Kelly Pavlik versus

[Vladimir5555]

Sumbu Kalambay
Iran Barkley
Felix Trinidad
Felix Sturm
Reggie Johnson

[Bobbyptsd]

He loses to Barkley on points, is stopped by Trinidad, stops Johnson and wins on points over Sturm and Kalambay.

Is my view.

[Vladimir5555]

Barkley W 12 Pavlik
Johnson SD 12 Pavlik
Pavlik TKO 9 Sturm
Kalambay W 12 Pavlik
Pavlik TKO 10 Trinidad

[Jaywheel]

He loses to Barkley on points, is stopped by Trinidad, stops Johnson and wins on points over Sturm and Kalambay.

Is my view.

So he beats Mugabi and Hamsho but loses to Barkley and Trinidad @ 160?

[The Great John L]

Pavlik TKO Barkley
Johnson UD Pavlik
Pavlik UD Sturm
Kalambay UD Pavlik
Pavlik TKO Trinidad

[Bobbyptsd]

He loses to Barkley on points, is stopped by Trinidad, stops Johnson and wins on points over Sturm and Kalambay.

Is my view.

So he beats Mugabi and Hamsho but loses to Barkley and Trinidad @ 160?

I don't think I said he beats Hamsho, I think I just singled out Nunn as someone I think definitely beats him. But I could be wrong, I'd have to go check that thread.

Regardless, I'm not as sure about Barkley and Hamsho, but Trinidad I am. He's made for him coming forward with a 1-2 style.

I also think Trinidad would have beaten Taylor, for what it's worth. I was always surprised they took the road they did (Wright, Jones) with him, when the top middleweights post-Hopkins were very good matchups for him in my view.