5 Best Performances-Any Fighter

silkov · Post by **silkov** » 07 Apr 2006, 15:16

kick asner wrote:
silkov wrote:
kick asner wrote:This one is a bit of an enigma given the fact he is not an all time great but to look at his five best performences you would think that he was.

Donald Curry
1. KO 2 Milt McCrory
2. KO 1 Roger Stafford
3. W ud Marlon Starling 2
4. KO 4 Colin Jones
5. KO 2 James "Hard Rock" Green
I'd say Curry is pretty close to being an all time great... I'm rather puzzled over why the Green fight is in there as it was rather a non-event... I would have put in Currys losing efforts to either Mccallum or Nunn...
I had Green because of the early knockout, sometimes it has to do with not only the caliber of opposition but with the way the opposition is beaten. Plus I thought Green was a very underrated fighter, he put a prime Muguibi through a war before going down to defeat. Also I think you have to look at his caliber of opposition rather than his record alone. He opted to take a tough road rather than stick with easy opponents. Don't get me wrong I am not saying he's great, just a bit underrated.

But it wasn't an early ko in reality, Green turned away after catching a thumb in the eye and the ref stopped the fight... till then nothing much had happened...

Seamus · Post by **Seamus** » 07 Apr 2006, 15:26

I always liked James "Hard Rock" Green, but he should have been called James "Hard Luck" Green. He was on the verge of a 4th round stoppage against an undefeated John Mugabi, when the Beast was saved by the bell. Later the bout was stopped prematurely in the final round when Mugabi was in control. Then Green had Frank Fletcher out on his feet when the Animal get's saved by the bell. A couple rounds later Green had an eye problem and the fight was stopped with him being hammered on the ropes. And finally, he get's thumbed in the eye against Donald Curry.

kick asner · Post by **kick asner** » 07 Apr 2006, 18:08

silkov wrote:
kick asner wrote:
silkov wrote: I'd say Curry is pretty close to being an all time great... I'm rather puzzled over why the Green fight is in there as it was rather a non-event... I would have put in Currys losing efforts to either Mccallum or Nunn...
I had Green because of the early knockout, sometimes it has to do with not only the caliber of opposition but with the way the opposition is beaten. Plus I thought Green was a very underrated fighter, he put a prime Muguibi through a war before going down to defeat. Also I think you have to look at his caliber of opposition rather than his record alone. He opted to take a tough road rather than stick with easy opponents. Don't get me wrong I am not saying he's great, just a bit underrated.
But it wasn't an early ko in reality, Green turned away after catching a thumb in the eye and the ref stopped the fight... till then nothing much had happened...

Poor recollection on my part. You could then replace Green with Nino Laroca. When it came to Curry's best fights I would stick with one pre Honeygen

As far as Curry being great he was close but maybe fell a couple of fights short. He had a great first half of his career, but the second half of his career sort of mirrored Frank Bruno's.

Seamus · Post by **Seamus** » 09 Apr 2006, 12:02

NEWSBOY BROWN (and this guy isn't in the HOF)
W 10 Panama Al Brown
W 10 Midget Wolgast
W 10 Chalky Wright
W 10 Frankie Genaro (1927)
W 10 Frankie Genaro (1925)

PACKEY McFARLAND
W 10 Freddie Welsh
W 10 Jack Britton I
W 10 Owen Moran
D 20 Freddie Welsh
W 10 Jack Britton II

SUMBU KALAMBAY
W 12 Mike McCallum
W 15 Iran Barkley
W 12 Herol Graham I
KO 7 Doug DeWitt
W 12 Robbie Sims

generic screen name · Post by **generic screen name** » 12 Apr 2006, 23:18

Floyd Mayweather Jr against Arturo Gatti, Diego Corrales
Marvin Hagler against Thomas Hearns, John Mugabi
Winky Wright vs Felix Trinidad
Zab Judah (I'll give him love) vs Corey Spinks
Thomas Hearns against Roberto Duran, Cuevas, Hagler
Diego Corrales and Castillo against each other

Expug · Post by **Expug** » 12 Apr 2006, 23:49

Willie The Worm Monroe. 1 Marvin Hagler W Ud 10 ,2 Stanley Kitten Hayward ko 7 . 3 Eugene Cyclone Hart w 10 . 4 Billly Dynamite Douglass w10. 5 Angel Robinson Garcia ko 7 .

Expug · Post by **Expug** » 13 Apr 2006, 00:34

Art Golden Boy Aragon. 1 Jimmy Carter w 10. 2 Lauro Salas w 10. 3 Don Jordan W 10 . 4 Don Jordan w 10. 5 Chuck Davey w 10 .

hawaiianpunch · Post by **hawaiianpunch** » 13 Apr 2006, 03:58

Floyd Mayweather Jr.
1. Diego Corrales
2. Zab Judah
3. Arturo Gatti
4. JL Castillo 2
5. Genaro Hernandez

Roy Jones Jr.
1. James Toney
2. John Ruiz
3. Montell Griffin 2
4. Bernard Hopkins
5. Virgil Hill

Aftermath · Post by **Aftermath** » 13 Apr 2006, 13:16

RUBEN OLIVARES

1. Lionel Rose
2. Chucho Castillo III
3. Bobby Chacon I
4. Bobby Chacon II
5. Jesus Pimentel

SALVADOR SANCHEZ

1. Wilfredo Gomez
2. Danny “Little Red” Lopez I
3. Danny “Little Red” Lopez II
4. Azumah Nelson
5. Ruben Castillo

JULIO CESAR CHAVEZ

1. Edwin Rosario
2. Meldrick Taylor I
3. Roger Mayweather I
4. Roger Mayweather II
5. Hector Camacho

DoubleM · Post by **DoubleM** » 19 Apr 2006, 08:57

Marvelous Marvin Hagler

1. TKO11 Mustafa Hamsho
2. TKO3 Alan Minter
3. TKO8 Fulgencio Obelmejias
4. TKO6 Tony Sibson
5. TKO3 Thomas Hearns

Carlos Monzon

1. KO12 Nino Benvenuti
2. TKO14 Emile Griffith
3. UD15 Bennie Briscoe
4. UD15 Rodrigo Valdez (II)
5. TKO13 Jean-Claude Bouttier

Roberto Duran

1. TKO12 Esteban DeJesus
2. UD15 Ray Leonard
3. TKO13 Ken Buchanan
4. UD10 Carlos Palomino
5. SD12 Iran Barkley

RazorKO · Post by **RazorKO** » 19 Apr 2006, 09:49

walshb wrote:Quarry clean KO'd Shavers??, that must have been something. Any info on that fight?. Was Quarry a big puncher. Didn't Shavers take Ali the full distance and almost KO Holmes

Quarry didnt KO Shavers clean. I thought the stoppage was premature and the ref should of given Shavers a chance to continue, Quarry got him with a few left hooks but missed the majority of his punches and only because Quarry was swarming Shavers throwing and missing....Earnie had to go down just to get Quarry of his back. When Earnie was knocked down it wasnt because of the impact of Quarry's punches. If Shavers had a chance to recover he might of won this fight.

kick asner · Post by **kick asner** » 19 Apr 2006, 11:12

RazorKO wrote:
walshb wrote:Quarry clean KO'd Shavers??, that must have been something. Any info on that fight?. Was Quarry a big puncher. Didn't Shavers take Ali the full distance and almost KO Holmes
Quarry didnt KO Shavers clean. I thought the stoppage was premature and the ref should of given Shavers a chance to continue, Quarry got him with a few left hooks but missed the majority of his punches and only because Quarry was swarming Shavers throwing and missing....Earnie had to go down just to get Quarry of his back. When Earnie was knocked down it wasnt because of the impact of Quarry's punches. If Shavers had a chance to recover he might of won this fight.

Interesting account. Thats the first time I have heard any information on that fight and what happened as I always had wondered about it. In a case like that where a fighter gets a raw deal usually he wants to have a rematch as soon as possible. I would be curious as to why one never took place.

Seamus · Post by **Seamus** » 19 Apr 2006, 11:39

I've seen the fight a few times, they might still have it on the Quarry memorial site. Jerry just jumped all over Shavers when the bell rang, dropped him once, and was all over him again when he got up, and shortly after the ref stopped it.

RazorKO · Post by **RazorKO** » 19 Apr 2006, 11:53

kick asner wrote:
RazorKO wrote:
walshb wrote:Quarry clean KO'd Shavers??, that must have been something. Any info on that fight?. Was Quarry a big puncher. Didn't Shavers take Ali the full distance and almost KO Holmes
Quarry didnt KO Shavers clean. I thought the stoppage was premature and the ref should of given Shavers a chance to continue, Quarry got him with a few left hooks but missed the majority of his punches and only because Quarry was swarming Shavers throwing and missing....Earnie had to go down just to get Quarry of his back. When Earnie was knocked down it wasnt because of the impact of Quarry's punches. If Shavers had a chance to recover he might of won this fight.
Interesting account. Thats the first time I have heard any information on that fight and what happened as I always had wondered about it. In a case like that where a fighter gets a raw deal usually he wants to have a rematch as soon as possible. I would be curious as to why one never took place.

Im not sure either why there was no rematch. When Shavers went down as I said he went down to get Quarry of him. But when he got up Shavers just simply covered up and Quary was again swarming him. But I thought the ref stopped it way too soon but Shavers should also went out of his shell and fight back to give the impression he was OK, and I believe Shavers was able to continue.

The Great John L · Post by **The Great John L** » 19 Apr 2006, 12:15

Seamus wrote:I've seen the fight a few times, they might still have it on the Quarry memorial site. Jerry just jumped all over Shavers when the bell rang, dropped him once, and was all over him again when he got up, and shortly after the ref stopped it.

Yes, there was no reason for that fight to continue, or for a rematch. As I recall there were no complaints from Shavers, and this fight got a great deal of coverage here in NE Ohio because Shavers was our guy. He simply got beat.

Tantum · Post by **Tantum** » 19 Apr 2006, 13:30

Reggie Strickland

WTKO5 Mike Stone
W6 Chris Rosenbalm
W4 Brent Cooper
W6 Rob Bleakley
W4 Manuel Esparza

mattyp151 · Post by **mattyp151** » 19 Apr 2006, 14:10

I'm gonna bring some new school flavor into that old school hit:

Floyd Mayweather Jr.:

KO 6 Gatti
TKO 10 Corrales
UD 12 Rios
TKO Hernandez
UD 12 Sosa - weird I know, but he came out firing, fought smartly whenever Sosa got inside, and gave Sosa everything in return that Sosa gave him, and then controlled the late rounds.

rufus payne · Post by **rufus payne** » 19 Apr 2006, 16:13

Irish Micky Ward

Arturo Gatti III L UD
Arturo Gatti I MD
Emanuel Augustus UD
Shea Neary TKO 8
Reggie Green TKO 10

theone · Post by **theone** » 19 Apr 2006, 20:58

Yes, there was no reason for that fight to continue, or for a rematch. As I recall there were no complaints from Shavers, and this fight got a great deal of coverage here in NE Ohio because Shavers was our guy. He simply got beat.

I agree. Ive watched the fight many times; the stoppage seems justified to me.

jezzamundo · Post by **jezzamundo** » 20 Apr 2006, 00:02

I'll do my favourite Lewis because I never missed any of his fights:

1. Ruddock (The only fight I thought Lewis had a chance of losing)
2. Tyson
3. Golota
4. Grant
5. Tua

Also Rahman II and the way he dispatched Derek "Sweet D" Williams was very funny!

I would definitely put Rahman II in the top5, if not at number 1. I would also have Lewis-Morrison in the top5, even though Tommy clearly had no idea how to fight Lewis. I'd probably take out Golota (just got overwhelmed and blown away, much like against Brewster), and Grant (just Lewis teeing off against a guy with a poor chin, Lewis also took some punches he shouldn't have in this fight).

Arsenal · Post by **Arsenal** » 20 Apr 2006, 02:01

The reason I had Golota and Grant was the hype the fighters got because the Lewis haters were just willing anyone to beat him and he just destroyed these two. I agree about Rahman though and to be honest I didn't really like the Morrison fight.

Seamus · Post by **Seamus** » 20 Apr 2006, 16:57

TOMMY GIBBONS
W10 Harry Greb (1920)
KO 6 Kid Norfolk
KO 4 Buck Crouse
W10 Georges Carpentier
W10 Battling Levinsky

MIKE GIBBONS
W10 Jack Dillon (1915)
W10 Ted "Kid" Lewis
KO 1 Young Ahearn
W10 Eddie McGoorty
W12 George Chip

pundit · Post by **pundit** » 20 Apr 2006, 17:21

MAX SCHMELING

1. KO12 Louis I
2. KO9 Risko
3. KO15 Stribling
4. LSD15 Sharkey II
4. UD15 Paolino I

Except for the Louis KO all these fights were 1929-1932 - Schmeling's real prime.

pundit · Post by **pundit** » 20 Apr 2006, 17:25

BrocktonBlockbuster49 wrote:
joe louis best preformances

1. KO 1 max schmeling
2. KO 4 max baer
3. KO 1 buddy baer
4. TKO 8 arturo godoy
5. KO 8 James Braddock

Max Baer fought scared and with swollen hands - not sure the fight should be ranked that highly. Baer offered too little resistance.

Brockton, can you do a Sharkey please? He blew so many fights that I find it hard to get a top 5 together.

Seamus · Post by **Seamus** » 12 Jul 2006, 01:04

THE BATTLING CORBETT's

JAMES J CORBETT
KO 21 John L Sullivan
LKO 23 James J Jeffries
NC 61 Peter Jackson
KO 27 Joe Choynski
KO 3 Charley Mitchell

YOUNG CORBETT II
KO 2 Terry McGovern
KO 11 Terry McGovern
KO 11 Dave Sullivan
D 10 Benny Yanger
KO 16 Eddie Hanlon

YOUNG CORBETT III
W 10 Jackie Fields
W 10 Billy Conn
KO 5 Gus Lesnevich
W 10 Mickey Walker
W 10 Fred Apostoli

DARREN CORBETT
KO 1 Roberto Dominguez Perez
KO 2 Noel Magee
KO 3 Chris Okoh
W 12 Robert Norton
KO 5 Ray Kane