Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Foreman-Ali
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sTn9GeHs11I
Benn-Watson
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0DgsDran0Hc
Got any more?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sTn9GeHs11I
Benn-Watson
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0DgsDran0Hc
Got any more?
-
Old bones Ian
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 11811
- Joined: 13 Jul 2004, 07:33
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Both of those wouldn't of made any difference if allowed to go on. Benn and Foreman were finished in those fights
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Lewis akinwande
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
-
mickey1975
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 23192
- Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Yes.fantaheed wrote:Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
NOmickey1975 wrote:Yes.fantaheed wrote:Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j& ... 0277,d.ZWU
Some of you need to get a life FFS
-
mickey1975
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 23192
- Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
I don't understand? The count WAS long. As for getting a life, I've got one thanks, just popped on here and answered as I remembered. Sorry for that...taffytoon wrote:NOmickey1975 wrote:Yes.fantaheed wrote:Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j& ... 0277,d.ZWU
Some of you need to get a life FFS
-
Final round
- Cruiserweight
- Posts: 4911
- Joined: 20 Oct 2010, 17:02
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
There was some dubious counting in the Williams v Airich fight (as well as some good old early bell ringing ala Enzo v McPhilibin)
-
keithmoonhangover
- Cruiserweight
- Posts: 17152
- Joined: 16 Sep 2010, 10:42
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
In fairness, Tyson also got a long countmickey1975 wrote:Yes.fantaheed wrote:Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
-
mickey1975
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 23192
- Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Sorry, not got time to reply properly, I'm busy watching Tyson-Douglas on a loop, I don't have a life(despite my mrs and three kids and job, etc)...keithmoonhangover wrote:In fairness, Tyson also got a long countmickey1975 wrote:Yes.fantaheed wrote:Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Why is Foreman-Ali dubious?
Foreman goes down with 11 seconds left and is counted out at when the clock ticks 0. Don't go by the commentator's erroneous count--he starts at one when Foreman has been down for several seconds, failing to consider that the ref looked over to the person taking the count and therefore presumably didn't start counting himself at 0; this happens all the time when refs take a few seconds to send someone to a neutral corner, then pick up the count at 3 or 4.
Foreman goes down with 11 seconds left and is counted out at when the clock ticks 0. Don't go by the commentator's erroneous count--he starts at one when Foreman has been down for several seconds, failing to consider that the ref looked over to the person taking the count and therefore presumably didn't start counting himself at 0; this happens all the time when refs take a few seconds to send someone to a neutral corner, then pick up the count at 3 or 4.
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
taffytoon wrote:NOmickey1975 wrote:Yes.fantaheed wrote:Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j& ... 0277,d.ZWU
Some of you need to get a life FFS
Long count or not, this was certainly queried. It was a huge deal at the time. So doesn't fall into the op's question category.
-
Old Jack J
- Middleweight
- Posts: 1626
- Joined: 24 Jan 2014, 16:34
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Benn vs mclennan.
Benn knocked through the ropes in the first round and was given a long count. The ref said after that he gave benn extra time to get back in the ring but benn never fell off the apron of the ring so wasn't entitled to a longer count. The ref changed his tune later and said it was a standard 10 count and no extra time was given.
We all know what happened next.
I don't recall this been queried at the time too much. It certainly looked a long count to me.
Benn knocked through the ropes in the first round and was given a long count. The ref said after that he gave benn extra time to get back in the ring but benn never fell off the apron of the ring so wasn't entitled to a longer count. The ref changed his tune later and said it was a standard 10 count and no extra time was given.
We all know what happened next.
I don't recall this been queried at the time too much. It certainly looked a long count to me.
-
forcefraser
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 5523
- Joined: 17 Jun 2008, 06:15
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Taylor v Froch. Taylor was down for about 12 seconds.
Questionable whether he would have made it up with a correct count.
Questionable whether he would have made it up with a correct count.
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Time it with a stopwatch. He was on the canvas for about 13 seconds.taffytoon wrote:NOmickey1975 wrote:Yes.fantaheed wrote:Could be completely off the mark but did buster Douglas get a long count v Tyson?
http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j& ... 0277,d.ZWU
Some of you need to get a life FFS
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
i've watched Benn Watson a few times but my connection is poor right now. I never thought anything was wrong with it?
I was wondering the other day what would have happened to the Boxing world had Henry Cooper knocked out Ali........I guess the answer would have been a rematch with predictable results....or would Cooper have had to face someone else? (i assume it was for the title).
I was wondering the other day what would have happened to the Boxing world had Henry Cooper knocked out Ali........I guess the answer would have been a rematch with predictable results....or would Cooper have had to face someone else? (i assume it was for the title).
-
Final round
- Cruiserweight
- Posts: 4911
- Joined: 20 Oct 2010, 17:02
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
The rematch did have predictable results..n1ebf wrote:i've watched Benn Watson a few times but my connection is poor right now. I never thought anything was wrong with it?
I was wondering the other day what would have happened to the Boxing world had Henry Cooper knocked out Ali........I guess the answer would have been a rematch with predictable results....or would Cooper have had to face someone else? (i assume it was for the title).
-
jameswilson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 13502
- Joined: 08 Jan 2004, 18:01
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Lamon Brewster v Luan Krasniqui.
First knockdown I think. Krasniqui was put down hard, the ref reaches 8 with Krasniqui still down, then stops counting and waits for about 5 seconds for him to get up.
First knockdown I think. Krasniqui was put down hard, the ref reaches 8 with Krasniqui still down, then stops counting and waits for about 5 seconds for him to get up.
-
billy nelson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 1966
- Joined: 12 Apr 2010, 12:49
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Amir Khan's knockdown against Willie Limmond
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
That's the longest count in history. Sure the ref went backwards at one stage ha 6,7... 7 and a half... 7 and 3 quarters..billy nelson wrote:Amir Khan's knockdown against Willie Limmond
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Bruno-Cummings. Cummings gets up during the count and then immediately drops down to one knee, and the referee just waves it off without continuing to count.
-
Boxerbeetle
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 33008
- Joined: 19 Sep 2011, 10:59
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
That fight left me with no doubt that Khan was a brutal KO waiting to happen.daviddee wrote:That's the longest count in history. Sure the ref went backwards at one stage ha 6,7... 7 and a half... 7 and 3 quarters..billy nelson wrote:Amir Khan's knockdown against Willie Limmond
-
billy nelson
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 1966
- Joined: 12 Apr 2010, 12:49
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
At 7 amir went down and Marcus signalled for him to get up rather than count 8,9 & outdaviddee wrote:That's the longest count in history. Sure the ref went backwards at one stage ha 6,7... 7 and a half... 7 and 3 quarters..billy nelson wrote:Amir Khan's knockdown against Willie Limmond
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Khan-Limond! How could I forget. They stopped just short of providing a crane to get him back up.
Re: Dubious counts from history that were never queried
Cleverley v Kovalev - the ref picked him up, gave him a cuddle and kiss didn't hedeadpan wrote:Khan-Limond! How could I forget. They stopped just short of providing a crane to get him back up.