RonnyJ wrote: ↑18 Mar 2020, 07:59
Enlightened-One wrote: ↑16 Mar 2020, 08:26
A fighter can be elusive due to their reflexes, even if they're lacking boxing fundamentals.
When Roy got old and started to slow down, his lack of technique became apparent.
This isn’t based on hindsight, since Bernard Hopkins and Floyd Mayweather Jr. both commented on Jones Jr’s lack of boxing fundamentals well before his demise.
Also, to be clear, I’m not undermining Roy’s legacy or remarkable in-ring performances in any way, but I do feel the main reason for his success was his fantastic athleticism, which allowed him to get away with certain things most other fighters can’t.
Unfortunately though, he existed in an era where PED testing was negligible. And he did test positive for banned substances on at least one occasion.
If you’re looking for a poster boy to represent the definifition of the word “technique”, from a boxing perspective, Roy Jones Jr. isn’t your guy, since (when he was in his prime) he used to do things that all boxing novices are taught not to do.
Regardless, the reason why Floyd Mayweather Jr. is praised for his technique, is because of he didn’t rely on his physicality to beat his foes. His success was solely built on his execution of the sweet science.
No. Floyd was very athletic and that helped mayor. When he was in his prime he was one of the most athletic boxers on earth. Even out of his prime he was still more athletic blessed with better reflexes than 98 % of all boxers.
Just watch the corrales fight, super athletic. He was born with that kind of speed and agility.
Athletic makes everything easier. Floyd of now lost his athltiscm, he still got his phenomenal technique, but with the loss of his athletiscm he would lose against todays top boxers.
I can’t believe I have to explain this, but I will do anyway.
I’m not suggesting that a fighter can keep going to the pub, drink lots of beer, eat rubbish food, do no training whatsoever… and still be successful, as long as they have skills.
Of course Floyd Mayweather Jr. was dedicated to his craft. He was super-disciplined, trained all the time and was super-fit.
I just feel that different fighters have a different mix of ingredients that contributes to their success.
For Floyd, especially at welterweight, despite being physically fit, he often faced opponents that were bigger and stronger than himself. Some might have even had better hand-speed and cardio levels. However, his skills literally paid the bills.
For Jones Jr., of course he had skills, but his main advantages over his opponents were related to his athleticism (hand-speed, power, reflexes etc.). He was a remarkable physical specimen, but his fighting style relied upon youth and speed, hence the quick decline.
All fighters need to train and be athletic to achieve success in the sport of boxing, but longevity tends to rely on traditional skills and ring IQ to allow for adaptability.