who do you rate higher in atg list, floyd or manny ?

[Cent0089]

IMO despite Manny lost against Floyd, he did enough since then to surpass him in ATG list. What is your opinion ?

[Ruthless-RKO]

IMO despite Manny lost against Floyd, he did enough since then to surpass him in ATG list. What is your opinion ?

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

[Thomastearns]

IMO despite Manny lost against Floyd, he did enough since then to surpass him in ATG list. What is your opinion ?

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

Absolutely! Pacquiao took the risks and didn't use the prima donna cherry picking/careful matchmaking/ A Side chicanery that Floyd practically invented and Clenelo furthered in his master's wake.

It's certainly good business, and it makes financial sense for sure, but it's simply not sport.

[Thomastearns]

IMO despite Manny lost against Floyd, he did enough since then to surpass him in ATG list. What is your opinion ?

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

Absolutely! Pacquiao took the risks and didn't use the prima donna cherry picking/careful matchmaking/ A Side chicanery that Floyd practically invented and Clenelo furthered in his master's wake.

It's certainly good business - the way things seem to work in the 21st century, and it certainly makes financial sense for sure, and it might even be entertaining at times, but it's simply not sport.

It's actually a form of legalised cheating.

[DrDuke]

Still Mayweather. Even if Pac wins Spence.

[Onetimeonly]

Clearly Floyd.

[Onetimeonly]

IMO despite Manny lost against Floyd, he did enough since then to surpass him in ATG list. What is your opinion ?

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

How many guys did mAnny fight after Floyd?

[Ruthless-RKO]

IMO despite Manny lost against Floyd, he did enough since then to surpass him in ATG list. What is your opinion ?

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

How many guys did mAnny fight after Floyd?

He already fought the same calibre of opponents before they fought.

The only decent name after FM was Thurman.

[Onetimeonly]

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

How many guys did mAnny fight after Floyd?

He already fought the same calibre of opponents before they fought.

The only decent name after FM was Thurman.

I meant the same guys. They're both legends, no way Manny is higher.

[Ruthless-RKO]

How many guys did mAnny fight after Floyd?

He already fought the same calibre of opponents before they fought.

The only decent name after FM was Thurman.

I meant the same guys. They're both legends, no way Manny is higher.

Why is Floyd higher?

because he beat Manny?

[Cent0089]

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

How many guys did mAnny fight after Floyd?

He already fought the same calibre of opponents before they fought.

The only decent name after FM was Thurman.

There is also retiring of Tim Bradley and stoppage over Matthysse. Schooling Broner was fun to watch too, but that fight was Mayweather - Berto level

[Onetimeonly]

He already fought the same calibre of opponents before they fought.

The only decent name after FM was Thurman.

I meant the same guys. They're both legends, no way Manny is higher.

Why is Floyd higher?

because he beat Manny?

Yeah, and the 0 matters there. How can Manny rate higher?

[Jeff_lacy_ko]

Mayweather

Look at what he did to pac and marquez.

[ironbeard]

Manny is my vote based on overall accomplishments and contributions to boxing, and the fact that he challenged himself far more.

He isn’t fighting Andre Berto on Saturday, although it is no longer Spence.

[Onetimeonly]

Mayweather

Look at what he did to pac and marquez.

And. Canelo, he might have lost 2rounds combined

[ironbeard]

Better yet, Manny is not fighting Tenshin Masukawa, or some YouTube influencer. Lest we forget, an MMA fighter.

Marciano was great, but he was not as great as Joe Louis, Ali, and Larry Holmes.

[tiny_acres]

Mayweather

Look at what he did to pac and marquez.

And. Canelo, he might have lost 2rounds combined

X2
It's a big gap between the 2 and Mayweather is the higher rated.

[ironbeard]

Joe Calzaghe was undefeated, but he was not as great as BHop and RJJ, even though he defeated both.

[Onetimeonly]

Weak analogy.

[ironbeard]

eve before he fought Floyd.

He fought way more boxers closer to their prime as well.

How many guys did mAnny fight after Floyd?

He already fought the same calibre of opponents before they fought.

The only decent name after FM was Thurman.

I disagree. Bradley, Vargas, Matthysse, Ugas. are ALL decent opponents.

And he was clearly jobbed v Horn, who was a legit opponent at the time.

[ironbeard]

Weak analogy.

Stronger than tossing out the “0” as your argument, exponentially.

[DrDuke]

How many guys did mAnny fight after Floyd?

He already fought the same calibre of opponents before they fought.

The only decent name after FM was Thurman.

I disagree. Bradley, Vargas, Matthysse, Ugas. are ALL decent opponents.

And he was clearly jobbed v Horn, who was a legit opponent at the time.

Bradley, Vargas, Matthysse all are decent, but neither of them was among major players, when Pac defeated them. And Horn had been a well-tracked pub fighter since the start.

[Onetimeonly]

Weak analogy.

Stronger than tossing out the “0” as your argument, exponentially.

Ok

[oogiebe]

Love Paq, but Floyd is the greater all timer. The debate begins with how high on the list of ATG's is Floyd.

[Enlightened-One]

Manny Pacquiao was the tax-dodging catchweight king who was rarely willing to undergo random unannounced blood based drug testing.

He was still a great fighter though, but nostalgia often compels people to perceive blissfully ignorant about historical reality.