It's a tough one alright.
Both drug cheats.
Both can rub fans the wrong way.
I dislike both. I dislike BJS more, for all the things people have already mentioned. Most recently the cracks about McGoogies deceased daughter. About as low as you thought it could go?

Terrible human being.
And the one thing I haven't read about BJS yet?
HE STINKS THE JOINT OUT!
Don't forget his last big fight against Lemieux 3 years ago, where he left our normally polite Canadian friends wanting to tear their seats out of the floor, toss them in the ring, and burn the stadium down. Want more of that?
I don't