Jermaine Taylor versus Miguel Cotto

[goose 5]

12 rounds.

[margaret thatcher]

i think taylor could edge a decision

[emallini]

Taylor behind that jab

[Jeff_lacy_ko]

Taylor by stoppage

[Evander]

Cotto by Decision, just a better all around technician isn't he.

[dan28uk]

Cotto by Decision, just a better all around technician isn't he.

Don’t forget Taylor beat Hopkins twice and was out boxing froch before he got stopped I’d say Taylor could of definitely used his jab and best cotto late stoppage

[Evander]

Cotto by Decision, just a better all around technician isn't he.

Don’t forget Taylor beat Hopkins twice and was out boxing froch before he got stopped I’d say Taylor could of definitely used his jab and best cotto late stoppage

I didn't forget the Hopkins v Taylor fights, Jermain looked good but ...
Was that that the best Jermain Taylor ?
I remember the Froch fight too and you're right he was out boxing Froch, but he did get stopped.
Due to the fact that both fighters did their best work at different weights comes down to a style issue and I'd give Cotto the edge.
Miguel was better on the inside and a lot more strategic enough to the point where he could probably get by via a decision.

[gilgamesh]

The size advantage and the jab means Taylor ekes out a close one. Cotto is competitive enough that some may argue he deserved it.

[JCS]

Prime for prime???

Taylor too big.

[Jeff_lacy_ko]

Taylor

The best taylor fought even with hopkins and wright - thats hof level