James Toney vs Bernard Hopkins

[Jeff_lacy_ko]

How does this one go?

[DrDuke]

Depends on the weight. At the MW I'd favor Toney, at the LHW I'd go with Hopkins.

[zuru]

I'd pick Toney over Hopkins at both weights.Toney at his best was magnificent.Hopkins at his best was really good.Just my thinking though.

[gilgamesh]

The match favors Hopkins more at Middleweight, he was at his very best in that weight class. Toney often struggled with the weight even when he was young, and I don't think ever got the best out of his abilities there.

I'd favor Hopkins by UD at Middleweight.

At Light Heavyweight it'd be more of a contest, and I could see either a draw or Split Decision either way.

[goose 5]

I'd take Toney at both weights, by decisive decisions.

[Woldemar]

Toney UD at 160

Toney SD or close UD at 175

[Jeff_lacy_ko]

I think at their best toney was better but bernard had a better career because of his discipline

[zuru]

I think at their best toney was better but bernard had a better career because of his discipline

You're right about discipline.If Toney had his discipline he'd probably still be a Champion.