Packey McFarland ND10 Mike Gibbons

[Senya13]

Why has it been changed to newspaper draw? Are the sources I have provided, together with explanation why each one of them was included in the count (ie, it wasn't a re-print of another report), not enough? 18 votes for McFarland, 9 for Gibbons and 4 for a draw. More votes for McFarland's win than Gibbons and draw combined, by considerable margin. People may talk that they don't see decision in favor of McFarland on film that has survived, but is it enough to overrule the newspaper votes?

[dnahar32]

I changed it back to a McFarland win and left a note about the consensus newspaper decisions that you mentioned.