Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Black Sam Bellamy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1476
Joined: 25 Sep 2008, 13:51

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Black Sam Bellamy »

I really doubt this to be true.
Maxsplit
Cruiserweight
Posts: 364
Joined: 13 Jul 2011, 22:26

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Maxsplit »

Black Sam Bellamy wrote:I really doubt this to be true.
allegedly said he had been told it was Joshua vs Scott on June 25th at o2 in his IFLTV interview released yesterday.

He also laid into it as you would expect.

Would this top Haye vs Audley as the weakest Heavyweight PPV ever? I think it might IMO.
keirw
Middleweight
Posts: 2681
Joined: 03 Nov 2013, 10:55

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by keirw »

Maxsplit wrote:
Black Sam Bellamy wrote:I really doubt this to be true.
allegedly said he had been told it was Joshua vs Scott on June 25th at o2 in his IFLTV interview released yesterday.

He also laid into it as you would expect.

Would this top Haye vs Audley as the weakest Heavyweight PPV ever? I think it might IMO.
Considering Smith's and Saunders' respective first defences he is hardly in a position to say anything.

Terrible opponent, I can't see it happening tbh, Takam\Parker winner would be most likely, get the mandatory out of the way to concentrate on bigger money fights.
If not Stiverne would be acceptable, at least he went the distance with Wilder.

Scott would have been a fair opponent before picking up the IBF strap, but now he would be a backward step.
Stuarty
Middleweight
Posts: 27293
Joined: 20 Aug 2014, 10:28

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Stuarty »

keirw wrote:
Maxsplit wrote:
Black Sam Bellamy wrote:I really doubt this to be true.
allegedly said he had been told it was Joshua vs Scott on June 25th at o2 in his IFLTV interview released yesterday.

He also laid into it as you would expect.

Would this top Haye vs Audley as the weakest Heavyweight PPV ever? I think it might IMO.
Considering Smith's and Saunders' respective first defences he is hardly in a position to say anything.

Terrible opponent, I can't see it happening tbh, Takam\Parker winner would be most likely, get the mandatory out of the way to concentrate on bigger money fights.
If not Stiverne would be acceptable, at least he went the distance with Wilder.

Scott would have been a fair opponent before picking up the IBF strap, but now he would be a backward step.
Yeah all true :TU:
Nightmare Roy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 16935
Joined: 18 May 2003, 17:29

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Nightmare Roy »

At least Steverne would give him rounds prehaps and if he did stop him that would look good, Scott will be similar to Martin, come over, get knocked over, get paid, go home.
asdfjkl
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by asdfjkl »

Nightmare Roy wrote:At least Steverne would give him rounds prehaps and if he did stop him that would look good, Scott will be similar to Martin, come over, get knocked over, get paid, go home.
Stiverne doesn't give him rounds at all, in his last fight he got KD in the first round as well, Stiverne is a joke.
Nightmare Roy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 16935
Joined: 18 May 2003, 17:29

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Nightmare Roy »

asdfjkl wrote:
Nightmare Roy wrote:At least Steverne would give him rounds prehaps and if he did stop him that would look good, Scott will be similar to Martin, come over, get knocked over, get paid, go home.
Stiverne doesn't give him rounds at all, in his last fight he got KD in the first round as well, Stiverne is a joke.
Oh I didn't know that.
Maxsplit
Cruiserweight
Posts: 364
Joined: 13 Jul 2011, 22:26

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Maxsplit »

asdfjkl wrote:
Nightmare Roy wrote:At least Steverne would give him rounds prehaps and if he did stop him that would look good, Scott will be similar to Martin, come over, get knocked over, get paid, go home.
Stiverne doesn't give him rounds at all, in his last fight he got KD in the first round as well, Stiverne is a joke.
I'm willing to give him a pass on that, Stiverne is the only one of Wilder's 36 opponents not to be stopped and he wasn't knocked down either after taking some hellacious shots. He also took some serious shots from Arreola in his two fights who can bang too.

Plus Stiverne has one punch KO power so I think it's an acceptable fight. I remember him banging out Price in the amateurs and his stoppage of Arreola was brutal. He would certainly be much better than Scott in anyone's eyes. His only legitimate defeat is to Wilder IMO.

That said he has a tendency to get trapped on the ropes, not good vs Joshua although he has a mean counter left hook which is AJs Achilles heel.

But for al those reasons IMO Stiverne would be too risky for a first fight and Don King would ensure Hearn breaks the bank for him.

It will be Scott or Molina (who Arreola stopped in a round) IMO.
Stuarty
Middleweight
Posts: 27293
Joined: 20 Aug 2014, 10:28

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Stuarty »

Maxsplit wrote:
asdfjkl wrote:
Nightmare Roy wrote:At least Steverne would give him rounds prehaps and if he did stop him that would look good, Scott will be similar to Martin, come over, get knocked over, get paid, go home.
Stiverne doesn't give him rounds at all, in his last fight he got KD in the first round as well, Stiverne is a joke.
I'm willing to give him a pass on that, Stiverne is the only one of Wilder's 36 opponents not to be stopped and he wasn't knocked down either after taking some hellacious shots. He also took some serious shots from Arreola in his two fights who can bang too.

Plus Stiverne has one punch KO power so I think it's an acceptable fight. I remember him banging out Price in the amateurs and his stoppage of Arreola was brutal. He would certainly be much better than Scott in anyone's eyes. His only legitimate defeat is to Wilder IMO.

That said he has a tendency to get trapped on the ropes, not good vs Joshua although he has a mean counter left hook which is AJs Achilles heel.

But for al those reasons IMO Stiverne would be too risky for a first fight and Don King would ensure Hearn breaks the bank for him.

It will be Scott or Molina (who Arreola stopped in a round) IMO.
Duhaupas would be a decent scrap. Seems a tough customer and coming off a career best win. Nothing special but better than Scott.
Ricky_
Middleweight
Posts: 8896
Joined: 16 Oct 2013, 08:03

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by Ricky_ »

Maxsplit wrote:
asdfjkl wrote:
Nightmare Roy wrote:At least Steverne would give him rounds prehaps and if he did stop him that would look good, Scott will be similar to Martin, come over, get knocked over, get paid, go home.
Stiverne doesn't give him rounds at all, in his last fight he got KD in the first round as well, Stiverne is a joke.
I'm willing to give him a pass on that, Stiverne is the only one of Wilder's 36 opponents not to be stopped and he wasn't knocked down either after taking some hellacious shots. He also took some serious shots from Arreola in his two fights who can bang too.

Plus Stiverne has one punch KO power so I think it's an acceptable fight. I remember him banging out Price in the amateurs and his stoppage of Arreola was brutal. He would certainly be much better than Scott in anyone's eyes. His only legitimate defeat is to Wilder IMO.

That said he has a tendency to get trapped on the ropes, not good vs Joshua although he has a mean counter left hook which is AJs Achilles heel.

But for al those reasons IMO Stiverne would be too risky for a first fight and Don King would ensure Hearn breaks the bank for him.

It will be Scott or Molina (who Arreola stopped in a round) IMO.
I put one of my biggest bets ever on Stiverne to win by KO in his last bout. Derric Rossy has been stopped by Audley Harrisson in prizefighter before, so i thought it was a stick-on. Stiverne is tough (wilder like you said) but he has fast hands, looked a beast in the Arreola fights.

Anyway, in his last bout he got put on his backside and Rossy came away crying robbery at the decision.

You can't give him "a pass" - he's 37, didn't land a punch on Wilder and got dropped in a horrible showing vs an Audley PrizeFighter victim. it's not like a blip, he's totally shot. That been said, he's still be a better opponent than Malik Scott.
asdfjkl
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Malik Scott is a strange choice of opponent for AJ to defend his world title against

Post by asdfjkl »

Ricky_ wrote:
Maxsplit wrote:
asdfjkl wrote: Stiverne doesn't give him rounds at all, in his last fight he got KD in the first round as well, Stiverne is a joke.
I'm willing to give him a pass on that, Stiverne is the only one of Wilder's 36 opponents not to be stopped and he wasn't knocked down either after taking some hellacious shots. He also took some serious shots from Arreola in his two fights who can bang too.

Plus Stiverne has one punch KO power so I think it's an acceptable fight. I remember him banging out Price in the amateurs and his stoppage of Arreola was brutal. He would certainly be much better than Scott in anyone's eyes. His only legitimate defeat is to Wilder IMO.

That said he has a tendency to get trapped on the ropes, not good vs Joshua although he has a mean counter left hook which is AJs Achilles heel.

But for al those reasons IMO Stiverne would be too risky for a first fight and Don King would ensure Hearn breaks the bank for him.

It will be Scott or Molina (who Arreola stopped in a round) IMO.
I put one of my biggest bets ever on Stiverne to win by KO in his last bout. Derric Rossy has been stopped by Audley Harrisson in prizefighter before, so i thought it was a stick-on. Stiverne is tough (wilder like you said) but he has fast hands, looked a beast in the Arreola fights.

Anyway, in his last bout he got put on his backside and Rossy came away crying robbery at the decision.

You can't give him "a pass" - he's 37, didn't land a punch on Wilder and got dropped in a horrible showing vs an Audley PrizeFighter victim. it's not like a blip, he's totally shot. That been said, he's still be a better opponent than Malik Scott.
I'm surprised by the reactions, I really consider Stiverne as an absolute bum TBH.
Post Reply