Hatton was never a welterweight, and probably not an ATG.thechump wrote:He fought ricky hatton in his prime,coralles in his prime and undefeated,castillo twice in his prime. Most of the fighters he fought from first winning a world title were world champs or former world champs or went on to be world champs or fight for a world title, JMM went on to fight pacman and beat him,hatton won the ibf belt back,cotto went onto win the wbc middle weight title,coralles went onto be lightweight champ,berto went on to fight for the title,canelo won wbc and wbo middleweight and light middle weight title pacman won the wbo ww belt and so on and so on,floyd is obviously gonna claim to be the best but as a fan of boxing we cannot deny he is at least in the top 10 p4p list best ever?Ricky_ wrote:thechump wrote: Apart from the heavyweights of the 70's and the fab 4 who else has beaten a prime all time great? So what your saying ricky is floyd isnt all that?
Floyd's a great fighter without question but his resume is lacking for a fighter that claims to be TBE. Ward faught a prime Kovalev twice - that's more than be said for Floyd, he never faced a single elite fighter in their prime at their comfortable weight. Catchweighting Canelo really took the biscuit.
He lost to Castillo, and again, probably not an ATG.
Cotto, nobody would agree was in his prime. Canelo... too green and weight drained. Marquez fat and jumped 2 weightclasses.
Morales beat a prime Pacquaio. Ward beat a prime Kovalev. Floyd simply doesn't have a "great" win.