Year end best in every division

Post Reply
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Year end best in every division

Post by Jip »

HW JOSHUA
CW USYK
LH KOVALEV
SM DEGALE
MM GOLOVKIN
SW LARA
WW THURMAN
SL CRAWFORD
LW BARTHELEMY
SF LOMACHENKO
FW VALDEZ
SB RIGONDEAUX
BW YAMANAKA
SF INOUE
FW IOKA
LF LOPEZ
MW MOONSRI
jezzamundo
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3127
Joined: 16 Jun 2004, 13:11

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by jezzamundo »

HW - unclear
CW - Usyk
LHW - Kovalev/Ward
SMW - DeGale (though I think GGG would beat him)
MW - GGG
LMW - unclear
WW - unclear
LWW - Crawford
I dont follow divisions south of 140lb to comment on them.
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by Jip »

jezzamundo wrote:HW - unclear
CW - Usyk
LHW - Kovalev/Ward
SMW - DeGale (though I think GGG would beat him)
MW - GGG
LMW - unclear
WW - unclear
LWW - Crawford
I dont follow divisions south of 140lb to comment on them.

stop with that kovalev/ward jezza, you better than that
ValMar
Welterweight
Posts: 4149
Joined: 07 Nov 2015, 14:24

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by ValMar »

jezzamundo wrote:HW - unclear
CW - Usyk
LHW - Kovalev/Ward
SMW - DeGale (though I think GGG would beat him)
MW - GGG
LMW - unclear
WW - unclear
LWW - Crawford
I dont follow divisions south of 140lb to comment on them.
Well done, I would add Beterbiev at LHW....I hope it will be clear soon at WW (Spence, of course)....
tigermoth87
Welterweight
Posts: 1795
Joined: 21 Feb 2016, 11:23

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by tigermoth87 »

Heavyweight - Povetkin
Cruiserweight - Usyk
Light Heavy - Kovalev
Super Middleweight - Degale
Middleweight - GGG
Super Welterweight - Canelo
Welterweight - Brook
Super Lightweight - Crawford
Lightweight - Linares
Super featherweight - Lomachenko
Featherweight - Frampton
Super Bantamweight - Rigo
Bantamweight - Yamanaka

Anything below that I don't really watch.
jezzamundo
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3127
Joined: 16 Jun 2004, 13:11

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by jezzamundo »

Jip wrote:
jezzamundo wrote:HW - unclear
CW - Usyk
LHW - Kovalev/Ward
SMW - DeGale (though I think GGG would beat him)
MW - GGG
LMW - unclear
WW - unclear
LWW - Crawford
I dont follow divisions south of 140lb to comment on them.

stop with that kovalev/ward jezza, you better than that
While I think Kovalev was slightly more deserving of the decision (though I initially scored it for Ward), I still have Ward winning most of the second half of the fight and I would pick Ward to win a rematch. I don't think their fight clearly established who is better.
Mexi-Box
Welterweight
Posts: 3963
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 16:19

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by Mexi-Box »

tigermoth87 wrote:Heavyweight - Povetkin
Cruiserweight - Usyk
Light Heavy - Kovalev
Super Middleweight - Degale
Middleweight - GGG
Super Welterweight - Canelo
Welterweight - Brook
Super Lightweight - Crawford
Lightweight - Linares
Super featherweight - Lomachenko
Featherweight - Frampton
Super Bantamweight - Rigo
Bantamweight - Yamanaka

Anything below that I don't really watch.
Probably the only good list here. I'd say WW should be Pacquiao at the moment since Brook moved up.

To add

Super Flyweight - Gonzalez
Flyweight - Casimiero (or Ioka since he's moving up)
Light Flyweight - Lopez
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by Jip »

HW, LH and WW are the 4 best division in boxing and 2017 the top guys of those divisions gonne face each other.

heavyweight i am certain, also bert and kovalev should take it on this year, ww could be difficult since haymon is involed. thurman and garcia are boxing, but i dont consider danny a top 4 ww. thurman/brook and spence need to fight each other, these are the best. thurman/garcia winner against brook/spence winner would be the perfect scenario to determin the #1 ww.
Mexi-Box
Welterweight
Posts: 3963
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 16:19

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by Mexi-Box »

Jip wrote:HW, LH and WW are the 4 best division in boxing and 2017 the top guys of those divisions gonne face each other.

heavyweight i am certain, also bert and kovalev should take it on this year, ww could be difficult since haymon is involed. thurman and garcia are boxing, but i dont consider danny a top 4 ww. thurman/brook and spence need to fight each other, these are the best. thurman/garcia winner against brook/spence winner would be the perfect scenario to determin the #1 ww.
Only right on LHW, but HW and WW are pretty horrendous at the moment.

LHW, CW, and S Fly are probably the best divisions at the moment. Probably S Featherweight too.
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by Jip »

Mexi-Box wrote:
Jip wrote:HW, LH and WW are the 4 best division in boxing and 2017 the top guys of those divisions gonne face each other.

heavyweight i am certain, also bert and kovalev should take it on this year, ww could be difficult since haymon is involed. thurman and garcia are boxing, but i dont consider danny a top 4 ww. thurman/brook and spence need to fight each other, these are the best. thurman/garcia winner against brook/spence winner would be the perfect scenario to determin the #1 ww.
Only right on LHW, but HW and WW are pretty horrendous at the moment.

LHW, CW, and S Fly are probably the best divisions at the moment. Probably S Featherweight too.

u dont know what you talking about. ortiz, josh and wilder would give any atg hw a tough time. height, power and ko ratio does matter.

and how is ww horrendous when there is prime thurman, prime spence, prime garcia, prime brook, atg pacquiao, prime porter and possibly crawford moving up involved?

just stop talking nonsense
Mexi-Box
Welterweight
Posts: 3963
Joined: 24 Jan 2016, 16:19

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by Mexi-Box »

Jip wrote:
Mexi-Box wrote:
Jip wrote:HW, LH and WW are the 4 best division in boxing and 2017 the top guys of those divisions gonne face each other.

heavyweight i am certain, also bert and kovalev should take it on this year, ww could be difficult since haymon is involed. thurman and garcia are boxing, but i dont consider danny a top 4 ww. thurman/brook and spence need to fight each other, these are the best. thurman/garcia winner against brook/spence winner would be the perfect scenario to determin the #1 ww.
Only right on LHW, but HW and WW are pretty horrendous at the moment.

LHW, CW, and S Fly are probably the best divisions at the moment. Probably S Featherweight too.

u dont know what you talking about. ortiz, josh and wilder would give any atg hw a tough time. height, power and ko ratio does matter.
Oh, I didn't know I was talking to an idiot. Sorry, I thought this site might've hosted some more knowledgeable posters. I was kind of thinking you would answer me that you meant "best" as in the most exciting, but I was wrong.

I also noticed you said HW, LH, and WW are the 4 best divisions.
Jip
Super Lightweight
Posts: 2518
Joined: 04 Nov 2016, 03:30

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by Jip »

Mexi-Box wrote:
Jip wrote:
Mexi-Box wrote: Only right on LHW, but HW and WW are pretty horrendous at the moment.

LHW, CW, and S Fly are probably the best divisions at the moment. Probably S Featherweight too.

u dont know what you talking about. ortiz, josh and wilder would give any atg hw a tough time. height, power and ko ratio does matter.
Oh, I didn't know I was talking to an idiot. Sorry, I thought this site might've hosted some more knowledgeable posters. I was kind of thinking you would answer me that you meant "best" as in the most exciting, but I was wrong.

I also noticed you said HW, LH, and WW are the 4 best divisions.

oh yeah typing error big deal...have no understanding of quality of a boxer, big deal without the irony
davie
Cruiserweight
Posts: 6763
Joined: 21 Aug 2010, 00:45

Re: Year end best in every division

Post by davie »

HW Joshua
CW Usyk
LH Ward
SM Degale
MM GGG
SW Canelo
WW Thurman
SL Crawford
LW Linarez
SF Lomachenko
FW Frampton
SB Rigondeaux
BW Yamanaka
SF Gonzalez
FW Ioka
LF Lopez
MW Menayothin
Post Reply