British Top 30 P4P March 2013

[Horse]

1. (1.) Carl Froch
2. (2.) Ricky Burns
3. (3.) David Haye
4. (4.) Amir Khan
5. (5.) Nathan Cleverly
6. (6.) Ola Afolabi
7. (7.) Kell Brook
8. (8.) Matthew Macklin
9. (9.) George Groves
10. (18.) Carl Frampton

11. (10.) Tyson Fury
12. (11.) Jamie McDonnell
13. (13.) Scott Quigg
14. (14.) James DeGale
15. (25.) Lee Selby
16. (12.) Gavin Rees
17. (15.) Darren Barker
18. (16.) Tony Bellew
19. (19.) Martin Murray
20. (20.) Gary Buckland

21. (24.) Andy Lee (Irish)
22. (28.) Kevin Satchell
23. (17.) David Price
24. (21.) Brian Magee (Irish)
25. (22.) Brian Rose
26. (23.) Frankie Gavin
27. (26.) Kevin Mitchell
28. (27.) Lee Haskins
29. (29.) Rendall Munroe
30. (30.) Dereck Chisora

[Horse]

Any comments or criticisms of the British Top 30 P4P list are very welcome.

[TheGoods]

Munroe is retired.

[Pugilist-specialist]

If P4P stands for Pound for Pound, Khan shouldn't be ranked above Brook at welterweight.

Munroe has retired - Kid Galahad is no.2 in Europe at his weight.

Haye deserves to be lower for entering celebrity shows instead of boxing.

Good effort as ever from TescoValueBurger.

[keithmoonhangover]

If P4P stands for Pound for Pound, Khan shouldn't be ranked above Brook at welterweight.

Munroe has retired - Kid Galahad is no.2 in Europe at his weight.

Haye deserves to be lower for entering celebrity shows instead of boxing.

Good effort as ever from TescoValueBurger.

Legend.

[Deno1986]

What time do you call this, Horse? I have never seen you late before with your list!

[Horse]

Munroe is retired.

I know.

[Horse]

If P4P stands for Pound for Pound, Khan shouldn't be ranked above Brook at welterweight.

If Khan moves up to welterweight, I will still take his past achievements at light welterweight into account. Khan belongs above Brook for now.

Munroe has retired - Kid Galahad is no.2 in Europe at his weight.

Galahad should be ranked below Frampton, Quigg and Martinez.

Haye deserves to be lower for entering celebrity shows instead of boxing.

I might drop Haye a few places soon.

Good effort as ever from TescoValueBurger.

Cheers.

[ThereByTheGrace]

Where the hell is Audley?

[Ratchet Exits Nu]

Where the hell is Audley?

Indeed! Where de Haudley?

[expe]

Quigg should be above Frampton, Selby is too high, Mitchell should be higher, Munroe is retired, Chisora should be higher, Satchell is too high and why has Andy Lee moved up? Macklin should be above Brook. Buckland is too high.

[Pugilist-specialist]

Munroe has retired - Kid Galahad is no.2 in Europe at his weight.

Galahad should be ranked below Frampton, Quigg and Martinez.

But he's above Munroe as he's no longer ranked.

[Pugilist-specialist]

If P4P stands for Pound for Pound, Khan shouldn't be ranked above Brook at welterweight.

If Khan moves up to welterweight, I will still take his past achievements at light welterweight into account. Khan belongs above Brook for now.

Would you then call your rankings "previous weight rankings" rather than "P4P"?

[Looking On]

Of course Khan should be ranked above Brook , While i may be of the opinion that i think Brook would beat Khan hes not done anything to justify being above Khan , Khans beaten better opponents , won world titles etc etc


Munroe im sure will gradually drop out of the rankings as he wont be boxing to improve his position where others will be doing so .


Good stuff Horse , no complaints from me

[Horse]

What time do you call this, Horse? I have never seen you late before with your list!

I didn't realize a new month had started until later in the day.

Sorry about the delay, Deno1986.

[Horse]

Where the hell is Audley?

I didn't think his Prizefighter wins were enough to give him a place this month.

[ThereByTheGrace]

Where the hell is Audley?

I didn't think his Prizefighter wins were enough to give him a place this month.

Ah ok, so he is number 31 then? Maybe best to have a British Top 31 next month Horse to quell the masses!

[Horse]

Quigg should be above Frampton, Selby is too high, Mitchell should be higher, Munroe is retired, Chisora should be higher,

Frampton has done more over the last 12 months, so I think he deserves to be ahead of Quigg at the moment. Selby has been cleaning house domestically better than anyone else recently. Mitchell hasn't won a fight in over a year and Burns destroyed him. Chisora will move up when he fights again.

Satchell is too high and why has Andy Lee moved up? Macklin should be above Brook. Buckland is too high.

Satchell and Lee moved up because they both won last month. They both moved up more than they normally would due to the larger than normal amount of fighters in the bottom 10 who are coming off a loss.

Macklin is far more proven than Brook at world level, so I can see why you would have Macklin higher. Buckland is on good form and he has established himself as the domestic No. 1 at his weight.

[Horse]

Would you then call your rankings "previous weight rankings" rather than "P4P"?

No.

Have you not seen many P4P lists before?

[Horse]

Of course Khan should be ranked above Brook , While i may be of the opinion that i think Brook would beat Khan hes not done anything to justify being above Khan , Khans beaten better opponents , won world titles etc etc


Munroe im sure will gradually drop out of the rankings as he wont be boxing to improve his position where others will be doing so .


Good stuff Horse , no complaints from me

[Horse]

Ah ok, so he is number 31 then? Maybe best to have a British Top 31 next month Horse to quell the masses!

I'll keep it at 30.

[Parson Cross]

Quote Chisora moves up when he fights again.
TescoSoothsayerBurger
Best get on the fixed odds.
Give us a "nod" with the lottery numbers

[expe]

Quigg should be above Frampton, Selby is too high, Mitchell should be higher, Munroe is retired, Chisora should be higher,

Frampton has done more over the last 12 months, so I think he deserves to be ahead of Quigg at the moment. Selby has been cleaning house domestically better than anyone else recently. Mitchell hasn't won a fight in over a year and Burns destroyed him. Chisora will move up when he fights again.

Satchell is too high and why has Andy Lee moved up? Macklin should be above Brook. Buckland is too high.

Satchell and Lee moved up because they both won last month. They both moved up more than they normally would due to the larger than normal amount of fighters in the bottom 10 who are coming off a loss.

Macklin is far more proven than Brook at world level, so I can see why you would have Macklin higher. Buckland is on good form and he has established himself as the domestic No. 1 at his weight.

Fair enough with those, I suppose it depends on how much you take recent performances into account, Mitchell hasn't won in a year but has wins over Murray, Prescott and Johanneson in the past and has fought for a world title, but has 1 meaningful win over Murray in the last 3 years.

[Ratchet Exits Nu]

Should Rees be dropped for losing to Broner?

[Horse]

Should Rees be dropped for losing to Broner?

I thought so.