If they both retired today, would Anthony Joshua or Tyson Fury have the better legacy?

[paultom]

Joshua

[Lenny Cravats]

The Wilder fights haven't aged well, and Tyson could easily have been stopped in two of them.
His win against Klitschko is better, but not by much.
So its just that, really. Fury's best win is better than Joshua's. Joshua has a deeper record.

Head to head, i'd say Fury. In terms of legacy? Not so clear. Could be persuaded either way. Edging towards Fury, for the simple reason that, at the time, Wlad was just marching through everyone.

[gilgamesh]

The Wilder fights haven't aged well, and Tyson could easily have been stopped in two of them.
His win against Klitschko is better, but not by much.
So its just that, really. Fury's best win is better than Joshua's. Joshua has a deeper record.

Head to head, i'd say Fury. In terms of legacy? Not so clear. Could be persuaded either way. Edging towards Fury, for the simple reason that, at the time, Wlad was just marching through everyone.

Fury also has Chis 3x which isn't bad, and the Whyte victory to match Joshua's.

Does Joshua have any controversial stoppage in his favor because Tyson Fury had that one against some unbeaten guy Najic or something. They both had dropped each other and the referee stopped it while the other man was still very much in the fight.

[2141437]

Joshua ducked Wilder and snickers bar Andy Ruiz Jr DESTROYED Femi in America - AJ never returned, understandable when the US brand was broken for good lol. Tyson Fury all the way.

[squiggy]

I think you've got to give it to Fury.

[tigermoth87]

Fury

And it isn't even close.

[gilgamesh]

Fury

And it isn't even close.

It's very close actually.

They both have wins over Wlad which is the biggest win either of them has, and Joshua has a win over Parker who has win over Wilder.

Wilder is Fury's best win other than Wlad, and Joshua beat a guy that beat Wilder.

I think Fury has the nod, but he's only ahead by inches. If he never fights, and Joshua gets a few more noteworthy wins than Joshua overtakes him for sure.

My favorite way to settle this issue though would be just to see them fight it out, and settle it once and for all.

[joshj909]

In terms of legitimate top 10-15 wins:

Klitschko, Whyte, Wilder, Chisora

Vs

Klitschko, Povetkin, Parker, Whyte, Pulev, Ruiz

[tigermoth87]

In terms of legitimate top 10-15 wins:

Klitschko, Whyte, Wilder, Chisora

Vs

Klitschko, Povetkin, Parker, Whyte, Pulev, Ruiz

Fury beat Klitschko first.

Wilder twice when he was in his peak and not shot is a better win than anyone else on Joshua's resume.

[gregregegg]

In terms of legitimate top 10-15 wins:

Klitschko, Whyte, Wilder, Chisora

Vs

Klitschko, Povetkin, Parker, Whyte, Pulev, Ruiz

It’s pretty grim reading isn’t it.

39 year old kilt, shot Whyte, wilder who most thought was shit until he had a draw with fury so in a weird way fury going shit vs wilder helped fury’s legacey, Chisora…

Or 41 year old kilt, 39 year old pulev and povetkin, fat as fornicate Ruiz, raw novice Whyte, a stinker with Parker…

I know it’s easy to be negative… but fornicate it’s pretty indisputably shit reading.

[joshj909]

In terms of legitimate top 10-15 wins:

Klitschko, Whyte, Wilder, Chisora

Vs

Klitschko, Povetkin, Parker, Whyte, Pulev, Ruiz

Fury beat Klitschko first.

Wilder twice when he was in his peak and not shot is a better win than anyone else on Joshua's resume.

Wilder might be the worst person on either list. Peak or not

[Perkin Warbeck]

My favorite way to settle this issue though would be just to see them fight it out, and settle it once and for all.

It’s a fight I’ve wanted to see for years. Joshua has been willing (he’s been calling Fury out again lately) but Fury has avoided him.

[BroughtonRulesRefuge]

- Post Wlad where Flubber had been suspended for drug use and retired in advance of the automatic Wlad rematch, he went on an alcoholic drug fueled binge before morphing into another Big Stiff Idiot.

Picked Deyonce for his title shot, and once he regained the disgraced WBC, he ended up ducking the $150Mil 50/50 split with AJ that Eddie moved Heaven and Earth to make for a Saudi match.

Now he's a permanently Blubberized Drugged up Big Stiff Idiot that Ngannou and Usyk had the opportunity to fully expose...yeah...

[Cent0089]

Well Joshuas career is more damaged because of that KO losses. On the other side, Fury close fight with mma guy looks bad too. Both of them should try to get some solid wins before retiring IMO

[gregregegg]

Are these 2 locked in as 2/3 or 3/2 behind usyk for this era? or can parker overtake them with a couple more choice wins (he obviously could over take them if he beat usyk, but assuming parker and usyk never fight can he overtake with a few more good wins?)

[joshj909]

Are these 2 locked in as 2/3 or 3/2 behind usyk for this era? or can parker overtake them with a couple more choice wins (he obviously could over take them if he beat usyk, but assuming parker and usyk never fight can he overtake with a few more good wins?)

The Joshua/Fury era is already over. They're just the old past it guys of the division now. Parker overtaking them now would only be regarding the coming post-Usyk era.

[gregregegg]

Are these 2 locked in as 2/3 or 3/2 behind usyk for this era? or can parker overtake them with a couple more choice wins (he obviously could over take them if he beat usyk, but assuming parker and usyk never fight can he overtake with a few more good wins?)

The Joshua/Fury era is already over. They're just the old past it guys of the division now. Parker overtaking them now would only be regarding the coming post-Usyk era.

The AJ/fury era is kinda over... but parker is from that era (obviosly theresno clear way of defining eras), if parker beat wardly, DDD and kabayal for example i would consider him above fury and AJ all time (and they are from the same era).... now thats a tought streak of fights to get let alone win.... so its hypothetical.

[joshj909]

Are these 2 locked in as 2/3 or 3/2 behind usyk for this era? or can parker overtake them with a couple more choice wins (he obviously could over take them if he beat usyk, but assuming parker and usyk never fight can he overtake with a few more good wins?)

The Joshua/Fury era is already over. They're just the old past it guys of the division now. Parker overtaking them now would only be regarding the coming post-Usyk era.

The AJ/fury era is kinda over... but parker is from that era (obviosly theresno clear way of defining eras), if parker beat wardly, DDD and kabayal for example i would consider him above fury and AJ all time (and they are from the same era).... now thats a tought streak of fights to get let alone win.... so its hypothetical.

Wardley, Dubois, Kabayel, Zhang and Wilder better than Klitschko, Povetkin, Whyte and Parker? Parker also has worse unavenged losses against Whyte, Joyce and Joshua himself. Whereas Joshua avenged his against Ruiz, it's just the loss against Dubois in his twilight years.

Either way, Parker would be winning those fights when a new era has begun. He'd be the best of a different era despite having had fights in the previous era.

[Thomastearns]

Joshua clearly.

AJ beat the same opponents more convincingly, particularly Ngannou (in front of Fury who probably decided right there and then he'd never face Joshua).

Anthony Joshua never tested positive for drugs and didn't need years of persuasion in order to face Usyk.

Fury's main claim to fame, now that everyone understands that Wilder couldn't box, is the disproportionate amount of money he's cunningly harvested through a canopy of cunning lies and misinformation over the years.

[2141437]

Joshua couldn't win in America to save his life lol nor become a brand. I heard Joshua's US PPV buys against Ngannou were 4,900 lol.

Didn't Russ/Porky's corner question why isn't AJ fighting this year, hinting at a silent secret ban or maybe AJ has well and truly lost the plot. His recent IG post about Fury seems to be a distraction rather then a statement and could well be Ai created.

[DrDuke]

Fury legacy is better. He dethroned Klitschko, he defeated Wilder, against whom everybody was waiting Joshua to fight first. Fury also gave more competetive bouts to Usyk.

[paultom]

Joshua clearly.

AJ beat the same opponents more convincingly, particularly Ngannou (in front of Fury who probably decided right there and then he'd never face Joshua).

Anthony Joshua never tested positive for drugs and didn't need years of persuasion in order to face Usyk.

Fury's main claim to fame, now that everyone understands that Wilder couldn't box, is the disproportionate amount of money he's cunningly harvested through a canopy of cunning lies and misinformation over the years.

This, also Joshua wasn't on rubber legs about to be stopped by Usyk at any time and didn't get floored by or, in many peoples eyes lose to Ngannou

[DrDuke]

Joshua clearly.

AJ beat the same opponents more convincingly, particularly Ngannou (in front of Fury who probably decided right there and then he'd never face Joshua).

Anthony Joshua never tested positive for drugs and didn't need years of persuasion in order to face Usyk.

Fury's main claim to fame, now that everyone understands that Wilder couldn't box, is the disproportionate amount of money he's cunningly harvested through a canopy of cunning lies and misinformation over the years.

This, also Joshua wasn't on rubber legs about to be stopped by Usyk at any time and didn't get floored by or, in many peoples eyes lose to Ngannou

Joshua also didn't win as many rounds vs Usyk as Fury did, and he didn't hurt Usyk the same much.

[paultom]

Joshua clearly.

AJ beat the same opponents more convincingly, particularly Ngannou (in front of Fury who probably decided right there and then he'd never face Joshua).

Anthony Joshua never tested positive for drugs and didn't need years of persuasion in order to face Usyk.

Fury's main claim to fame, now that everyone understands that Wilder couldn't box, is the disproportionate amount of money he's cunningly harvested through a canopy of cunning lies and misinformation over the years.

This, also Joshua wasn't on rubber legs about to be stopped by Usyk at any time and didn't get floored by or, in many peoples eyes lose to Ngannou

Joshua also didn't win as many rounds vs Usyk as Fury did, and he didn't hurt Usyk the same much.

did in the second fight, whereas Fury lost more clearly second time round