Middleweights : James Toney vs. Bennie Briscoe

[Woldemar]

12 rounds.Who would won?

[DrDuke]

Toney would be too fast and slick for Briscoe. Toney by UD.

[scorpio83]

Toney WUD 15 in a convincing fashion while Bad Bennie pressed the fight along the way, but Toney would counter him with jabs and combinations.

[AntonioMartin]

Toney W15...good fight through..

[Onetimeonly]

Briscoe outworks him, tight decision.

[Nile4000]

Briscoe outworks him, tight decision.

My feelings exactly.

[Seamus]

Briscoe is one of the most overrated fighters on BoxRec. He'd give Toney a good battle, but Light's Out has the better skills and his chin is just as good. Toney wins by about 4 pts.

[Onetimeonly]

Briscoe is one of the most overrated fighters on BoxRec. He'd give Toney a good battle, but Light's Out has the better skills and his chin is just as good. Toney wins by about 4 pts.

Toney is crazy overrated at 60

[gilgamesh]

Toney drained too much, and was never at his peak of physical strength as a Middleweight. He had the skills to make it close in spite of that, but the better conditioned, super tough Briscoe is gonna outwork him and take a decision win.

[BoxBuzz]

The clear winner of this fight would be anyone on earth who got to witness it.


It would be an absolute classic!

[giacomino]

Toney UD12