P4P UK … Past & Present

[Spud]

Hello Forum,

Give me your P4P top 5 … past and then present

UK

Past

Lennox Lewis
Joe Calzaghe
Naz Hamed
Ricky Hatton
Nigel Benn

Present

Tyson Fury
Josh Taylor
Chris Eubank Jr
Lawrence Okolie
Conor Benn

Am I outrageously wrong?

[tiny_acres]

Where is Bob Fitzsimmons?
Jimmy Wilde?
Ken Buchannan?

Sorry your list sucks

[Spud]

Where is Bob Fitzsimmons?
Jimmy Wilde?
Ken Buchannan?

Sorry your list sucks

[cpx2]

In terms of present, I think Sunny Edwards (irritating as he is) is certainly a better boxer than Benn, Eubank Jr, or Okolie. Strong arguments could be made for a couple of the featherweights (Warrington, Leigh Wood), maybe Liam Smith, and also a couple of names at 175 (Buatsi, Callum Smith, possibly Yarde).

Think my list would be:
1. Fury
2. Taylor
3. Edwards
4. Okolie
5. Joyce

Not sure if Benn would crack the top 10 if I'm honest. Hard to say he's more accomplished than any of the above.

[Spud]

In terms of present, I think Sunny Edwards (irritating as he is) is certainly a better boxer than Benn, Eubank Jr, or Okolie. Strong arguments could be made for a couple of the featherweights (Warrington, Leigh Wood), maybe Liam Smith, and also a couple of names at 175 (Buatsi, Callum Smith, possibly Yarde).

Think my list would be:
1. Fury
2. Taylor
3. Edwards
4. Okolie
5. Joyce

Not sure if Benn would crack the top 10 if I'm honest. Hard to say he's more accomplished than any of the above.

[Spud]

I was a tadge mischievous to create debate

[tiny_acres]

I was a tadge mischievous to create debate

P4P lists are always a debate. No 2 people will ever agree

[dr_devious]

Past

Jimmy Wilde
Bob Fitzsimmons
Benny Lynch
Jim Driscoll
Lennox Lewis


Present

Tyson Fury
Josh Taylor
Sunny Edwards
Anthony Joshua
Lawrence Okolie

[fizzjambo]

Taylor
Fury
Edwards
Joshua
Okolie

No way Fury’s resume is better than Taylor’s - Taylor has as good a resume at world level as any UK fighter of the past 25 years. Lucky boy against JC but it’s a win all the same

[margaret thatcher]

taylor got a gift, sh!t judging doesn't need to be given any credibility

[Khaosai-Galaxy]

Hello Forum,

Give me your P4P top 5 … past and then present

UK

Past

Lennox Lewis
Joe Calzaghe
Naz Hamed
Ricky Hatton
Nigel Benn

Present

Tyson Fury
Josh Taylor
Chris Eubank Jr
Lawrence Okolie
Conor Benn

Am I outrageously wrong?

Yes, as per bloody usual.

Nothing changes

[Coco]

AJ?

[Spud]

I cant believe it … I am wrong

[Spud]

I must get serious …

Where do people place Joe Calzaghe in a past uk fighters p4p list

[dookus]

I must get serious …

Where do people place Joe Calzaghe in a past uk fighters p4p list

Top 5. Without hand troubles, probably would have been 1.