Carl Froch vs prime James Toney

[orbtastic]

Just kinda mumbled. Seemed grumpy. He seemed to be on his own, from what I could tell. It was Halloween '98 so not exactly the best point in his career.

[danconnollyeire]

Fit, in shape, SM Toney would beat him easily by a wide UD. Froch would miss all day long and get countered constantly

[Tuan_Jim]

Toney at his best too much of everything for Froch. Wide decision for the wily Lights Out.

[MightyWarrior]

Toney would have toyed with Froch, Carl wouldn't have been able to hurt him, or even hit him, and would have taken a brutal beating in the process

[keithmoonhangover]

Toney all day every day....one of the best in his prime

When would you say was his prime?

[gilgamesh]

I can't see any way that Froch would beat James. I'd go with James big time in this. I think he'd win a Unanimous decision most likely, but a late stoppage isn't inconceivable either.

[Calamity James]

Toney picks him apart all day long