Post Your Scorecards

[Casablanca]

Tony Tucker vs. Buster Douglas (5-30-1987)

R1: 10-9 Douglas
R2: 10-9 Douglas
R3: 10-9 Douglas
R4: 10-9 Tucker
R5: 10-9 Douglas
R6: 10-9 Douglas
R7: 10-9 Tucker
R8: 10-9 Tucker
R9: 10-9 Douglas
R10: Tucker wins by TKO

Mike Tyson vs. Pinklon Thomas (5-30-1987)

R1: 10-9 Tyson
R2: 10-9 Tyson
R3: 10-9 Thomas
R4: 10-9 Thomas
R5: 10-9 Thomas
R6: Tyson wins by TKO

[Ambling Alp II]

Was rooting for Thomas, but don't think I gave him more than one round. Never heard of anyone having Thomas ahead. Some people had it a shutout for Tyson. Having said that, most of the rounds were competitive. Some fights are like that. A lot of competitive rounds, but the same guy is winning most or all of them.

[Casablanca]

Jimmy Young showed up significantly out of shape for his fight with Ocasio and he got off to a very slow start. By coming on over the second half of the fight and taking almost the entire second half of the fight on my card, Young narrowly stole on a win on my card, but the judges, by split decision, gave the fight to Ocasio.

Jimmy Young vs. Ossie Ocasio (6-08-1978)

R1: 10-9 Young
R2: 10-9 Ocasio
R3: 10-9 Ocasio
R4: 10-9 Ocasio
R5: 10-9 Ocasio
R6: 10-9 Young
R7: 10-9 Young
R8: 10-9 Young
R9: 10-10 Even
R10: 10-9 Young

96-95 Young

What a fight for the Heavyweight Championship of the World. Holmes just got out to too great a lead for Norton to claw it all the way back, but from round eight onwards the fight was an absolute war. My card ended up coming out a bit wider than the judges cards did.

Ken Norton vs. Larry Holmes (6-08-1978)

R1: 10-9 Norton
R2: 10-9 Holmes
R3: 10-9 Holmes
R4: 10-9 Holmes
R5: 10-9 Holmes
R6: 10-9 Holmes
R7: 10-9 Holmes
R8: 10-9 Norton
R9: 10-10 Even
R10: 10-9 Holmes
R11: 10-9 Norton
R12: 10-9 Holmes
R13: 10-9 Holmes
R14: 10-9 Norton
R15: 10-9 Norton

145-141 Holmes

[gilgamesh]

Miguel Cotto vs Shane Mosley

1. Mosley *
2. Cotto
3. Mosley
4. Cotto
5. Cotto
6. Cotto
7. Mosley
8. Cotto
9. Mosley
10. Mosley
11. Cotto
12. Cotto

115-113 Miguel Cotto

Good, Competitive fight. Mosley fans have nothing to be ashamed of here, he gave a world class effort in defeat.

[Casablanca]

In an amazing development, the site Eye on the Ring is again back up and operational. I had contacted the owner and informed him that the site was down. Maybe that had an impact. Let me post several of my scorecards here for fights which I have not scored here on Boxrec from there. I was user "TryingtoPlay" on Eye on the Ring. Here is one.

Oscar De La Hoya vs. Felix Trinidad (9-18-1999)

R1: 10-9 Trinidad
R2: 10-9 Trinidad
R3: 10-9 De La Hoya
R4: 10-9 De La Hoya
R5: 10-9 Trinidad
R6: 10-9 De La Hoya
R7: 10-9 De La Hoya
R8: 10-9 De La Hoya
R9: 10-9 De La Hoya
R10: 10-9 Trinidad
R11: 10-9 Trinidad
R12: 10-9 Trinidad

114-114 Even

I am going to add the first two Pacquiao-Marquez fights to my previous post in which I scored the third and fourth fights from their iconic series.
*They have been added to that previous post.

[Seamus]

Exactly what I scored it the second time. Live I had Tito winning 115-114. Harold Lederman said it was an easy fight to score 6-6. Still we had guys here claiming it was an outrageous robbery, and while Oscar admitted he lost the last 4 rds, he claimed he won the first 8.

[Casablanca]

Exactly what I scored it the second time. Live I had Tito winning 115-114. Harold Lederman said it was an easy fight to score 6-6. Still we had guys here claiming it was an outrageous robbery, and while Oscar admitted he lost the last 4 rds, he claimed he won the first 8.

Yeah, it certainly wasn’t a robbery. It was an extremely close fight and De La Hoya himself is in no small part responsible for what happened in the way he fought the last several rounds of the fight.

Eye on the Ring appears to have blown up again already. I am sure that it will be back up again soon, but they are probably struggling with user flow and have insufficient storage space for newly posted scores, or something.

[gilgamesh]

Exactly what I scored it the second time. Live I had Tito winning 115-114. Harold Lederman said it was an easy fight to score 6-6. Still we had guys here claiming it was an outrageous robbery, and while Oscar admitted he lost the last 4 rds, he claimed he won the first 8.

Yeah, it certainly wasn’t a robbery. It was an extremely close fight and De La Hoya himself is in no small part responsible for what happened in the way he fought the last several rounds of the fight.

Eye on the Ring appears to have blown up again already. I am sure that it will be back up again soon, but they are probably struggling with user flow and have insufficient storage space for newly posted scores, or something.

I'm pretty sure I had the same score of 114-114 in Tito vs De La Hoya. I remember thinking Tito did reasonably well in the early rounds as well.

The narrative that De La Hoya had completely controlled the fight until the last 3 rounds is false.

[Casablanca]

Eye on the Ring is coming and going at the moment. Here is another of my cards which I just took from there. The fabled Heavyweight Championship fight between Max Baer and Jimmy Braddock.

Max Baer vs. Jimmy Braddock (6-13-1935)

R1: 10-9 Braddock
R2: 10-9 Braddock
R3: 10-9 Braddock
R4: 10-9 Baer
R5: 10-9 Baer
R6: 10-9 Braddock
R7: 10-9 Baer
R8: 10-9 Braddock
R9: 10-9 Braddock
R10: 10-9 Braddock
R11: 10-9 Baer
R12: 10-9 Baer
R13: 10-9 Braddock
R14: 10-9 Baer
R15: 10-9 Baer

143-142 Braddock

[Casablanca]

And another for you guys from Eye on the Ring:

Mike Tyson vs. James 'Buster' Douglas (2-11-1990)

R1: 10-9 Douglas
R2: 10-9 Douglas
R3: 10-9 Douglas
R4: 10-9 Douglas
R5: 10-9 Douglas
R6: 10-9 Tyson
R7: 10-9 Douglas
R8: 10-8 Tyson (knockdown)
R9: 10-9 Douglas
R10: Douglas wins by Knockout

That is 87-83 at the time of the stoppage.

[Casablanca]

And two more from Eye on the Ring:

Floyd Mayweather vs. Marcos Maidana I (5-03-2014)

R1: 10-9 Maidana
R2: 10-9 Maidana
R3: 10-9 Mayweather
R4: 10-9 Maidana
R5: 10-9 Maidana
R6: 10-9 Maidana
R7: 10-9 Mayweather
R8: 10-9 Mayweather
R9: 10-9 Mayweather
R10: 10-9 Mayweather
R11: 10-9 Mayweather
R12: 10-9 Maidana

114-114 Even

Floyd Mayweather vs. Marcos Maidana II (9-13-2014)

R1: 10-9 Mayweather
R2: 10-9 Mayweather
R3: 10-9 Mayweather
R4: 10-9 Maidana
R5: 10-9 Mayweather
R6: 10-9 Mayweather
R7: 10-9 Mayweather
R8: 10-9 Mayweather
R9: 10-9 Mayweather'
R10: 10-9 Maidana
R11: 10-9 Mayweather
R12: 10-9 Maidana

117-111 Mayweather

[Casablanca]

Exactly what I scored it the second time. Live I had Tito winning 115-114. Harold Lederman said it was an easy fight to score 6-6. Still we had guys here claiming it was an outrageous robbery, and while Oscar admitted he lost the last 4 rds, he claimed he won the first 8.

Yeah, it certainly wasn’t a robbery. It was an extremely close fight and De La Hoya himself is in no small part responsible for what happened in the way he fought the last several rounds of the fight.

Eye on the Ring appears to have blown up again already. I am sure that it will be back up again soon, but they are probably struggling with user flow and have insufficient storage space for newly posted scores, or something.

I'm pretty sure I had the same score of 114-114 in Tito vs De La Hoya. I remember thinking Tito did reasonably well in the early rounds as well.

The narrative that De La Hoya had completely controlled the fight until the last 3 rounds is false.

Agreed.

Trinidad took several early rounds before De La Hoya really began to take control of the fight into the middle rounds.

[goose 5]

I had it 115-113 De La Hoya watching it live; 114-114 watching it on replay.

[Casablanca]

Eye on the Ring only had pages for the first two fights between Tyson Fury and Deontay Wilder. Here were my scores for each:

Deontay Wilder vs. Tyson Fury I (12-01-2018)

R1: 10-9 Wilder
R2: 10-9 Fury
R3: 10-9 Fury
R4: 10-9 Fury
R5: 10-9 Fury
R6: 10-9 Wilder
R7: 10-9 Fury
R8: 10-9 Fury
R9: 10-8 Wilder (knockdown)
R10: 10-9 Fury
R11: 10-9 Fury
R12: 10-8 Wilder (knockdown)

114-112 Fury

Deontay Wilder vs. Tyson Fury II (2-22-2020)

R1: 10-9 Fury
R2: 10-9 Wilder
R3: 10-8 Fury (knockdown)
R4: 10-9 Fury
R5: 9-8 Fury (knockdown; pt deduction to Fury for holding and hitting on the break)
R6: 10-9 Fury
R7: Fury wins by TKO

[Ambling Alp II]

Fury did virtually nothing round after round. He seemed to be saving his energy for raising his hands almost every time after the bell ended the round as if he actually did something great.

Wish I had my scorecard handy. There were several rounds that were very close simply because neither guy did anything. Taking out the two rounds where he got decked, that leaves just 10 rounds. Giving Fury 8 of the 10 to Fury is being very charitable to him. fury was very fortunate to get a draw here. You could make a case that this was worst heavyweight title fight of all time.

[Casablanca]

Fury did virtually nothing round after round. He seemed to be saving his energy for raising his hands almost every time after the bell ended the round as if he actually did something great.

Wish I had my scorecard handy. There were several rounds that were very close simply because neither guy did anything. Taking out the two rounds where he got decked, that leaves just 10 rounds. Giving Fury 8 of the 10 to Fury is being very charitable to him. fury was very fortunate to get a draw here. You could make a case that this was worst heavyweight title fight of all time.

I have scored this fight twice. One of them is the card above. The other time I scored it 113-113 Even. The above was the first of the two and goes up there as a result (and I have the card from Eye on the Ring).

I call them as I see them brother.

[Casablanca]

Moses Itauma vs. Jermaine Franklin (3-28-2026)

R1: 10-9 Itauma
R2: 10-9 Itauma
R3: 10-8 Itauma (knockdown)
R4: 10-9 Itauma
R5: Itauma wins by Knockout

That was an immensely impressive performance. I posted a link to the fight in the thread for the fight.

[witherspoon]

Moses Itauma vs. Jermaine Franklin (3-28-2026)

R1: 10-9 Itauma
R2: 10-9 Itauma
R3: 10-8 Itauma (knockdown)
R4: 10-9 Itauma
R5: Itauma wins by Knockout

That was an immensely impressive performance. I posted a link to the fight in the thread for the fight.

I agree, very exciting young fighter. If I were Oleksander Usyk I'd be trying to make this fight as soon as possible. Moses looks like he has a good head on his shoulders and will improve rapidly if he is matched competitively.

[witherspoon]

Humberto Gonzalez v Michael Carbajal 1

R 1 10-9 HG
R2 10-8 HG
R3 9-10 MC
R4 10-10
R5 10-8 HG
R6 10-9 HG

59-54 HG

Another fight that I missed out on all those years ago. I'd forgotten how much I used to enjoy watching these two in the early days of Sky TV in the UK, on Eurosport and Screensport.

I don't usually score fights with the commentary on but as soon as I heard Al Bernsteins voice I knew that I wouldn't be turning the volume down. This was one of the most enjoyably nostalgic fights I've watched.

I only vaguely remember the result so I was kind of shocked at the finish. I really don't want to say more than that, I feel like I'd be spoiling a brilliant fight for any potential scorers who intend to watch this

[Casablanca]

Humberto Gonzalez v Michael Carbajal 1

R 1 10-9 HG
R2 10-8 HG
R3 9-10 MC
R4 10-10
R5 10-8 HG
R6 10-9 HG

59-54 HG

Another fight that I missed out on all those years ago. I'd forgotten how much I used to enjoy watching these two in the early days of Sky TV in the UK, on Eurosport and Screensport.

I don't usually score fights with the commentary on but as soon as I heard Al Bernsteins voice I knew that I wouldn't be turning the volume down. This was one of the most enjoyably nostalgic fights I've watched.

I only vaguely remember the result so I was kind of shocked at the finish. I really don't want to say more than that, I feel like I'd be spoiling a brilliant fight for any potential scorers who intend to watch this

It is now on my list of fights to check out.

[Ambling Alp II]

I had it 115-113 De La Hoya watching it live; 114-114 watching it on replay.

I had it 115-113 for De La Hoya. Often when a fight is that close, I can see where other had it differently. But not this one. There were not many close rounds. I had De La Hoya up winning 7 of the first 9 rounds, without much question. He was simply outboxing Trinidad. Then he stopped doing anything offensively the last three rounds and you had to give those rounds to Trinidad.
A lot of the blame should go to Gil Clancy, who was De La hoya's chief second. Clancy told him that he had the fight won and not to take any chances in the last three rounds. Clancy had been in the sport for a long time and should have known better than to tell him that.

[Casablanca]

Jake Lamotta vs. Sugar Ray Robinson VI (2-14-1951)

R1: 10-9 Lamotta
R2: 10-9 Robinson
R3: 10-9 Robinson
R4: 10-9 Robinson
R5: 10-9 Lamotta
R6: 10-9 Robinson
R7: 10-9 Robinson
R8: 10-9 Lamotta
R9: 10-9 Robinson
R10: 10-9 Robinson
R11: 10-9 Robinson
R12: 10-9 Robinson
R13: Robinson wins by TKO

The famous sixth meeting between Lamotta and Robinson, in this fight fighting for the Middleweight Championship of the World. Robinson had obviously moved up from Welterweight to Middleweight in order to challenge for the Middleweight title and this was their famous final meeting for the Middleweight Championship of the World which Lamotta had won in ‘49 against Marcel Cerdan and had subsequently successfully defended prior to this fight against Robinson.

It was a competitive and tough fight through the first eight rounds, but Robinson ultimately took over the fight and began to really dominate the action. Had I been the referee I would have stopped the fight in the 12th round and I am very confident that today the fight would have been stopped at some point in that round and rightly so. A brilliant performance from Robinson.

[Casablanca]

Humberto Gonzalez v Michael Carbajal 1

R 1 10-9 HG
R2 10-8 HG
R3 9-10 MC
R4 10-10
R5 10-8 HG
R6 10-9 HG

59-54 HG

Another fight that I missed out on all those years ago. I'd forgotten how much I used to enjoy watching these two in the early days of Sky TV in the UK, on Eurosport and Screensport.

I don't usually score fights with the commentary on but as soon as I heard Al Bernsteins voice I knew that I wouldn't be turning the volume down. This was one of the most enjoyably nostalgic fights I've watched.

I only vaguely remember the result so I was kind of shocked at the finish. I really don't want to say more than that, I feel like I'd be spoiling a brilliant fight for any potential scorers who intend to watch this

I just watched it. What a vicious fight between two huge punchers for their weight level. Here was my card:

Humberto Gonzalez vs. Michael Carbajal I (3-13-1993)

R1: 10-9 Gonzalez
R2: 10-8 Gonzalez (knockdown)
R3: 10-9 Gonzalez
R4: 10-9 Carbajal
R5: 10-8 Gonzalez (knockdown)
R6: 10-9 Carbajal
R7: Carbajal wins by Knockout

[witherspoon]

I just watched it. What a vicious fight between two huge punchers for their weight level. Here was my card:

Humberto Gonzalez vs. Michael Carbajal I (3-13-1993)

R1: 10-9 Gonzalez
R2: 10-8 Gonzalez (knockdown)
R3: 10-9 Gonzalez
R4: 10-9 Carbajal
R5: 10-8 Gonzalez (knockdown)
R6: 10-9 Carbajal
R7: Carbajal wins by Knockout

That fifth round was a roller coaster. Gonzalez was looking like he'd sealed the deal, with a heavy early knockdown. By the midway point I was starting to wonder if he would win the round at all. Probably the closest 10-8 round I've ever seen.

[gilgamesh]

James Toney vs Samuel Peter 2

1. Peter
2. Peter 10-8
3. Toney
4. Toney *
5. Peter
6. Peter
7. Peter
8. Peter
9. Peter
10. Peter
11. Peter
12. Peter

118-109 Peter

I may even be being generous to Toney to give him that 4th round (not that it makes a difference). He was dominated in this one.