British Top 30 P4P April 2016

[Switch hitter]

Murrey and Eubank jr too high.....

[Horse]

payano is wba champ not mcdonnell...........p4p?...........selby would batter mcdonnell..........

McDonnell has a better record.

Selby is unproven.

[cocobongo]

Would swap Flanagan and Murray apart from that decent enough list

[Manchester Massive]

Groves and Murray serial world title fight losers, Eubanks Jr beaten by weakest champ in his division, none of them should be ahead of Crolla

[Supremo]

To me pound for pound means if all were equal in size then who would be the best- to me Kell Brook despite his appalling standard of opposition would be best if they were all the same size. But he hasn't proved it by fighting anyone decent. Tyson Fury has the most notable scalp on his resume but his performance was poor and his technique is poor, if he was the same weight as most of they fighters he would get destroyed- so for me he can be nowhere near the top.

[Supremo]

Billy Joe Saunders should be higher as well.

[Horse]

Murrey and Eubank jr too high.....

Eubank Jr's place seems about right to me.

He had a very close fight with Saunders less than 18 months ago and since then he's been building a decent record and looking pretty good doing it.

[Horse]

Would swap Flanagan and Murray apart from that decent enough list

[Horse]

Groves and Murray serial world title fight losers, Eubanks Jr beaten by weakest champ in his division, none of them should be ahead of Crolla

Crolla lost to Mathews, Crolla lost to Sykes.

Crolla's not fought at world class yet.

[Horse]

To me pound for pound means if all were equal in size then who would be the best- to me Kell Brook despite his appalling standard of opposition would be best if they were all the same size. But he hasn't proved it by fighting anyone decent.

He might be the best, but if he fought better opposition I wouldn't be surprised if he lost and we found out that he wasn't really all that good after all.

Tyson Fury has the most notable scalp on his resume but his performance was poor and his technique is poor, if he was the same weight as most of they fighters he would get destroyed- so for me he can be nowhere near the top.

Fury's performance was not poor at all.

He got one of the best wins in British boxing history.

Any British P4P rankings without Fury at the top are bogus.

[Supremo]

He hardly swung a punch and just danced about outside of the distance of someone who couldn't get set to throw. That's not p4p boxing in my book.

[fizzjambo]

He hardly swung a punch and just danced about outside of the distance of someone who couldn't get set to throw. That's not p4p boxing in my book.

He was winning the fight so kept doing what was being successful against a decade long champion who can dig and was being neutralised.

I don't think anyone would say it was fight of the year but it was possibly performance of the year

[Hinchy70]

Paul Smith should be making that NO.1 spot his own

[mickey1975]

Paul Smith should be making that NO.1 spot his own

This list was one of the main reasons Paul doesn't post here anymore. It really wound him up. I miss Smigga.

[keirw]

...........selby would batter mcdonnell..........

Given that he is a full division above him, i'd say you are right.

[los2]

...........selby would batter mcdonnell..........

Given that he is a full division above him, i'd say you are right.

he's 2 divisions above..........youve cut the bit off where i said p4p.............if they were same division selby wins.............

[DannyMCR]

1. (1.) Tyson Fury
2. (2.) James DeGale
3. (3.) Carl Frampton
4. (4.) Kell Brook
5. (5.) Amir Khan
6. (6.) Jamie McDonnell
7. (7.) Lee Selby
8. (8.) Martin Murray
9. (9.) Billy Joe Saunders
10. (10.) Scott Quigg

11. (14.) Terry Flanagan
12. (11.) Tony Bellew
13. (12.) George Groves
14. (13.) Lee Haskins
15. (15.) Andy Lee (Irish)
16. (22.) Chris Eubank Jr.
17. (16.) Ricky Burns
18. (17.) Ola Afolabi
19. (18.) Anthony Crolla
20. (19.) Ovill McKenzie

21. (20.) Callum Smith
22. (21.) Nathan Cleverly
23. (23.) Anthony Joshua
24. (NE.) Bradley Skeete
25. (24.) Liam Smith
26. (25.) David Haye
27. (NE.) Khalid Yafai
28. (27.) Paul Butler
29. (26.) Gavin McDonnell
30. (28.) Enzo Maccarinelli

Out - (29.) Ryan Farrag
Out - (30.) Sam Eggington

Would be interested to see an updated version of this list

[crusader]

http://boxrec.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=201907