James Toney vs Carmen Basilio

[Nile4000]

15/160, who wins?

[gilgamesh]

It's hard to imagine the weight drained Middleweight Toney beating any fighter with a bottomless pit of stamina.

Basilio UD

[goose 5]

Toney of the first Mccallum bout wasn't weight drained.

[gilgamesh]

True, but Middleweight Toney was never the best Toney to me. That being said he still may have been good enough to beat Basilio. It'd be close either way.

[elmersalsa]

It would be a war. A terrific fight. James "Lights Out" Toney by split decision. He had much more to his game. Better ring generalship. A complete fighter.