http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/news ... -rate.html
Events like Froch Vs. Kessler might be used to get non-SKY Sports subscribers to cough up £9.99 for a day pass. It's PPV, but not as we know it
I'm sorry but that's an utterly ridiculous idea if you apply it to any programme you want to watch. Essentially it would prevent anyone from changing channels without having to pay in advance! Ludicruous, unworkable and would never be implemented.JLP wrote:That is a good idea and more along the lines of what I have been calling for for years. I've long believed all TV should be PAYG on demand i.e. no licence or platform fees and no package fees. If you want to watch a programme, you pay for it there and then. The quality of programming would sky-rocket as result.
There would obviously be trailers and opportunities for programme makers to market their wares. If you walk into a shop you get to have a look, but not a taste (usually), before you buy.SteveDow wrote:I'm sorry but that's an utterly ridiculous idea if you apply it to any programme you want to watch. Essentially it would prevent anyone from changing channels without having to pay in advance! Ludicruous, unworkable and would never be implemented.JLP wrote:That is a good idea and more along the lines of what I have been calling for for years. I've long believed all TV should be PAYG on demand i.e. no licence or platform fees and no package fees. If you want to watch a programme, you pay for it there and then. The quality of programming would sky-rocket as result.
That's the retailer's problem. If £9.99 doesn't work, they'll either make it more affordable or sack the idea off. You don't need to worry about it.Final round wrote:Disregarding the Froch/Kessler fight as it doesn't mention it in the link, most people wont cough up 9.99 to watch a football match on their laptop.
The point is that people don't always know what they want to watch. When people buy a TV they are buying it in the knowledge that they are getting a certain number of channels for free. These channels will sometimes contain programmes they want to watch and sometimes they won't but how on earth could it be practicable for someone to have to plan in advance what they want to watch at all times? Most people come home from work and just switch the TV on and flick between channels and eventually decide on something they want to watch. People wouldn't want to be making concious payment decisions everytime they switch the TV on! The idea of not penalising existing Sky customers by charging them PPV is one I very much applaud but that's entirely different to what you propose which is charging someone for everything they watch.JLP wrote:There would obviously be trailers and opportunities for programme makers to market their wares. If you walk into a shop you get to have a look, but not a taste (usually), before you buy.SteveDow wrote:I'm sorry but that's an utterly ridiculous idea if you apply it to any programme you want to watch. Essentially it would prevent anyone from changing channels without having to pay in advance! Ludicruous, unworkable and would never be implemented.JLP wrote:That is a good idea and more along the lines of what I have been calling for for years. I've long believed all TV should be PAYG on demand i.e. no licence or platform fees and no package fees. If you want to watch a programme, you pay for it there and then. The quality of programming would sky-rocket as result.
Edit: at the moment with TV you have to pay your licence before you see anything and if you want Sky you have to pay your subscription before you see anything. Why is that good for the customer? You might want to watch Man U vs Arsenal but not snooker, for example. Why do you have to pay for both? And why am I subsidising some geek watching some dross on BBC 4?
eh? I'm giving my opinion on their proposal.JLP wrote:That's the retailer's problem. If £9.99 doesn't work, they'll either make it more affordable or sack the idea off. You don't need to worry about it.Final round wrote:Disregarding the Froch/Kessler fight as it doesn't mention it in the link, most people wont cough up 9.99 to watch a football match on their laptop.
SteveDow wrote:The point is that people don't always know what they want to watch. When people buy a TV they are buying it in the knowledge that they are getting a certain number of channels for free. These channels will sometimes contain programmes they want to watch and sometimes they won't but how on earth could it be practicable for someone to have to plan in advance what they want to watch at all times? Most people come home from work and just switch the TV on and flick between channels and eventually decide on something they want to watch. People wouldn't want to be making concious payment decisions everytime they switch the TV on! The idea of not penalising existing Sky customers by charging them PPV is one I very much applaud but that's entirely different to what you propose which is charging someone for everything they watch.
The TV licence pays solely for the BBC channels so you get every other channels that is not a BBC channel for free.JLP wrote:SteveDow wrote:The point is that people don't always know what they want to watch. When people buy a TV they are buying it in the knowledge that they are getting a certain number of channels for free. These channels will sometimes contain programmes they want to watch and sometimes they won't but how on earth could it be practicable for someone to have to plan in advance what they want to watch at all times? Most people come home from work and just switch the TV on and flick between channels and eventually decide on something they want to watch. People wouldn't want to be making concious payment decisions everytime they switch the TV on! The idea of not penalising existing Sky customers by charging them PPV is one I very much applaud but that's entirely different to what you propose which is charging someone for everything they watch.
You don't get any channels for free now, you pay (or you should pay) £145.50 per year before you are allowed to turn your television on and you get what you're given, like it or not, watch it or not.
You don't always know what you want to watch but you don't always know what you'll buy from the Chinese, you have a look at the menu and the description and then you decide. You're still taking a bit of a risk, the food might turn out to be less than expected but how long will the Chinese stay in business if the stuff it serves up is invariably shite? And you certainly don't have to pay to merely have the Chinese as an available option that you may or may not use.
To use me as an example. I only watch sport on TV. Boxing, MMA, Rugby, Cricket, American Football. That's it. I don't want to watch anything else. I don't want to pay to watch anything else. I am more than prepared to pay to watch those five sports. I do not want to pay for things I don't watch, which is what I am legally bound to do now if I wish to own a television set. Your standpoint seems illogical to me. Mine seems the opposite.
I agree more with your later points but it still wouldn't be practicable for every programme to be pay per view. Channel schedules need to be filled and sometimes that is with programmes almost nobody would buy. PPV only works with special events. It didn't even work with football on Sky a few years ago and was abandoned.JLP wrote:SteveDow wrote:The point is that people don't always know what they want to watch. When people buy a TV they are buying it in the knowledge that they are getting a certain number of channels for free. These channels will sometimes contain programmes they want to watch and sometimes they won't but how on earth could it be practicable for someone to have to plan in advance what they want to watch at all times? Most people come home from work and just switch the TV on and flick between channels and eventually decide on something they want to watch. People wouldn't want to be making concious payment decisions everytime they switch the TV on! The idea of not penalising existing Sky customers by charging them PPV is one I very much applaud but that's entirely different to what you propose which is charging someone for everything they watch.
You don't get any channels for free now, you pay (or you should pay) £145.50 per year before you are allowed to turn your television on and you get what you're given, like it or not, watch it or not.
You don't always know what you want to watch but you don't always know what you'll buy from the Chinese, you have a look at the menu and the description and then you decide. You're still taking a bit of a risk, the food might turn out to be less than expected but how long will the Chinese stay in business if the stuff it serves up is invariably shite? And you certainly don't have to pay to merely have the Chinese as an available option that you may or may not use.
To use me as an example. I only watch sport on TV. Boxing, MMA, Rugby, Cricket, American Football. That's it. I don't want to watch anything else. I don't want to pay to watch anything else. I am more than prepared to pay to watch those five sports. I do not want to pay for things I don't watch, which is what I am legally bound to do now if I wish to own a television set. Your standpoint seems illogical to me. Mine seems the opposite.
Just to add to make myself clear: I think the Licence Fee should go and I don't like the Sky subscription model.
Genuinely free to air TV (i.e. not subsidised by the tax payer) is fine, be it commercially driven through advertising, philanthropic, or what have you. Other than that you should be able to buy what you choose to watch and only what you choose to watch.
Why is it unworkable? I don't think we should pay taxes at all. I think it's inefficient.SteveDow wrote:Just to put a different slant on this, in an ideal world we'd all only like to pay for what we use but in reality that's unworkable. I'd only like my taxes to go on things I specifically use rather than to pay for people to live on benefits which I don't claim but it's just not possible for services to operate in this individualistic way. The same applies for TV. There has to be a payment made into a big pot and how that payment is used is determined by the people governing the channel in question.
This might interest you:JLP wrote:Why is it unworkable? I don't think we should pay taxes at all. I think it's inefficient.SteveDow wrote:Just to put a different slant on this, in an ideal world we'd all only like to pay for what we use but in reality that's unworkable. I'd only like my taxes to go on things I specifically use rather than to pay for people to live on benefits which I don't claim but it's just not possible for services to operate in this individualistic way. The same applies for TV. There has to be a payment made into a big pot and how that payment is used is determined by the people governing the channel in question.
Anyway, with TV what I'm suggesting could work and I think it's the way things will go. Especially as TV and online fuse further.
A guy like Dave Coldwell could have his shows on the boxing planner as an option for people to purchase. He couldn't do that on Freeview or Sky right now.
That just backs up eveything I've said about the idea being currently unworkable across all channels. I don't see how the concept could ever catch on across all channels and JLP was suggesting that that was the way he'd prefer to go.chad wrote:This might interest you:JLP wrote:Why is it unworkable? I don't think we should pay taxes at all. I think it's inefficient.SteveDow wrote:Just to put a different slant on this, in an ideal world we'd all only like to pay for what we use but in reality that's unworkable. I'd only like my taxes to go on things I specifically use rather than to pay for people to live on benefits which I don't claim but it's just not possible for services to operate in this individualistic way. The same applies for TV. There has to be a payment made into a big pot and how that payment is used is determined by the people governing the channel in question.
Anyway, with TV what I'm suggesting could work and I think it's the way things will go. Especially as TV and online fuse further.
A guy like Dave Coldwell could have his shows on the boxing planner as an option for people to purchase. He couldn't do that on Freeview or Sky right now.
http://www.broadbandtvnews.com/2013/01/ ... n-5-years/