James Kirkland vs. Antonio Margarito.

[VG_Addict]

This would be a war. But who comes out on top at 154?

Kirkland hits hard, but has a weak chin. Margarito has a granite chin, but is slower and not as hard a puncher. Both are relentless, both are slow starters, and both are hittable.

[jewboypgh]

Make it happen. These are the kind of fights they used to gave on Gillette
NBC boxing every week. Not no more

[ReggieDiggs]

The last thing Antonio needs to do with his bionic eye is fight again.

[SenorPipino]

I assume this is a theoretical fight and not actually being considered.
Margarito made some noise about a year ago about a comeback but I haven't heard anything about it since.

I have to like the Mexican in this one. He's tougher guy who can take it while I doubt that the weak chinned Kirkland would be able to absorb the punishment Margarito dishes out.
Margarito by KO in 6.

[Badhusker]

Do your research, before wasting our time with these bs hypothetical match-ups. Try to at least pick guys that are still active.

Hypothetical match-ups of current boxers are bad enough the way it is.

[KBB]

This would be a war. But who comes out on top at 154?

Kirkland hits hard, but has a weak chin. Margarito has a granite chin, but is slower and not as hard a puncher. Both are relentless, both are slow starters, and both are hittable.

Please man, MargoCHEATO is done and would get ktfo, without his loaded gloves he's no threat to any fighter.

[hurricanemitch14]

margarito has 0 legit wins after getting caught cheating. Kirkland beats the shit out of him