Byrd is utterly incompetent. She does not know the first thing about combat sports. I don't know how she keeps working.Nightmare Roy wrote:I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going onJip wrote:My simple question is, do these kind of judges like byrd get illegal extra money or are they just too stupid tocorrectly judge a fight?
Round-by-Round: Golovkin vs. Canelo 1 - September 16, 2017
-
punchoutsb
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 5842
- Joined: 16 Sep 2009, 01:05
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
I know. But is it realy criminal, like byrd getting money to score for canelo no matter what or is she just stupid.Nightmare Roy wrote:I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going onJip wrote:My simple question is, do these kind of judges like byrd get illegal extra money or are they just too stupid tocorrectly judge a fight?
-
Enlightened-One
- Super Lightweight
- Posts: 14618
- Joined: 19 Jul 2016, 05:12
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Andre Ward stops Canelo and GGG in a 164lbs catchweight bout.
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Cone on, man! You know.punchoutsb wrote:Byrd is utterly incompetent. She does not know the first thing about combat sports. I don't know how she keeps working.Nightmare Roy wrote:I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going onJip wrote:My simple question is, do these kind of judges like byrd get illegal extra money or are they just too stupid tocorrectly judge a fight?
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
BS cards are too one-sidedly in the money fighter's favourfor mere incompetence
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Agreedcrusader wrote:BS cards are too one-sidedly in the money fighter's favourfor mere incompetence
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
The worst part of this is Canelo fought really well and was very eye catching at times but it's completely overshadowed by a poor score card. He wasnt outclassed and he dealt with the power very well. I'd like to see that again even if the scorecards had have given the correct decision. Its ruined a decent fight.
Last edited by Covfefe on 17 Sep 2017, 00:42, edited 1 time in total.
-
punchoutsb
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 5842
- Joined: 16 Sep 2009, 01:05
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Tanzio wrote:Cone on, man! You know.punchoutsb wrote:Byrd is utterly incompetent. She does not know the first thing about combat sports. I don't know how she keeps working.Nightmare Roy wrote: I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going on
We all do, really
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
This is how close canelo fights go.
One ref gets bought, paid to make it 114:114, in the mayweather fight it was ross. Nonsense bevause floyd easily won. In the ggg fight it was trella who made the 114:114.
One ref gets bought, paid to make it 114:114, in the mayweather fight it was ross. Nonsense bevause floyd easily won. In the ggg fight it was trella who made the 114:114.
Last edited by Jip on 17 Sep 2017, 00:44, edited 1 time in total.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Id say the consistentcy points that she is on the take in some capacityJip wrote:I know. But is it realy criminal, like byrd getting money to score for canelo no matter what or is she just stupid.Nightmare Roy wrote:I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going onJip wrote:My simple question is, do these kind of judges like byrd get illegal extra money or are they just too stupid tocorrectly judge a fight?
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Too fvcking predictable.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
No sh!t!!?Tinnie wrote:Id say the consistentcy points that she is on the take in some capacityJip wrote:I know. But is it realy criminal, like byrd getting money to score for canelo no matter what or is she just stupid.Nightmare Roy wrote: I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going on
-
Enlightened-One
- Super Lightweight
- Posts: 14618
- Joined: 19 Jul 2016, 05:12
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Andre Ward stops Canelo and GGG in a 164lbs catchweight bout.
-
tigermoth87
- Welterweight
- Posts: 1791
- Joined: 21 Feb 2016, 11:23
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
This is why I barely watch boxing any more. Blatant corruption and constant robberies.
I used to watch any televised fight. Now it's getting to the point where I can't be bothered because I'm going to see someone get screwed over whether by crap judges, the ref stopping the fight for a nut shot or other such nonsense.
Next week it will be Parker's turn to get screwed over vs Hughie.
I used to watch any televised fight. Now it's getting to the point where I can't be bothered because I'm going to see someone get screwed over whether by crap judges, the ref stopping the fight for a nut shot or other such nonsense.
Next week it will be Parker's turn to get screwed over vs Hughie.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Of course she was paid off. The shitty thing is, because she's a woman it's twice as bad, as the age old defence would be 'they' don't know as much about boxing as men.Nightmare Roy wrote:I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going onJip wrote:My simple question is, do these kind of judges like byrd get illegal extra money or are they just too stupid tocorrectly judge a fight?
I don't agree with this, but it's s cop out. As soon as I saw BHOP whispering in that fishnet wearing, bloated cheat (ODLH), I knew GGG would get shafted.
If your home fans boo you and the result, something is clearly wrong.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Tanzio wrote:No sh!t!!?Tinnie wrote:Id say the consistentcy points that she is on the take in some capacityJip wrote:
I know. But is it realy criminal, like byrd getting money to score for canelo no matter what or is she just stupid.
ok ok half a page of responses went by before i got my reply in lol
-
punchoutsb
- Heavyweight

- Posts: 5842
- Joined: 16 Sep 2009, 01:05
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
You're putting it very mildly.Tinnie wrote:Id say the consistentcy points that she is on the take in some capacityJip wrote:I know. But is it realy criminal, like byrd getting money to score for canelo no matter what or is she just stupid.Nightmare Roy wrote: I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going on
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
That's relevant... Nobody is stopping GGG.Enlightened-One wrote:Andre Ward stops Canelo and GGG in a 164lbs catchweight bout.
Last edited by Loki on 17 Sep 2017, 00:45, edited 1 time in total.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Hopkins straight up said last night on ESPN "Golovkin needs a knockout to win"Loki wrote:Of course she was paid off. The shitty thing is, because she's a woman it's twice as bad, as the age old defence would be 'they' don't know as much about boxing as men.Nightmare Roy wrote:I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going onJip wrote:My simple question is, do these kind of judges like byrd get illegal extra money or are they just too stupid tocorrectly judge a fight?
I don't agree with this, but it's s cop out. As soon as I saw BHOP whispering in that fishnet wearing, bloated cheat (ODLH), I knew GGG would get shafted.
If your home fans boo you and the result, something is clearly wrong.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Simple. She scores it for the guy who brings in the most money. The important are happy and she keeps her job as well as any other kickback.punchoutsb wrote:Byrd is utterly incompetent. She does not know the first thing about combat sports. I don't know how she keeps working.Nightmare Roy wrote:I can't believe anyone can be that incompetent, something is going onJip wrote:My simple question is, do these kind of judges like byrd get illegal extra money or are they just too stupid tocorrectly judge a fight?
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Well perhaps her incompetence lies in her lack of subtletypunchoutsb wrote:You're putting it very mildly.Tinnie wrote:Id say the consistentcy points that she is on the take in some capacityJip wrote:
I know. But is it realy criminal, like byrd getting money to score for canelo no matter what or is she just stupid.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Let us not forget that we all knew that 3G needed a stoppage.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Guestion is: How does GGG win a rematch? Arguable that he won 11 rounds here, although I had it merely at 10, yet he still can't get it. He won't KO Canelo. How is he supposed to top that in a rematch? Answer is, he doesn't. Canelo will fight slightly better and get the decision next time out.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
If you think he won ten rounds you're almost as bad as Byrd.Blodhemn wrote:Guestion is: How does GGG win a rematch? Arguable that he won 11 rounds here, although I had it merely at 10, yet he still can't get it. He won't KO Canelo. How is he supposed to top that in a rematch? Answer is, he doesn't. Canelo will fight slightly better and get the decision next time out.
Re: 3G v GingerHead RBR
Huh?Covfefe wrote:If you think he won ten rounds you're almost as bad as Byrd.Blodhemn wrote:Guestion is: How does GGG win a rematch? Arguable that he won 11 rounds here, although I had it merely at 10, yet he still can't get it. He won't KO Canelo. How is he supposed to top that in a rematch? Answer is, he doesn't. Canelo will fight slightly better and get the decision next time out.
Canelo didn't clearly win a thing past round 3. And in most cases, he clearly LOST them.