Ricky_ wrote:
So you don't wan't evaluate weight based upon clear photographs showing present condition such as the Canelo photoshoot, nor do you want to consider data from were he actually stood upon a scale.
I know you already admitted to being to stupid to make a judgement on a photograph (which begs the question why you would even weigh in on your guesses as to what he currently weighs), but here's what Mayweather looks like when he weighs 151lb after a 3-month training camp;
And having been out of action for over 4 months, you think he only weights 4 pounds heavier? He would have went to bed that night 4 pounds heavier. You're way off, and i think you know it.
1) I don't know how many times I can say this. Judging weight based on photos is inherently unreliable. And you were the first person to dismiss actual data from a scale when you said we couldn't trust Showtime's unofficial fight-night weight of 148. Yet you are happy to accept a weight from WWE of all sources.
2) I'm "to stupid"? Whatever you say, champ.
3) Not every fighter balloons in weight after a fight. Floyd takes very good care of his body and does not cut a significant amount of water weight, so it is highly unlikely he is gaining 20 pounds between fights. You are basically putting him at a comparable size to Canelo, who hasn't been able to make 147 for years whereas Floyd can still make it very easily.
In the end, what's important is what weight a fighter enters the ring at. Floyd and Manny would both enter the ring within a couple pounds of 150. They are approximately the same size, give or take a few pounds. That is all.