I saw and was wondering how Donaire lost, my personal score was 116-112 Donaire and it surprised me that was the contrary. I was rooting for Magdaleno and he did better in first rounds and 8,9 only, but didn't realized that final score as Donaire was doing better in final rounds (including power punching statistics that have good judging valor for scoring)...
As well for Pacman, he did ok (not that supreme old of his performances but ok) and no way he got that score, Vargas did good boxing in at least 4 rounds (4,5,6 and maybe 1 and/or 3)
Well... boxing judging.
How Donaire lost? And what was that Pac official scorecards?
Re: How Donaire lost? And what was that Pac official scorecards?
I didn't score the Donaire/Magdaleno fight, but I remembered thinking it was pretty even. I would assume Magdaleno got the decision because the sport benefits more from having a young star, than a faded old star.
Agree on the Pac scoring. Pac won the fight handily. 118-109 scores were pretty accurate.
Agree on the Pac scoring. Pac won the fight handily. 118-109 scores were pretty accurate.
Re: How Donaire lost? And what was that Pac official scorecards?
Manny 118:109 real.114:113 is joke or something worse.
I was not surprised victory Magdaleno but I thought it was more close fight when I watched.115:113 or draw 114:114.It was a close fight!
I was not surprised victory Magdaleno but I thought it was more close fight when I watched.115:113 or draw 114:114.It was a close fight!
-
handsofstone
- Cruiserweight
- Posts: 23080
- Joined: 11 Jan 2011, 17:28
Re: How Donaire lost? And what was that Pac official scorecards?
118-109 Pacquiao and I had Magdaleno/Donaire 114-114
-
Boxing Prospect
- Light Heavyweight
- Posts: 6592
- Joined: 25 Jun 2012, 14:35
Re: How Donaire lost? And what was that Pac official scorecards?
Had Magdaleno winning comfortably, he waited too long too often, Magdaleno didn't so much win as Donaire gave it away looking for one bomb at a time
-
BAD INTENTIONS
- Heavyweight
- Posts: 1885
- Joined: 22 Oct 2005, 17:45
Re: How Donaire lost? And what was that Pac official scorecards?
After the Montiel fight, Donaire has been a one bomb fighter. Sad.Boxing Prospect wrote:Had Magdaleno winning comfortably, he waited too long too often, Magdaleno didn't so much win as Donaire gave it away looking for one bomb at a time
-
ClivePatrickLyons
- Super Welterweight
- Posts: 2811
- Joined: 07 Aug 2014, 22:10
Re: How Donaire lost? And what was that Pac official scorecards?
It would have been a Robbery but not the worse but still the same a robbery if Magdaleno didn't get the nod he surely deserved that dec he out boxed and out worked Donaire I was Hoping Nonito could pull the win out from the jaws of defeat but it wasn't to be The young Challenger showed a good chin and a huge heart to get the verdict 
I thought two of the judge's watched the fight with both eye's open thank god I think one judge had it one way traffic for Magdaleno and it was not a one-sided fight by any stretch of the imagination
Who was that clown doing the commentary with the two boxing expert's he said that he had Jessie in front about the middle round's of the fight what the f.c was he watching he made a real ass of himself he'd would have been to intent in watching what his fantasy Floyd was doing during the fight and that judge that had the fight 114/113 should be locked up for impersonating a professional boxing judge so if Pacman didn't drop Jessie for a count it would have been a draw on that judge's score card will this bloke been made to explain his score card or does just sit back pulling his prick waiting for his next gig get rid of scum like this and if this is corruption/fraud get them charged and make an EXAMPLE out of these imposter's this is getting worst these people should be charged with bringing the game of boxing into disrepute.
I thought two of the judge's watched the fight with both eye's open thank god I think one judge had it one way traffic for Magdaleno and it was not a one-sided fight by any stretch of the imagination Who was that clown doing the commentary with the two boxing expert's he said that he had Jessie in front about the middle round's of the fight what the f.c was he watching he made a real ass of himself he'd would have been to intent in watching what his fantasy Floyd was doing during the fight and that judge that had the fight 114/113 should be locked up for impersonating a professional boxing judge so if Pacman didn't drop Jessie for a count it would have been a draw on that judge's score card will this bloke been made to explain his score card or does just sit back pulling his prick waiting for his next gig get rid of scum like this and if this is corruption/fraud get them charged and make an EXAMPLE out of these imposter's this is getting worst these people should be charged with bringing the game of boxing into disrepute.