How would you rate Marciano if Tiger Ted Lowry got the decision?

[gilgamesh]

I properly see the dubious "Draw" Whitaker fought with Chavez as what it really was, Whitaker dominating the great Chavez. I don't give a f*ck what the judges said.

My eyes ain't lying to me when I see Whitaker outbox the sh*t out of him.

[Ambling Alp II]

I’d probably rank him the same actually.
Lowry was a tough journeyman who fought everyone.
He was only stopped a couple times in about 150 fights. It would be a learning experience if Tiger got the nod and Rocky came back and beat him more decisively in their rematch.
I might actually look at him more positively if it happened that way.
I’m always skeptical of glossy undefeated records anyhow.

As you should be!

I would rank him the same. He was in the still improving phase. Had he lost badly maybe a little. Have him just inside the top 10. (Could be a little higher) after Ali and Louis, there are several guys that are close.

[Ezzard]

I’d probably rank him the same actually.
Lowry was a tough journeyman who fought everyone.
He was only stopped a couple times in about 150 fights. It would be a learning experience if Tiger got the nod and Rocky came back and beat him more decisively in their rematch.
I might actually look at him more positively if it happened that way.
I’m always skeptical of glossy undefeated records anyhow.

same

[Ambling Alp II]