BoxRec now has active fighters in all time ratings

[jezzamundo]

Worth a look for anyone who is interested.

Here's a sample of the all-time p4p rankings of several current fighters, I'd be curious to know if you think they are being way overrated, a bit overrated, about right, a bit underrated or way underrated. Of course, the ratings are determined by the results of their fights and favour guys who had long careers and fought other top fighters at their peak.

Pound-for-pound
7) Floyd Mayweather
23) Bernard Hopkins
26) Manny Pacquiao
31) Juan Manuel Marquez
37) Wladimir Klitschko
50) Roy Jones Jr

[jezzamundo]

IMO:

7) Floyd Mayweather - a little overrated
23) Bernard Hopkins - a little overrated
26) Manny Pacquiao - about right
31) Juan Manuel Marquez - a little overrated
37) Wladimir Klitschko - WAY overrated
50) Roy Jones Jr - about right

[jamesmcdonnell]

IMO:

7) Floyd Mayweather - a little overrated
23) Bernard Hopkins - a little overrated
26) Manny Pacquiao - about right
31) Juan Manuel Marquez - a little overrated
37) Wladimir Klitschko - WAY overrated
50) Roy Jones Jr - about right

I'd rate Roy a LOT higher than that. In his prime he was phenomenal. He'd not lost a single fight (aside from a DQ) until he dropped back down from Heavyweight.

[MachoTime]

Archie Moore is number one P4P. Roberto Duran isn't even in the top 50.