cases where u/you disagree with most ppl

[Offthehook]

I had Fury winning against McDermott in the first fight.

lol im still laughing at that one....furys mother didnt have him winning that....and the board nicely appointed judges following that fight for an english title....seriously though, cheers for the chuckle :)

[mickey1975]

I had Fury winning against McDermott in the first fight.

lol im still laughing at that one....furys mother didnt have him winning that....and the board nicely appointed judges following that fight for an english title....seriously though, cheers for the chuckle :)

I think the 9 fight novice should have given him an immediate rematch. Oh wait.....

[Offthehook]

I had Fury winning against McDermott in the first fight.

lol im still laughing at that one....furys mother didnt have him winning that....and the board nicely appointed judges following that fight for an english title....seriously though, cheers for the chuckle :)

I think the 9 fight novice should have given him an immediate rematch. Oh wait.....

ahh mickey mouse comments....i didnt say he was better, i didnt say about the rematch where he was sporting reyes gloves and mcdermott had bbe's...i did say he didnt win that fight....is that what youre saying? Kinda redundant comment to make really wasnt it :)

[Crease]

There are a few "unpopular opinions" of mine where I seem to be swimming against the tide...

1. Rocky Marciano BEATS Muhammad Ali
I see The Rock as an upgraded version of Joe Frazier (obviously there are differences but their styles are comparable) and I think we would punch the fight right out of Ali... Muhammad was spent against Frazier, I think The Rock takes him...

2. Manny Pacquaio ranks HIGHER than Floyd Mayweather
Pacman achieved more... Beat better fighters (arguably) and deserves to be higher ranked in the P4P list...

3. Steve Collins beats ANY version of Eubank or Benn
Yep, he beat them both twice... But he does so every day....

[margaret thatcher]

joe joyce's work rate doesnt actually seem that high to me , at least vs his good opponents jenn and dubois

i think prob with him, he has more to the skill and a bit less to the work rate than the general narrative..........he is actually surprisingly accurate despite his glacial, from the stoneages, thrown the first punch of his next fight already, slowness

[Dan Dares]

Howard Foster got it spot on in the first Froch v Groves fight.

[Counter-puncher]

Howard Foster got it spot on in the first Froch v Groves fight.

my personal, minority opinion

[emallini]

I think Haye gave Wlad a decent fight

[mickey1975]

I think Haye gave Wlad a decent fight

Mods, sort him out.

[emallini]

I think Haye gave Wlad a decent fight

Mods, sort him out.

Go away you clueless idiot

[stujones]

It seems to be going this way as memory fades -

Fury DID NOT school Wlad, it was a fight that could have gone either way - and I know most on here know this, but I sometimes feel like I need to remind people - it was a shit, shit, shit fight. It seems to have gone down as some Ali vs Cleveland Williams punch perfect beautiful clinic. Even Fury has said a few times "didn't lose a round" - yes you did Tyson - you lost a few rounds.

Whilst I don't agree with the view that Haye gave Wlad a particularly challenging night - I do though scratch my head at the credit Fury gets for a completely non committal display against Wlad and the lambasting Haye gets for his non committal display. Fury on average landed just over 1 more punch per round than Haye did. Both were pretty crap performances if you ask me. Haye threw and landed a lot more punches vs Wlad than Wlad did vs Fury - that's how negative Wlad was.

Now Fury vs Wilder 1 and 2 is a different matter.

[margaret thatcher]

haye lost widely to wlad, about 9-3 or 10-2 for me

but, i can sort of see what is meant, wlad could hardly land anything himself and basically just ended up doing a bit more of nothing. haye landed the best shot of the fight in the 12th.

so he was a bit tricky for wlad even if well beat

[lefthook82]

Had Canelo comfortably winning the 2nd GGG fight 116-112.

[margaret thatcher]

Had Canelo comfortably winning the 2nd GGG fight 116-112.

what did you have for the first?

[oogiebe]

Had Lennox beating Holy easily both times. Much wider the first fight than the latter.

[a force]

haye lost widely to wlad, about 9-3 or 10-2 for me

but, i can sort of see what is meant, wlad could hardly land anything himself and basically just ended up doing a bit more of nothing. haye landed the best shot of the fight in the 12th.

so he was a bit tricky for wlad even if well beat

I had no issue with Haye’s performance against Wlad. He was probably his own worst enemy in that he talked trash to sell PPV’s but he was never a pressure fighter so he always likely to lose nearly every round by getting out jabbed or win by stoppage if he managed to clip & hurt Wlad & follow it up.

I don’t think anyone who backed Haye to win expected him to be winning rounds & going in the front foot. It just wasn’t the way he fought.

[lefthook82]

Had Canelo comfortably winning the 2nd GGG fight 116-112.

what did you have for the first?

Didnt score. Felt GGG should have had his hand raises

[margaret thatcher]

116-113 ggg
115-113 canelo

for me

i do think if they fought again that canelo would win pretty handily though tbh, maybe even a late stoppage

[coneye]

116-113 ggg
115-113 canelo

for me

i do think if they fought again that canelo would win pretty handily though tbh, maybe even a late stoppage

Agree ,,, GGG seems to have faded ,, Age catches everyone

[Grilling Machine]

I also think Canelo'd stop G late at this point. And because I respect Golovkin I don't wanna see it. In my book he's 1-1-0, with many others seeing it 1-0-1. And that's the post-prime version.

2. Manny Pacquaio ranks HIGHER than Floyd Mayweather
Pacman achieved more... Beat better fighters (arguably) and deserves to be higher ranked in the P4P list...

3. Steve Collins beats ANY version of Eubank or Benn
Yep, he beat them both twice... But he does so every day....

I imagine there's more agreement on Pac than you think. I agree with you, at least.

Collins is debatable. Had he fought a trilogy against each when they were in their primes, my view's that he was certainly good enough to win a couple of those fights.

[Monzon83]

I rate Froch above Calslappy. Much better resume and Carl fought nearly every top fighter in his division in their prime. Didn't wait 10 years for 2 legends to age past prime before taking them on either. Funny how Joe's alleged fear of flying mysteriously disappeared once it came to fighting the 43 and 38 year olds...

Take the names Hopkins and RJJ away from Joe's record and his best wins are Kessler and the massively over-rated Lacy. Decent but hardly HOF material is it?

[Grilling Machine]

That's one of the great unknowns, where it's very arguable that Froch has the better record, but we got to see his limits.

Whereas I only feel we saw the very best of Calzaghe in glimpses. In his prime, that is. Between Brewer and Lacy there's a bit of a ghost town either side of Mitchell. I think it's very possible that his absolute prime was lost in there. I don't think he'd have had that classic with Mitchell had he been braver in his matchmaking.

[margaret thatcher]

froch obviously has more depth, but i think hopkins and prime kessler are right up there with any of froch's wins.

hoppy was old but still accomplished a lot after the fight, and kessler of course beat froch after losing to joe

[Grilling Machine]

Shame he didn't rematch Reid. Veit had a second chance. His only rematch, in fact.

[margaret thatcher]

veit got the rematch with a mandatory i think