Jack Kid Berg

Post Reply
Musashi
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 342
Joined: 23 Nov 2003, 21:06

Jack Kid Berg

Post by Musashi »

Jack Kid Berg's record in this book below has some slight differences from what Boxrec has.

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/086051 ... oding=UTF8

Differences
vs. Harry Corbett (Boxrec says 1926-04-26, Book says 1926-04-25)
vs. Pedro Amador (Boxrec says 1928-05-31, Book says 1928-05-12)
vs. Johnny Mellow (Boxrec says 1928-06-07, Book says 1928-06-14/Boxrec says W10, Book says "Won stpd 8")
vs. Freddie Muller (Boxrec says 1928-06-14, Book says 1928-05-30)
vs. Mike Watters (Boxrec says 1928-07-12, Book says 1928-07-04)
vs. Spug Myers (Boxrec says 1928-10-08, Book says 1928-09-06)
vs. Tony Caragliano (Boxrec says WDQ2, Book says "Won stpd")
vs. Tony Canzoneri (Boxrec says date 1930-01-17, Book says 1930-01-23)
vs. Sammy Fuller (Boxrec says date 1932-05-20, Book says 1932-05-29)
vs. Eugene Drouhin (Boxrec says date 1933-07-14, Book says 1933-07-12/Boxrec says TKO8, book says "Won ret 9")
vs. Harry Wallace (Boxrec says date 1933-10-07, Book says 1933-09-30)
vs. Jackie Flynn (Boxrec says date 1934-04-14, Book says 1934-04-29)
vs. Nicolas Wilke (Boxrec says date 1934-08-19, Book says 1934-09-30)
vs. Harry Brown (Boxrec says 1935-05-19, Book says 1935-05-15)
vs. Pat Haley (Boxrec says TKO9, Book says "Won ret 10")
vs. Jake Kilrain (Boxrec says TKO6, Book says "Won stpd 10")
vs. George Odwell (Boxrec says TKO7, Book says "Lost ret 10")
vs. Charlie Chetwin (Boxrec says TKO5, Book says "Won stpd 10")
vs. Silvio Zangrillo (Boxrec says date 1938-02-19, Book says 1938-02-03/Boxrec says TKO4, Book says "KO 8")
vs. Vincent Pimpinella (Boxrec says W10, Book says "Won pts 8")
vs. Marine Bunker (Boxrec says date 1939-04-10, Book says 1939-04-11/Boxrec says TKO9, Book says "KO8")
vs. Ernie Roderick (Boxrec says date 1941-06-12, Book says 1941-05-30)
vs. Arthur Danaher (Boxrec says date 1941-07-24, Book says 1941-02-05)

Missing bout
Jack Berg WKO6 Mike Gamiere (5/28/1928 at Ocean Park)
Matt
Editor
Editor
Posts: 2290
Joined: 28 Dec 2001, 20:00

Post by Matt »

That's books may be right in some counts, British bouts in particular. But by looking at the dates they gave for the Fuller, Canzoneri, and some New York and Chicago bouts, I would say that I would not trust that as a resource. Many of those dates we have already been confirmed against a newspaper. What that book confirmed against, I couldn't guess.
Musashi
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 342
Joined: 23 Nov 2003, 21:06

Post by Musashi »

tegenm wrote:That's books may be right in some counts, British bouts in particular. But by looking at the dates they gave for the Fuller, Canzoneri, and some New York and Chicago bouts, I would say that I would not trust that as a resource. Many of those dates we have already been confirmed against a newspaper. What that book confirmed against, I couldn't guess.
:TU:

I don't know if they're right or not, but it's worth noting.
Post Reply