Martin Power Vs Ian Napa

MPG
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 642
Joined: 14 Aug 2005, 17:06

Post by MPG »

I have seen that martin power is boxing david gueault for the european

(ebu-eu) title on december 3rd.

I have also seen that simone maludrottu will be defending his european(ebu) title against carmelo ballone on 11/12/2005 next week.

Could anybody tell me the difference between each title and do they have any views on david gueault.

I rate power as an excellent boxer and taking on this fight has impress me,with away advantage aswell and experience going against him.

I would still tip him to win and was hoping others would share their opions with me. :box:
Freiheit
Editor
Editor
Posts: 2851
Joined: 28 Dec 2001, 20:00

Post by Freiheit »

EU is a small EBU wher eonly boxers that are EU citizens can fight for. Its almost like the intercontineltal belt for the world federations, but here there are mandatory defenses.

Guerault used to be a good boxer but he has faded badly the last couple of years.
stujones
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 27489
Joined: 29 Aug 2003, 15:08

Post by stujones »

I cannot see the Gueault fight happening, not so soon after the war with Napa.

I believe Gueault has slipped a bit, but if he is anything like the fighter who destroyed Ady Lewis then he will beat Power, Gueault (used to be at least) fringe world class, and I would say Power is fringe European title class. Different level, unless he is shot.
Max Molyneux
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7084
Joined: 16 Aug 2004, 16:53

Post by Max Molyneux »

Broncano wrote:Has anybody seen Craig Watson, (Khan's amateur nemesis) who is on the undercard of this. Is there any chance his fight will be shown in the broadcast?
They should set Khan up with him. :TU:
J
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 8015
Joined: 17 Feb 2004, 12:39

Post by J »

GREAT TUNE THAT NAPA CAME INTO THOUGH!

jamrock by damien marley, can well recomend the album.

i thotuhgt napa was unlucky but tough fight to score.

power I thought was overtly dismissive inthe post fight interview you didnt win it easily son it could have gone either way so less of the cockiness. :wink:
nickd
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7071
Joined: 17 Mar 2004, 13:45

Post by nickd »

Was anyone at York Hall? What was all that trouble outside the ring all about?
somerstown
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 97
Joined: 28 Jan 2004, 15:33

Post by somerstown »

nickd wrote:Was anyone at York Hall? What was all that trouble outside the ring all about?
Seems to have started in the bar and dragged through to the main hall.
A lot of comotion and a couple of flare ups on the way to the main doors, but not really anything to talk about.
I thought it was very close on the night but after watching it back on tape I had Power winning 116 - 113, but some rounds could have gone either way. Good idea to now have 3 judges. Great fight.
MPG
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 642
Joined: 14 Aug 2005, 17:06

Post by MPG »

I AGREE WITH THE 116 - 113 SCORE CARD HAVING WATCH IT AGAIN

MYSELF,BRILLENT FIGHT.

MARTIN POWER HAS TO DEFEND AGAINST ISSACK WARD INSIDE THREE MONTHS,

BUT COULD ANYBODY HELP ME OUT,I AM CONFUSED BUT HOW DOES ISSACK WARD BECOME NUMBER 1 CONTENDER TO FIGHT FOR THE BRITISH BAMTANWEIGHT TITLE WHEN HE HAS MAINLY FOUGHT AT FEATHER AND SUPER FEATHER WEIGHT.
nickd
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7071
Joined: 17 Mar 2004, 13:45

Post by nickd »

On the fight I scored a draw, there have to be serious concerns over Power's chin though as Napa can't crack an egg but had him in serious bother. I'd love to see a rematch.
tea
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 291
Joined: 25 Apr 2003, 17:03

Post by tea »

martin_g wrote:I AGREE WITH THE 116 - 113 SCORE CARD HAVING WATCH IT AGAIN

MYSELF,BRILLENT FIGHT.

MARTIN POWER HAS TO DEFEND AGAINST ISSACK WARD INSIDE THREE MONTHS,

BUT COULD ANYBODY HELP ME OUT,I AM CONFUSED BUT HOW DOES ISSACK WARD BECOME NUMBER 1 CONTENDER TO FIGHT FOR THE BRITISH BAMTANWEIGHT TITLE WHEN HE HAS MAINLY FOUGHT AT FEATHER AND SUPER FEATHER WEIGHT.
Isaac Ward was 8 7 last time out and previous to that boxed at around 8 10.....so he`s bantam....Power got two back to back controversial decisions over blown up flyweights,hardly inspiring.Geurault used to be an excellent fighter but has faded.....but Power is strictly domestic class.
MPG
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 642
Joined: 14 Aug 2005, 17:06

Post by MPG »

JUST HAD A LOOK AT BOXREC AND THEY HAVE ISSACK WARD RATED AS A SUPER FEATHERWEIGHT,

I HAVE ALSO HAD A LOOK AT HIS RECORD AND HAVE SEEN THAT IN ALL OF HIS FIGHTS HE HAS ONLY WEIGHT IN AS A BANTAMWEIGHT ONCE

WHICH WAS LAST TIME OUT BECAUSE HE HAD ALREADY BEEN CHOSEN TO FIGHT THE WINNER OF POWER VERUS NAPA,AND THEREFORE HAD TO GET DOWN TO BANTAMWEIGHT TO PREPARE HIMSELF FOR THE WINNER AS HE HAS NEVER FOUGHT AT BANTAM.

HIS TWO FIGHTS PREVIOUSLY WAS AT FEATHER AND SUPER FEATHERWEIGHT.

:TU:
steve689
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 9660
Joined: 20 Jan 2003, 13:50

Post by steve689 »

I had Napa winning by a couple of rounds, its a shame he can't punch a bit harder. Power dismissed him a bit too much afterwards "There aint no way you won that fight" he said in an accent i can't decipher, i thought it was very tight and Power knew it.
nickd
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7071
Joined: 17 Mar 2004, 13:45

Post by nickd »

steve689 wrote:I had Napa winning by a couple of rounds, its a shame he can't punch a bit harder. Power dismissed him a bit too much afterwards "There aint no way you won that fight" he said in an accent i can't decipher, i thought it was very tight and Power knew it.
Power is a gypsy hence the odd accent. Power should definitely rematch Napa or Robinson.
Old bones Ian
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 11805
Joined: 13 Jul 2004, 07:33

Post by Old bones Ian »

nickd wrote: Power is a gypsy hence the odd accent. Power should definitely rematch Napa or Robinson.
Think Robinson is going to be back down in the fly/superfly divisions,
nickd
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7071
Joined: 17 Mar 2004, 13:45

Post by nickd »

On reflection I am not sure Power will go much further than domestic class, in all honesty he's been lucky in many peoples eyes to get by two much smaller flyweights in his 2 British title fights and both have had him hurt. Neither is a knockout puncher at fly let alone up at bantam, I have the feeling he might get stretched when he steps it up against genuine bantams at euro level.
MPG
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 642
Joined: 14 Aug 2005, 17:06

Post by MPG »

SORRY MATE BUT I WOULD HAVE TO DISAGREE WITH YOU,

I DONT THINK MARTIN POWER IS THE FINISHED FIGHTER YET AND I THINK HE WILL AT LEAST WIN A EUROPEAN TITLE AND MAYBE BOXED FOR A WORLD TITLE,

HE HAS JUST BEATEN THE TWO BEST BANTAMWEIGHTS IN THE COUNTRY AND BOTH WERE VERY TOUGH FIGHTS BUT I CANT SEE ALL OF HIS FIGHTS BEING AS TOUGH AS THESE FOR A WHILE.

HE DEFENDS HIS BRITISH TITLE AGAINST ISSAC WARD EARLY NEXT YEAR AND ISSAC NORMALLY FIGHTS AT FEATHERWEIGHT,WHICH I THINK POWER WILLL WIN.

I ALSO THINK THAT IF THE WERE TO BE A REMATCH BETWEEN NAPA OR ROBINSON,I THINK POWERS WOULD WIN EASIER BECAUSE I THINK LIKE ALL SKILFUL BOXERS DO,THEY LEARN FROM IT.
nickd
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7071
Joined: 17 Mar 2004, 13:45

Post by nickd »

martin_g wrote:SORRY MATE BUT I WOULD HAVE TO DISAGREE WITH YOU,

I DONT THINK MARTIN POWER IS THE FINISHED FIGHTER YET AND I THINK HE WILL AT LEAST WIN A EUROPEAN TITLE AND MAYBE BOXED FOR A WORLD TITLE,

HE HAS JUST BEATEN THE TWO BEST BANTAMWEIGHTS IN THE COUNTRY AND BOTH WERE VERY TOUGH FIGHTS BUT I CANT SEE ALL OF HIS FIGHTS BEING AS TOUGH AS THESE FOR A WHILE.

HE DEFENDS HIS BRITISH TITLE AGAINST ISSAC WARD EARLY NEXT YEAR AND ISSAC NORMALLY FIGHTS AT FEATHERWEIGHT,WHICH I THINK POWER WILLL WIN.

I ALSO THINK THAT IF THE WERE TO BE A REMATCH BETWEEN NAPA OR ROBINSON,I THINK POWERS WOULD WIN EASIER BECAUSE I THINK LIKE ALL SKILFUL BOXERS DO,THEY LEARN FROM IT.
I have to disagree with you, Napa and Robinson are not Bantamweights.
steve689
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 9660
Joined: 20 Jan 2003, 13:50

Post by steve689 »

nickd wrote:On reflection I am not sure Power will go much further than domestic class, in all honesty he's been lucky in many peoples eyes to get by two much smaller flyweights in his 2 British title fights and both have had him hurt. Neither is a knockout puncher at fly let alone up at bantam, I have the feeling he might get stretched when he steps it up against genuine bantams at euro level.
I agree with you, Power is a good fighter at British level but both wins have been very tight and against smaller guys. Talk of European class or above i think is too much at this stage, bit maybe down the line he could make that jump.
stujones
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 27489
Joined: 29 Aug 2003, 15:08

Post by stujones »

nickd wrote:
martin_g wrote:SORRY MATE BUT I WOULD HAVE TO DISAGREE WITH YOU,

I DONT THINK MARTIN POWER IS THE FINISHED FIGHTER YET AND I THINK HE WILL AT LEAST WIN A EUROPEAN TITLE AND MAYBE BOXED FOR A WORLD TITLE,

HE HAS JUST BEATEN THE TWO BEST BANTAMWEIGHTS IN THE COUNTRY AND BOTH WERE VERY TOUGH FIGHTS BUT I CANT SEE ALL OF HIS FIGHTS BEING AS TOUGH AS THESE FOR A WHILE.

HE DEFENDS HIS BRITISH TITLE AGAINST ISSAC WARD EARLY NEXT YEAR AND ISSAC NORMALLY FIGHTS AT FEATHERWEIGHT,WHICH I THINK POWER WILLL WIN.

I ALSO THINK THAT IF THE WERE TO BE A REMATCH BETWEEN NAPA OR ROBINSON,I THINK POWERS WOULD WIN EASIER BECAUSE I THINK LIKE ALL SKILFUL BOXERS DO,THEY LEARN FROM IT.
I have to disagree with you, Napa and Robinson are not Bantamweights.
Not only that but Napa offically lost to Callaghan. He thought Napa won, but Callaghan did close the score towards the end.
MPG
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 642
Joined: 14 Aug 2005, 17:06

Post by MPG »

I AGREE THAT ROBINSON MAY NOT BE A BANTAMWEIGHT BUT IAN NAPA LAST FIGHT WAS FOR THE SOUTHERN AREA SUPER BATAMWEIGHT TITLE,

I KNOW NAPA ALSO STARTED HIS CAREER AT FLY BUT DE LA HOYA STARTED HIS CAREER AT SUPER FEATHERWEIGHT AND MOVED ALL THE WAY UP TO LIGHT MIDDLE I THINK.

BOTHS FIGHTS WERE VERY CLOSE AND I FOR ONE WOULD LOVE TO SEE AGAIN.

IAN NAPA IMPRESSED ME WITH THE STRENGH HE SHOWED BUT AS FOR ROBINSON ,I THINK HE MAY BE FINISH (JUST MY OPION) BUT HE DIDNT LOOK HIMSELF IN HIS LAST FIGHT.
stujones
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 27489
Joined: 29 Aug 2003, 15:08

Post by stujones »

I do agree with Martin in that there isn't much left for Power domestically at Bantam, unless Wilders can get motivated.

Armour is shot, Culshaw seems to be retired and Wilders has looked more likely to fight at Feather than Welter.

Take Napa and Robinson out of the equation and the next fighter in the line is Mark Moran, who is a novice pro.
nickd
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7071
Joined: 17 Mar 2004, 13:45

Post by nickd »

Why no talk of rematches, both fights were excellent and close enough to warrant a second match.
MPG
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 642
Joined: 14 Aug 2005, 17:06

Post by MPG »

I AGREE THAT POWERS NEXT FIGHT SHOULD HAVE BEEN EITHER ROBINSON OR NAPA.

COULD SOMEBODY TELL ME HOW ISSAC WARD GETS A CHANCE BEFORE DALE ROBINSON OR NAPA.

RICKY OWEN HAS A BRIGHT FUTURE,NICE WIN LAST TIME OUT OVER RAKHIM MINGALEEV,
johnswan1
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3348
Joined: 27 Feb 2005, 18:03

Post by johnswan1 »

Powers record flatters him. I thought he had very little power and a poor chin. If Napa had the experience of a couple of knockouts on his record, he could have finished the fight and that would have been humiliating for Power. I do not expect Power to be anything better than British level and he'll be doing well to keep defending that a few more times.
plum6474
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 5
Joined: 08 Nov 2005, 16:26

Post by plum6474 »

do you know what your talking about mate obviously not!
Post Reply