who is the biggest sinner?

[rhino222]

view the 3 options, who deserves to be 'sent to the wolves'

[paddy chavez]

carragher hands down

[wesshaw1985]

none

[mickey1975]

Carragher. The other two are just thick.

[samwbr]

They are all people who made a mistake. Every one does it.

[littlepug]

Carragher, he was in a fantastic privileged position and as such is held to a higher standard than regular folk, if your arrogant enough to not realise that then you should lose the lot.

[Heretic]

Me

[KiwiRider]

It's not that bad. If this was the US forum, the choices would be a lot more deserving of the title sinner.

[JimJim2009]

Could Adam Smith's commentary (literally any) be added as a 4th option ?

[samwbr]

Carragher, he was in a fantastic privileged position and as such is held to a higher standard than regular folk, if your arrogant enough to not realise that then you should lose the lot.

Here comes the judge

[jamamb]

carragher, had real rage and malice and was wildly out of hand going ballastic and being threatning with a young girl there

i dont think davies was making a hillsborough dig and booth imo just had a poor and tactless attempt at being 'deep'

[jamamb]

They are all people who made a mistake. Every one does it.

sure, but when someone acts a raging twat like carragher did i see 0 problem with calling it out or him getting bad press. thats very poor form whether hes a public name or not

[tobyh5]

OD did not do anything wrong. It was clearly a misunderstanding and nothing about hillsborough

[bbjc]

Tyan booth. Not only tweeted but the only one that came back and tried to justify his actions. At least carragher showed remorse and o,hara seems to be a bit of a mix up.

I blame the old man for the carragher incident anyway. Can't stand the I can do what I want attitude but as soon as someone rises I m gonna complain attitude. Would be no incident if the old man never goaded carragher. Let's stop calling it banter...its just trying to antagonize people.

[Nightmare Roy]

The bin dipper, all day!

[Oiky]

Carragher

[samwbr]

The bin dipper, all day!

Your posts on other stuff show you aren't a thick person, strange that you keep using such a ludicrous term as this.

[Nightmare Roy]

The bin dipper, all day!

Your posts on other stuff show you aren't a thick person, strange that you keep using such a ludicrous term as this.

Don't be soft, it's only bants

[fizzjambo]

All three.

If you’re a grown man you’ve got to a stage that you need to take responsibility for your own actions. All three were out of order and just have to accept what comes to them. If you f**k up then suck it up.

Adam Smith is beyond redemption for his crimes

[ILikeBeer]

Eubank Jr, for his towel comments on Twitter, considering what the family had done to Nick Blackwell and Michael Watson.

[ElJefe]

OD is just stupid, I don't think it was an intentional reference and I say that as a Liverpool fan. Carragher, although inexcusable, was heat of the moment. Tyan Booth for me was the worst because he's clearly thought through what he's going to say, said it and then tried to justify it. Don't think you can pass that off as "oh he's just thick."