johnswan1 wrote:Matthysse is greatly overrated.
Yes he is exciting to watch and has a high KO record, but look at the guys who beat him - Garcia, Alexander and Judah.
If he was really one of the best guys in the sport P4P he would not be getting into close or controversial fights with Alexander or Judah, and Garcia beat him decisively. Even an aging Judah performed better against Garcia than Lucas did. Bradley was able to overcome Alexander, Khan was able to outbox him, Porter was able to steamroll through him. Lucas couldn't. Baldomir, Spinks, Khan and Malignaggi were all able to get past Judah who has also not showed the best chin in the past.
Garcia didn't beat him decisively, nobody has. I had him wining all of those fights, the ref in the Garcia fight was a joke.
Not sure how anyone comes to the conclusion Matthysse is overrated, he;s not in most peoples top 10, Boxrec has him 27th, with Abraham, Wilder, Pulev, Tyson Fury, Khan and Thurman all ahead of him. He's without doubt a better fighter than all of them.