I'm not sure why, but that is evidently NOT relevant in this conversation at all.Cap wrote: ↑01 Jun 2020, 12:46 Neven Pajkic was only 2 inches taller than Liston and nowhere near as skilled but he managed to put Tyson Fury down. If that had been Liston instead, Fury would not have gotten up.
When Liston was active there were at least 10 times as many pro boxers around as there are today. What you have now is the best of a very feeble lot.
The only thing that matters is some guys went the distance with Liston, and current guys are bigger, therefore Liston cannot win.
Liston's relative talent level has no impact on this question. Or, in the alternative, that he DOES NOT have the talent level to bridge the gap and compete is a foregone conclusion that cannot be argued. How one arrives at that when he has not competed in 2020 is beyond me, but there it is.
Any evidence that shows, SHOWS mind you, not merely suggests or infers, that a smaller fighter can hurt, knock down, and even finish a larger fighter does nothing to undermine the argument that Liston is smaller, guys went the distance, and these behemoths cannot be hurt by a smaller fighter like Liston. And, it's Sonny Liston we're discussing here, a guy who was generally thought of as being quite powerful.
But, that brings us to another rule, what someone else or even what many have said is wholly unreliable. The only thing that matters is EO's eye test which tells him that Liston is not particularly powerful. And certainly not powerful enough to do what: Cunningham, Pajkic, and David Haye among others have done. This point is obvious because of some results on Liston's boxrec page. Results can tell us a lot, unless it's Harry Greb, then it tells us nothing. It is possible, that only EO can interpret results on a boxrec page.
We all employ constant strawman and red herring arguments, but EO never does. And again, any argument that speaks to Liston's talents or what the smaller fighter has done in the ring is failing to present any argument at all about Liston possibly being competitive. Only a reference to the weight of today's fighters and Liston's decision victories makes for a compelling argument.
And, finally, anyone who says Liston could possibly compete possess neither the requisite knowledge of Liston, or any current day heavyweights, and needs to watch more boxing.
Welcome, CAP!