WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Joshua vs. Haye Winner?

Anthony Joshua
93
42%
David Haye
130
58%
 
Total votes: 223

jamesmcdonnell
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 45238
Joined: 12 Nov 2003, 06:11

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by jamesmcdonnell »

ILikeBeer wrote:
Rob3_142 wrote:I think David Haye's career as a heavyweight has been built up to be something it is not. The only heavy he has stepped in the ring with worth mentioning is Klitchko, and Haye didn't even get close to him. David Haye was a fantastic cruiserweight, but since being a heavy, he has ducked real opposition, despite having two opportunities to fight Fury.

Haye inherently struggles against tall opposition, which he gives 3 inches away to Joshua. Throw into the fact that the power that Joshua possesses would rock Haye to his boots. It's easy stalking someone in the ring when you know they're not going to throw anything back. Valuev (his highest ranking win) didn't get within a few metres of him, Chisora (also not a big puncher - more of a slugger) is shorter than Haye!

I think this is Joshua's hardest fight out there, but I also think it's Haye's hardest fight also.
Did he struggle with Valuev?

I mean, I know it was boring-ass fight, but he boxed the fight he needed to to win against an opponent who dwarved him.
Well, Haye spent most of the fight running around Valuev in circles, and it was a split decision victory, so yes, he did struggle.
wesshaw1985
Super Middleweight
Posts: 7483
Joined: 21 Jul 2013, 17:57

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by wesshaw1985 »

Haye getting more Sky TV time tonight.
Any chance he turns out to be AJs December opponent?
mickey1975
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 23132
Joined: 02 Mar 2009, 12:54

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by mickey1975 »

wesshaw1985 wrote:Haye getting more Sky TV time tonight.
Any chance he turns out to be AJs December opponent?
No, Boomers in February.
Tom Moore
Welterweight
Posts: 37
Joined: 27 May 2016, 01:54

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by Tom Moore »

Haye at the moment, leagues above anything Joshua's faced. Although Joshua has at least a punchers chance.
asdfjkl
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by asdfjkl »

Haye beats the wurm and some other guy I've barely ever heard from and now people think he's better as AJ?! People must be nutjobs, Haye barely managed to touch Klitschko at all in Haye his prime?! A 46 year old Holyfield showed a better performance against Valuev as Daffy in his prime lol!
keithmoonhangover
Cruiserweight
Posts: 17104
Joined: 16 Sep 2010, 10:42

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by keithmoonhangover »

Joshua - Haye is a stadium fight for next summer. Wemberleeeeeeee!
wesshaw1985
Super Middleweight
Posts: 7483
Joined: 21 Jul 2013, 17:57

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by wesshaw1985 »

after todays Haye/Bellew presser it sounds like Haye is planning on going after AJ after he has beat Bellew.
Haye/Bellew is due for March, Hearn has AJ vs. Klit scheduled not long after.
If all goes to plan do these 2 meet at Wembley in the summer?
TheGman
Middleweight
Posts: 8964
Joined: 10 Oct 2013, 12:37

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by TheGman »

Haye,too quite too power and has the best 1 punch knock out power in the division at present
Loftgroov
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3712
Joined: 10 Oct 2003, 10:48

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by Loftgroov »

I suspect the plan is Haye v Joshua, Wembley, Summer 2017.

After disposing with Bellew, it will be down to the humble Anthony to save Matchroom's honour and silence the nightclub-frequenting Bermondsey badboy.

Adam Smith is probably writing the script already.

Hopefully the fight gets an endorsement from Wayne Rooney and Jamie Carragher shortly - then you know its on. :bag:
Cyclops
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 5744
Joined: 13 Jun 2009, 04:14

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by Cyclops »

jamesmcdonnell wrote:
ILikeBeer wrote:
Rob3_142 wrote:I think David Haye's career as a heavyweight has been built up to be something it is not. The only heavy he has stepped in the ring with worth mentioning is Klitchko, and Haye didn't even get close to him. David Haye was a fantastic cruiserweight, but since being a heavy, he has ducked real opposition, despite having two opportunities to fight Fury.

Haye inherently struggles against tall opposition, which he gives 3 inches away to Joshua. Throw into the fact that the power that Joshua possesses would rock Haye to his boots. It's easy stalking someone in the ring when you know they're not going to throw anything back. Valuev (his highest ranking win) didn't get within a few metres of him, Chisora (also not a big puncher - more of a slugger) is shorter than Haye!

I think this is Joshua's hardest fight out there, but I also think it's Haye's hardest fight also.
Did he struggle with Valuev?

I mean, I know it was boring-ass fight, but he boxed the fight he needed to to win against an opponent who dwarved him.
Well, Haye spent most of the fight running around Valuev in circles, and it was a split decision victory, so yes, he did struggle.
I've never understood the argument that Valuev won that fight. Haye was extremely negative and obviously intimidated by the huge man in front of him, and an ancient Holyfield had done better against the Russian and got robbed, but I really don't see what Valuev did to deserve the win. He was completely flummoxed by Haye, who surprised everybody by actually boxing (when he was known only previously as a come forward gun slinging banger). Haye outlanded him and stole rounds. Sure, there was only one moment in the fight where there was any action (when Valuev did the Judah dance for a couple of seconds) but it was a clear win for Haye. What did people expect him to do? He was one fight removed from cruiserweight, with a suspect chin, fighting the biggest HW champion ever. Jim Watt's commentary was mental, saying Haye has lost. No way. Look at Valuev at the end of the fight: he knew he'd lost.

Did he struggle? Yeah, a bit. It's hard to fight a guy a foot taller than you and look good. He dropped rounds for sure. But he boxed to a game plan. Don't forget, there were plenty of people who thought he couldn't do it (James Degale picked Valuev for instance). It was the shittest fight ever, though.
Nightmare Roy
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 16928
Joined: 18 May 2003, 17:29

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by Nightmare Roy »

Loftgroov wrote:I suspect the plan is Haye v Joshua, Wembley, Summer 2017.

After disposing with Bellew, it will be down to the humble Anthony to save Matchroom's honour and silence the nightclub-frequenting Bermondsey badboy.

Adam Smith is probably writing the script already.

Hopefully the fight gets an endorsement from Wayne Rooney and Jamie Carragher shortly - then you know its on. :bag:
Rooney has done a bit of boxing too, apparently.
Rob3_142
Super Welterweight
Posts: 2791
Joined: 26 Jun 2015, 06:03

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by Rob3_142 »

clopixolacuphase wrote:
jamesmcdonnell wrote:
ILikeBeer wrote:
Did he struggle with Valuev?

I mean, I know it was boring-ass fight, but he boxed the fight he needed to to win against an opponent who dwarved him.
Well, Haye spent most of the fight running around Valuev in circles, and it was a split decision victory, so yes, he did struggle.
I've never understood the argument that Valuev won that fight. Haye was extremely negative and obviously intimidated by the huge man in front of him, and an ancient Holyfield had done better against the Russian and got robbed, but I really don't see what Valuev did to deserve the win. He was completely flummoxed by Haye, who surprised everybody by actually boxing (when he was known only previously as a come forward gun slinging banger). Haye outlanded him and stole rounds. Sure, there was only one moment in the fight where there was any action (when Valuev did the Judah dance for a couple of seconds) but it was a clear win for Haye. What did people expect him to do? He was one fight removed from cruiserweight, with a suspect chin, fighting the biggest HW champion ever. Jim Watt's commentary was mental, saying Haye has lost. No way. Look at Valuev at the end of the fight: he knew he'd lost.

Did he struggle? Yeah, a bit. It's hard to fight a guy a foot taller than you and look good. He dropped rounds for sure. But he boxed to a game plan. Don't forget, there were plenty of people who thought he couldn't do it (James Degale picked Valuev for instance). It was the shittest fight ever, though.
I don't think Valuev won the fight. Haye was keeping out of range and nicking rounds. Not a classic by any stretches, but Haye did enough.
asdfjkl
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by asdfjkl »

jamesmcdonnell wrote:
ILikeBeer wrote:
Rob3_142 wrote:I think David Haye's career as a heavyweight has been built up to be something it is not. The only heavy he has stepped in the ring with worth mentioning is Klitchko, and Haye didn't even get close to him. David Haye was a fantastic cruiserweight, but since being a heavy, he has ducked real opposition, despite having two opportunities to fight Fury.

Haye inherently struggles against tall opposition, which he gives 3 inches away to Joshua. Throw into the fact that the power that Joshua possesses would rock Haye to his boots. It's easy stalking someone in the ring when you know they're not going to throw anything back. Valuev (his highest ranking win) didn't get within a few metres of him, Chisora (also not a big puncher - more of a slugger) is shorter than Haye!

I think this is Joshua's hardest fight out there, but I also think it's Haye's hardest fight also.
Did he struggle with Valuev?

I mean, I know it was boring-ass fight, but he boxed the fight he needed to to win against an opponent who dwarved him.
Well, Haye spent most of the fight running around Valuev in circles, and it was a split decision victory, so yes, he did struggle.
In fact, the 46 year old opponent Valuev fought just before showed a lot better performance
jamesmcdonnell
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 45238
Joined: 12 Nov 2003, 06:11

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by jamesmcdonnell »

asdfjkl wrote:
jamesmcdonnell wrote:
ILikeBeer wrote:
Did he struggle with Valuev?

I mean, I know it was boring-ass fight, but he boxed the fight he needed to to win against an opponent who dwarved him.
Well, Haye spent most of the fight running around Valuev in circles, and it was a split decision victory, so yes, he did struggle.
In fact, the 46 year old opponent Valuev fought just before showed a lot better performance
I think at the time I scored it a draw. So little happened in most rounds that I had I think the majority of them even.
wesshaw1985
Super Middleweight
Posts: 7483
Joined: 21 Jul 2013, 17:57

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by wesshaw1985 »

jamesmcdonnell wrote:
asdfjkl wrote:
jamesmcdonnell wrote:
Well, Haye spent most of the fight running around Valuev in circles, and it was a split decision victory, so yes, he did struggle.
In fact, the 46 year old opponent Valuev fought just before showed a lot better performance
I think at the time I scored it a draw. So little happened in most rounds that I had I think the majority of them even.
Haye won the fight, it wasn't pretty on the eye, but he won...
asdfjkl
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by asdfjkl »

wesshaw1985 wrote:
jamesmcdonnell wrote:
asdfjkl wrote: In fact, the 46 year old opponent Valuev fought just before showed a lot better performance
I think at the time I scored it a draw. So little happened in most rounds that I had I think the majority of them even.
Haye won the fight, it wasn't pretty on the eye, but he won...
Most people watching expected the 46 year old to be the winner after seeing the fight, somehow Valuev won that one.
PredatorHayds
Super Welterweight
Posts: 4891
Joined: 08 Jul 2015, 08:23

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by PredatorHayds »

When I watched it live and drunk I had Valuev nicking it.

I haven't watched it back and I was ridiculously drunk at the time and my card is just about legible. Take my scores credibility with a pinch of salt.
dirk2686
Super Lightweight
Posts: 1982
Joined: 26 Sep 2016, 09:35

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by dirk2686 »

Boxing News had Haye winning every round of the Valuev fight. Sounds ridiculous but it genuinely wasn't. Valuev walked forward and hit nothing all night.

Not a good fight but Haye won it by miles. Did exactly what he needed to do.
wesshaw1985
Super Middleweight
Posts: 7483
Joined: 21 Jul 2013, 17:57

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by wesshaw1985 »

this fight is getting brought up more and more in the past few days.
Got a feeling it will be AJs summer fight at Wembley if AJ gets past Klit in April...
SamWise72
Cruiserweight
Posts: 1346
Joined: 02 Jul 2011, 16:41

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by SamWise72 »

We don't know what happens if AJ gets hit. We DO know what happens if Haye is hit. I have a feeling he can't move for 12 any more, and AJ hits harder than Mormeck or Thompson. Hard to call, but too many unknowns to say AJ has no chance
Rob3_142
Super Welterweight
Posts: 2791
Joined: 26 Jun 2015, 06:03

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by Rob3_142 »

wesshaw1985 wrote:this fight is getting brought up more and more in the past few days.
Got a feeling it will be AJs summer fight at Wembley if AJ gets past Klit in April...
Do we reckon that there's scope for two Wembley fights in a year? That would be mega bucks!
pimp
Super Middleweight
Posts: 288
Joined: 27 Nov 2012, 16:55

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by pimp »

Not read all the posts so might be repeating what been said but hearn will avoid haye for now and will sit back to see exactly what haye has left cos we don't actually no, hearn knows he's a very dangerous opponent and has the power spark AJ out I think it will happen next year it has to
wesshaw1985
Super Middleweight
Posts: 7483
Joined: 21 Jul 2013, 17:57

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by wesshaw1985 »

Rob3_142 wrote:
wesshaw1985 wrote:this fight is getting brought up more and more in the past few days.
Got a feeling it will be AJs summer fight at Wembley if AJ gets past Klit in April...
Do we reckon that there's scope for two Wembley fights in a year? That would be mega bucks!
vs. Klit and vs. Haye are mega fights, Wembley is a fitting venue for both so can't see why they wouldn't go for it and maximise revenue for both fights...
afcmarshall
Super Welterweight
Posts: 390
Joined: 16 Jul 2015, 14:03

Re: WHO WINS? Anthony Joshua vs. David Haye

Post by afcmarshall »

wesshaw1985 wrote:
Rob3_142 wrote:
wesshaw1985 wrote:this fight is getting brought up more and more in the past few days.
Got a feeling it will be AJs summer fight at Wembley if AJ gets past Klit in April...
Do we reckon that there's scope for two Wembley fights in a year? That would be mega bucks!
vs. Klit and vs. Haye are mega fights, Wembley is a fitting venue for both so can't see why they wouldn't go for it and maximise revenue for both fights...
The problem would be turn around time can only realistically fight there between mid May and mid September and cant see them having two big fights within 4 months. plus mid May Wembley is booked
Post Reply