled up and you pulled out the fight.billy nelson wrote:Boxingcutsman wrote:I can say 100% that we (team Keane) are willing to fight anybody just like we've been trying to for the last 3 and a half yrs since Chris turned pro. We hope has much has anyone that politics don't get in the way, and hold us back no longer. we've been waiting a long time to get moving in the right direction that were finally moving in now, that's all thanks to Errol Johnson who has had faith & helped us without no big promoter, backer or sponsorship at all, and were not willing to let the chances go when we get them, no matter what or who stands in the way. We believe Chris is the best in Britain already and were confident enough and willing to put that to the test against any of the top 10 in Britain
Stephen and i never moaned about fighting in your hometown with english referees or judges yet YOUR team did,so your being a little misleading shall we say that your team were willing to fight anyone anywhere.
Mate im not saying Chris isnt a decent fighter he is but imo hes certainly not the best cruiser in the UK.
Who do you think is the best in UK then Billy ? We never actually said NO, and that can be proven. I cant believe your trying to insinuate we we're scared aswell lol. Stephen doesn't even punch mate, all he's got is a good work rate, why would anyone be scared ? I've heard some shit but that's the worst I've ever heard Billy. I guarantee you this mate 100% if and when they fight, Stephen will definitely get knocked out.
Simmons will beat Chris with ease its all about levels and Stephen is levels above Chris,so get some cash out when if it happens, I will match what you earn for the fight no problem but being a nice guy I will buy you a beer afterwards
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
Chris is an improved fighter, Sparring will be the deciding factor for him, you gotta mix with people who take you out your comfort zone and push you to new limits.. You don't wanna be taken to them places in fights and you've not experienced it in the gym..
I think this is a good division domestically I really do! Price,JLD,Askin,Chris,Simmons!! All good fighters..
I think this is a good division domestically I really do! Price,JLD,Askin,Chris,Simmons!! All good fighters..
-
Boxingcutsman
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 783
- Joined: 30 May 2012, 21:35
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
I no longer coach stephen but is it not fact he was to fight you in your home town with no complaints from us? Yet when the show got switched to Glasgow your underwear filled up and you pulled out the fight.billy nelson wrote:
Stephen and i never moaned about fighting in your hometown with english referees or judges yet YOUR team did,so your being a little misleading shall we say that your team were willing to fight anyone anywhere.
Mate im not saying Chris isnt a decent fighter he is but imo hes certainly not the best cruiser in the UK.
Who do you think is the best in UK then Billy ? We never actually said NO, and that can be proven. I cant believe your trying to insinuate we we're scared aswell lol. Stephen doesn't even punch mate, all he's got is a good work rate, why would anyone be scared ? I've heard some shit but that's the worst I've ever heard Billy. I guarantee you this mate 100% if and when they fight, Stephen will definitely get knocked out.[/quote]Well me and you can have a wager on the outcome if and when it happens?[/quote]
Yes most definitely mate
-
Boxingcutsman
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 783
- Joined: 30 May 2012, 21:35
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
[/quote]What Stephen can do is punch very correctly and plenty hard enough,all of a sudden Christ is a puncher I dont think so mate!
Simmons will beat Chris with ease its all about levels and Stephen is levels above Chris,so get some cash out when if it happens, I will match what you earn for the fight no problem but being a nice guy I will buy you a beer afterwards
[/quote]
Hahaha Chris is not all of a sudden a puncher Billy, he's always been a puncher
he's only the 2nd person in the ABA's to knock out all his opponents at heavyweight mate and nearly all in the nations aswell. He only had 24 amateur fights and he knocked out 20 of them, now even you have to admit that's good going Billy. Stephen struggled with Taher Memhed pal, Chris had him reeling and let him off because we had told him to get some rounds in, same has Hastings Rasani. So He's not all of a sudden a puncher mate by any means
And yes either way of the out come I'd like a drink with you anyway pal, I like your banter and respect you has a trainer
(but Chris will win KO)

Simmons will beat Chris with ease its all about levels and Stephen is levels above Chris,so get some cash out when if it happens, I will match what you earn for the fight no problem but being a nice guy I will buy you a beer afterwards
Hahaha Chris is not all of a sudden a puncher Billy, he's always been a puncher
And yes either way of the out come I'd like a drink with you anyway pal, I like your banter and respect you has a trainer
Last edited by Boxingcutsman on 29 Jan 2013, 06:20, edited 1 time in total.
-
Boxingcutsman
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 783
- Joined: 30 May 2012, 21:35
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
Bomber 1 wrote:Chris is an improved fighter, Sparring will be the deciding factor for him, you gotta mix with people who take you out your comfort zone and push you to new limits.. You don't wanna be taken to them places in fights and you've not experienced it in the gym..![]()
I think this is a good division domestically I really do! Price,JLD,Askin,Chris,Simmons!! All good fighters..
Fair point there Tony
We've tried getting him the best sparring has we can when we can, has you say thats where he's gonna learn and need to learn and make his mistakes and correct them. We've been quite lucky to date with i.e Enzo Macranelli, Micheal Sprott, yourself a couple times Tony, Juno Hoopja(he just took Masternak the distance for EBU Cruiser title), Dereck Chisora, Ian Lewison, the list is endless really in the UK plus we've had interest and offers from Nathan Cleverly & just the other day Jonathan Banks, so in that department it's been has good has can be really, the next step is going over to Europe to spar with the likes of Branco, Fraggomenni, Afolabi, Mormeck, Huck, Adamek, that's our next aim with some big names and experienced Cruiserweight's.
it's great for boxing that another division in Britain is hotting up.
Re: Chris Keane Best British Cruiserweight since David Haye ?
christ has resurrected his career as a puncher....miraculousbilly nelson wrote:What Stephen can do is punch very correctly and plenty hard enough,all of a sudden Christ is a puncher I dont think so mate!
Simmons will beat Chris with ease its all about levels and Stephen is levels above Chris,so get some cash out when if it happens, I will match what you earn for the fight no problem but being a nice guy I will buy you a beer afterwards