How risky is amateur boxing?

Post Reply
johnreilly
Super Middleweight
Posts: 33
Joined: 14 Jan 2013, 07:43

How risky is amateur boxing?

Post by johnreilly »

After the sad death of pro-boxer Michael Norgrave, Headway - a charity associated with brain injuries - had this to say:
The death of boxer Michael Norgrove, who died after collapsing in the ring, is another tragic and deeply saddening example of the brutal and dangerous nature of a sport that should not be allowed to continue. Every time a boxer gets into the ring, there is a significant risk that they may lose their life or sustain a devastating, life-changing brain injury.
(https://www.headway.org.uk/news/headway ... afety.aspx)

A different opinion was put forward by a writer at Inside the Games. In his article he said over the last 27 years there have been four deaths and 21 boxers who required emergency surgery in professional and amateur contests in the UK (http://www.insidethegames.biz/blogs/101 ... -the-sport)

So that's 25 tragedies in a 27 year period. Would anyone like to volunteer a guess for how many pro and amateur contests there have been in the last 27 years? And then discuss whether 27 incidents in X-thousands of contests constitutes a "significant risk"?

My gut feeling? Boxing injuries are a real risk. But the pro and amateur bodies in the UK have rules and standards in place to reduce those risks to an acceptable level. When I step into a ring I understand and have accepted those risks. Headway should be working with boxers to educate them, rather than calling for the sport we love to be banned.
JMac
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 2308
Joined: 06 Sep 2007, 14:41

Re: How risky is amateur boxing?

Post by JMac »

johnreilly wrote: When I step into a ring I understand and have accepted those risks. Headway should be working with boxers to educate them, rather than calling for the sport we love to be banned.
Agreed.
Tarquin Tarpaulin V
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 68
Joined: 14 Sep 2009, 16:40

Re: How risky is amateur boxing?

Post by Tarquin Tarpaulin V »

Headway have featured on the radio here in the UK several times.

Boxing is an easy target but they'll just as happily have a go at Football (Soccer) players for heading a ball throughout their careers and any other sport where head injury could be an issue.
polecateddy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: How risky is amateur boxing?

Post by polecateddy »

I reckon if you do ten years of amateur boxing you're bound to end up with some brain damage. Chances are you won't end up with a lisp, but you may forget where you left your keys in later life.
Zelley
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 298
Joined: 17 Sep 2008, 23:10

Re: How risky is amateur boxing?

Post by Zelley »

polecateddy wrote:I reckon if you do ten years of amateur boxing you're bound to end up with some brain damage. Chances are you won't end up with a lisp, but you may forget where you left your keys in later life.
One does not need to step outside of the home, to worry about potential brain damage or accidents.
Even the shut-ins have a high risk of slips and falls from stairs, bathtubs and try going outside n
the winter. One does not need to go to boxing gym to worry about risks. Try stepping on an icy
sloping driveway - now that is brain damage or back injuries just waiting to happen, but I don't
see any rants about slip and fall in your own driveway, and if it is some other driveway well
some folks with no injuries will become academy award like actors in a blink of an eye to milk
the system.
Post Reply